History · Ming
讀史訂疑 Dú Shǐ Dìng Yí
Settling Doubts in Reading History
A one-juan notebook of textual notes, probably 王世懋 Wáng Shìmào's. The 四庫 Sì Kù catalogue lists his book of this title and observes that despite its title not all of it is about history. It is quoted at 5.2 on whether 南容 Nán Róng is 南宮敬叔 Nángōng Jìngshū. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against kind: Histories"Histories" is acceptable. The earlier checkers noted that 讀史訂疑 ("Settling Doubts in Reading History") is a notebook that isn't only about history. However, the Siku catalogue files it under historical criticism, and it is quoted at 5.2 on a historical identification. I agree with the fixer.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026Concern · minor ResolvedChecked against the kind against taxonomy.kinds, from my own knowledge of the work"Histories" is defensible from the title 讀史訂疑 ("Settling Doubts in Reading History"), but the line says it is a notebook that isn't all about history, so "Philosophers and miscellanies" fits better.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026Concern · minor Second opinion ResolvedChecked against the kind against taxonomy.kinds, from my own knowledge of the work"Histories" is defensible, because the 四庫 catalogue files 讀史訂疑 ("Settling Doubts in Reading History") with the critiques of history. But the record says it is a notebook of textual notes, not all on history, and it is quoted on an identification of a person. "Dictionaries and philology", which covers evidential notebooks, could fit it equally well.Earlier versions · changed since validatedClaude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026Confirmed Second opinionChecked against 論語集釋 5.2; own knowledge (四庫全書總目 存目)At 5.2 the source quotes 讀史訂疑:南宮适非敬叔 ("Nangong Kuo is not Jingshu") in the discussion of 南容. The 四庫 存目 lists a one-juan 讀史訂疑 by Wang Shimao (Wáng Shìmào), and the line keeps "probably" because the 集釋 doesn't name the author.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026Concern · minor ResolvedChecked against own knowledgeWáng Shìmào's one-juan 讀史訂疑 ("Settling Doubts in Reading History") and the 四庫 remark that not all of it is history fit what I know. I couldn't verify that it is quoted at 5.2 on whether Nán Róng is Nángōng Jìngshū.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026Concern · minor Second opinion ResolvedChecked against own knowledgeThe 四庫 存目 lists a one-juan 讀史訂疑 ("Settling Doubts in Reading History") by Wáng Shìmào (王世懋), so the identity holds. I couldn't verify that it is quoted at 5.2 on Nán Róng, because I don't have that passage's source.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledge; 論語集釋 5.2At 5.2 the 集釋 quotes 讀史訂疑 with 4 doubts that 南宮适 (Nángōng Kuò) is 南宮敬叔 (Nángōng Jìngshū). The Siku catalogue lists a one-juan 讀史訂疑 by the Ming author 王世懋 (Wáng Shìmào), and the line hedges the attribution appropriately.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026Concern · minorChecked against own knowledge; web search (no hit)The item hedges the attribution to 王世懋 (Wáng Shìmào) with "probably". I couldn't confirm that the 四庫 catalogue lists only his book of this title, or what it says about the contents.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026Concern · minor Second opinionChecked against own knowledge; web search (no hit)I believe a 1-juan 讀史訂疑 ("settling doubts in reading history") by 王世懋 (Wáng Shìmào) does exist. I couldn't confirm that it is the only book of the title in the 四庫 catalogue, or that the catalogue says it isn't all about history.How this was made
Histories · Named in 1 passage, always in the disputes.
In 1 passage
Each row is a dispute or note that names 讀史訂疑. It opens the passage on it.
公冶長 Book 5 · Gōngyě Cháng 1
Connected
Named in this entry