Book 17: 《陽貨》 Yang Huo
《陽貨》 Passage 17.10
Legge Translation (1861)
The Master said to Boyu: "Do you give yourself to the Zhou-nan and the Shao-nan. The man who has not studied the Zhou-nan and the Shao-nan, is like one who stands with his face right against a wall. Is he not so?"Word by word
- 子 zǐ
Confucius, the Master
- 謂…曰 wèi … yuē
said to, addressed
- 謂 to say to, address (someone)
- 曰 said, spoke (introduces a direct quotation)
謂 (address) and 曰 (say) jointly form the standard frame introducing direct speech; all eight translators render the pair as a single verb phrase.
- 伯魚 bó yú
Boyu, courtesy name of Confucius's son Kong Li
- 伯 eldest (component of the name Boyu, Confucius's son)
- 魚 fish (component of the name Boyu, Confucius's son)
- 女 rǔ
you (second-person pronoun)
- 為 wéi
to work at, study, master, apply oneself to
- 周南 zhōu nán
Zhounan, 'Odes of the South of Zhou' (opening section of the Book of Odes)
- 周 Zhou (dynasty name, first element of the title Zhounan)
- 南 south (second element of the title Zhounan, 'South of Zhou')
- 召南 shào nán
Shaonan, 'Odes of the South of Shao' (second opening section of the Book of Odes)
- 召 Shao (place name, first element of the title Shaonan)
- 南 south (second element of the title Shaonan, 'South of Shao')
召 is read shào, the name of the Shao domain (朱熹: 召,音邵), not zhào, to summon; the same at [31,32].
- 矣乎 yǐ hū
perfective + interrogative particles: completed-action question marker
- 矣 perfective particle marking a completed or realized action
- 乎 interrogative final particle
- 人 rén
a person, someone, a man
- 而 ér
conditional particle: if
- 不 bù
not
- 為 wéi
to work at, study, master, apply oneself to
- 周南 zhōu nán
Zhounan, 'Odes of the South of Zhou' (opening section of the Book of Odes)
- 周 Zhou (dynasty name, first element of the title Zhounan)
- 南 south (second element of the title Zhounan, 'South of Zhou')
- 召南 shào nán
Shaonan, 'Odes of the South of Shao' (second opening section of the Book of Odes)
- 召 Shao (place name, first element of the title Shaonan)
- 南 south (second element of the title Shaonan, 'South of Shao')
- 其 qí
he, they (referring back to the person just described)
- 猶 yóu
to be like, similar to
- 正 zhèng
correctly, directly, straight-on
- 牆 qiáng
wall
- 面 miàn
face (of a person)
- 而 ér
conjunctive particle: and, linking two sequential actions
Translators uniformly render this with a participial 'with' phrase ('stands with his face to the wall') rather than an explicit 'and', so no rendering is quoted.
- 立 lì
to stand
- 也與 yě yú
sentence-final particles forming a rhetorical question: is it not so?
- 也 final particle paired with the following 與/哉 in a question
- 與 interrogative final particle expressing a rhetorical question
也與 (也歟) marks a rhetorical question expecting agreement; Legge and Slingerland render it as an explicit tag question, Peimin Ni folds its force into 'wouldn't', and the rest end the sentence with a period, dropping the marker.
A text file for Anki 2.1.55 or later: File → Import. The cards go to the deck “Analects”, tagged by passage, and importing again updates them instead of adding copies.
Discussion
No one has started on this passage yet.
Start the discussion in r/analects