論語The Analects of Confucius

論語The Analects of Confucius

Book 3: 《八佾》 Ba Yi (Eight Rows)

《八佾》 Passage 3.11

或問禘之說。子曰:「不知也。知其說者之於天下也,其如示諸斯乎!」指其掌。

Legge Translation (1861)

Some one asked the meaning of the great sacrifice. The Master said: "I do not know. He who knew its meaning would find it as easy to govern the kingdom as to look on this"; — pointing to his palm.
Word by word 18 terms · glosses and Anki cards
  1. 或 huò

    someone, some person (indefinite pronoun)

  2. 問 wèn

    to ask about, inquire

  3. 禘 dì

    the di sacrifice, a grand royal rite honoring a dynasty's founding ancestors

    Roberts and Watson use broader interpretive glosses ('First Founders service', 'the ancestral sacrifice'), reflecting scholarly uncertainty over exactly which rite is meant

  4. 之 zhī

    possessive/attributive particle: 's, of

  5. 說 shuō

    explanation, account, theory (of a rite)

    noun sense here, not the verb 'to speak'

  6. 子曰 zǐ yuē

    the Master said

    • 子 the Master, Confucius
    • 曰 said, spoke
  7. 不…也 bù … yě

    negation with assertive final particle: it is not the case that..., do not

    • 不 not
    • 也 final particle marking assertion or emphasis

    也 marks the negation as a categorical assertion; Lau and Chin render this literally as 'is/is not something that...'

  8. 知 zhī

    to know, understand

  9. 知…者 zhī … zhě

    nominalizing frame: the one who knows/understands (something)

    • 知 to know, understand
    • 者 nominalizing particle: one who, the one who
  10. 其 qí

    its, referring back to the sacrifice's meaning

  11. 說 shuō

    explanation, account

  12. 之於…也 zhī yú … yě

    topic-comment frame: as for X in relation to Y

    • 之 particle marking the preceding clause as topic
    • 於 coverb: in regard to, concerning, at
    • 也 final particle marking assertion or topical pause

    The classical 之於…也 pattern, setting up 'as for his relation to the world'.

  13. 天下 tiān xià

    all under heaven, the world, the realm

    • 天 heaven, sky
    • 下 below, under
  14. 其…乎 qí … hū

    rhetorical/modal frame: would it not be that...?, expressing hypothetical certainty

    • 其 modal particle introducing a rhetorical question: would it be...?
    • 乎 interrogative or exclamatory final particle
  15. 如示諸斯 rú shì zhū sī

    as if showing/having it right here, idiom for effortless mastery

    • 如 as if, like, as though
    • 示 to show, display, manifest
    • 諸 fusion particle: it + at, to (= 之於)
    • 斯 this, here

    包咸 reads 示 as to point out and show, as if the world lay in one's palm; 朱熹 reads 示 as 視, to look at, which Legge follows ('as to look on this').

  16. 指 zhǐ

    to point at, indicate

  17. 其 qí

    his, referring to Confucius

  18. 掌 zhǎng

    palm of the hand

A text file for Anki 2.1.55 or later: File → Import. The cards go to the deck “Analects”, tagged by passage, and importing again updates them instead of adding copies.

Discussion

No one has started on this passage yet.

Start the discussion in r/analects
智 天命

Settings

Reading profiles
Characters 繁 简
Text size
100%
Theme
Colour scheme
Superdim Lights-out reading: true black, everything barely lit
Font
Adjust
Reading Order, pinyin
Order
Show Pinyin 拼
Tone colours How the 聲 toggle paints
Mode:
Reader mode How pages turn