Dao De Jing Chapter 41 同異 tóng yì
“Sameness in Difference”, Carus's rendering of the 河上公 title
- Deep divide Choosing a camp changes what the saying teaches.
- Minor split The camps take the words differently, but the point holds.
- Outlier One camp, with an outlier reading against it.
Readings that end up saying the same thing are grouped in a camp. Each reading keeps its letter, oldest first: . The filled letter, , marks the reading this site's word definitions follow.
Legge Scholars of the highest class, when they hear about the Tao, earnestly carry it into practice. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 1, Legge's translation上士 ("superior scholar") is paired with "Scholars of the highest class", 聞道 ("hear the Way") with "hear about the Tao", 勤 ("diligent") with "earnestly" and 行 ("practise") with "carry … into practice".How this was made Scholars of the middle class, when they have heard about it, seem now to keep it and now to lose it. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 2, Legge's translation中士 ("middling scholar") is paired with "Scholars of the middle class" and 若存若亡 ("as if keeping, as if losing") with "seem now to keep it and now to lose it".How this was made Scholars of the lowest class, when they have heard about it, laugh greatly at it. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 3, Legge's translation下士 ("lowest scholar") is paired with "Scholars of the lowest class", 大笑 ("laugh loudly") with "laugh greatly" and 之 ("it") with "it".How this was made
Carus When a superior scholar hears of Reason he endeavors to practise it. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 1, Carus's translation上士 ("superior scholar") is paired with "a superior scholar", 勤 ("diligent") with "endeavors", 而 ("and") with "to" and 行 ("practise") with "practise".How this was made
When an average scholar hears of Reason he will sometimes keep it and sometimes lose it. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 2, Carus's translation中士 ("middling scholar") is paired with "an average scholar", 聞道 ("hear the Way") with "hears of Reason" and 若存若亡 ("as if keeping, as if losing") with "sometimes keep it and sometimes lose it".How this was made
When an inferior scholar hears of Reason he will greatly ridicule it. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 3, Carus's translation下士 ("lowest scholar") is paired with "an inferior scholar", 大笑 ("laugh loudly") with "greatly ridicule" and 之 ("it") with "it".How this was made
若存若亡 Is 「若存若亡 ruò cún ruò wáng」 "as if he kept it, as if he lost it" keeping the Way and losing it to desire, or half believing and half doubting? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 河上公章句 and 老子翼 (陸希聲) ch. 41The question is fair: 河上公 has 欣然而存之…而復亡之 ("gladly keeps it, then loses it again"), while 陸希聲 has 疑信相半 ("doubt and belief half and half").How this was made
上士 Commentary Two commentators name 顏回 as the model of the top scholar
下士 Commentary 陸希聲 sorts the three scholars with a line from 易 Book of Changes
大笑 Commentary 焦竑 quotes 君平
Legge If it were not (thus) laughed at, it would not be fit to be the Tao. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 4, Legge's translation不笑 ("not laugh") is paired with "not (thus) laughed at", 不足 ("not enough") with "not be fit", 為 ("be") with "be" and 道 ("the Way") with "the Tao".How this was made
Carus Were it not thus ridiculed, it would as Reason be insufficient. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 4, Carus's translation不笑 ("not laugh") is paired with "not thus ridiculed", 為 ("serve as") with "as" and 不足 ("not enough") with "insufficient". 以 is unlinked with its reason.How this was made
Legge Therefore the sentence-makers have thus expressed themselves:--
'The Tao, when brightest seen, seems light to lack;
Who progress in it makes, seems drawing back;
Its even way is like a rugged track.
Its highest virtue from the vale doth rise;
Its greatest beauty seems to offend the eyes;
And he has most whose lot the least supplies.
Its firmest virtue seems but poor and low;
Its solid truth seems change to undergo;
Its largest square doth yet no corner show
A vessel great, it is the slowest made;
Loud is its sound, but never word it said;
A semblance great, the shadow of a shade.'
The Tao is hidden, and has no name; Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 5, Legge's translation建言 ("established sayings") is paired with "the sentence-makers", 若昧 ("seems dark") with "seems light to lack", 大方 ("great square") with "Its largest square" and 隱 ("hidden") with "is hidden".How this was made
Carus Therefore the poet says:
"The Reason-enlightened seem dark and black,
The Reason - advanced seem going back,
The Reason - straight - levelled seem rugged and slack.
"The high in virtue resemble a vale,
The purely white in shame must quail,
The staunchest virtue seems to fail.
"The solidest virtue seems not alert,
The purest chastity seems pervert,
The greatest square will rightness desert.
"The largest vessel is not yet complete,
The loudest sound is not speech replete,
The greatest form has no shape concrete."
Reason so long as it remains latent is unnamable. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 5, Carus's translation建言 ("established sayings") is paired with "the poet", 上德 ("high virtue") with "The high in virtue", 廣德 ("broad virtue") with "The staunchest virtue" and 大器 ("great vessel") with "The largest vessel", all in the order of the verse.How this was made
若纇 Is it 纇 lèi "knotted" or 類 lèi "of a kind": does the level Way look uneven, or does the man of the Way look like everyone else? The 河上公 Héshàng Gōng and 傅奕 Fù Yì texts read 類. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注, 河上公章句, 傅奕古本, 音義 ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 reads 纇 and glosses 纇,㘨也 ("a knot"), while 河上公 and 傅奕 read 類 and 河上公 says 若多比𩔖 ("seems one of the many").How this was made
若偷 Is the 偷 tōu "slack" or "steal" of established virtue slack and makeshift, acting by stealth, or open to being robbed and emptied? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 老子翼 (蘇轍, 焦竑), 憨山解, 河上公章句 ch. 41The question is fair: 蘇轍 has 外若偷惰 ("outwardly idle"), 憨山 潛行密用 ("acts in secret") and 河上公 若可偷引使空虚 ("could be drained empty").How this was made
若渝 Does 渝 yú "change" mean he seems to change, or seems faded like colors gone dull? The 傅奕 Fù Yì text reads 輸 shū for 渝. 焦竑 Jiāo Hóng keeps 渝 with 王弼 Wáng Bì's text. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 老子翼 (蘇轍, 焦竑), 河上公章句, 傅奕古本 ch. 41The question is fair: 蘇轍 has 外若渝也 ("seems changeable"), 河上公 若五色有渝 ("like faded colors"), and 傅奕 reads 質真若輸.How this was made
希聲 Is 希 xī "rare" a sound that cannot be heard, or one heard seldom, like thunder that waits its time? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 河上公章句 ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 has 不可得聞之音也 ("a sound that can't be heard"), while 河上公 has 猶雷霆待時而動 ("like thunder waiting its time").How this was made
方無隅 Is 方 fāng "square" or "space": a great square with no sharp corners, or great space with no fixed quarter? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 老子翼 (呂惠卿) ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 has 方而不割 ("square, yet not cutting"), while 呂惠卿 reads 無南無北 ("no south, no north").How this was made
建言 Quotation The lines after 建言 "set sayings" are older sayings that 老子 quotes
進道 Text The 傅奕 text puts the level-Way line before 「進道若退」 "the advancing Way seems to retreat."…
若辱 Commentary Two commentators say why great whiteness must take dirt
渝 Text The 傅奕 text reads 輸 for 渝 "change." 焦竑 reports that 傅奕's notes give 輸 as the ancient…
大器 Background 河上公 likens the great vessel to the 九鼎 "nine cauldrons" and the 瑚璉 "ritual vessels," which…
Legge but it is the Tao which is skilful at imparting (to all things what they need) and making them complete. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 6, Legge's translation夫 ("now") is paired with "but", 唯道 ("only the Way") with "it is the Tao which", 善貸 ("good at lending") with "skilful at imparting" and 成 ("complete") with "making them complete".How this was made
Carus Yet Reason alone is good for imparting and completing. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against Dao De Jing ch. 41 line 6, Carus's translation夫 ("now") is paired with "Yet", 唯道 ("only the Way") with "Reason alone", 善貸 ("good at lending") with "good for imparting" and 成 ("complete") with "completing".How this was made
貸且 Is the 貸 dài "loan" of the Way a lasting gift that truly completes, or a short loan and a completion only for now? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 老子翼 (趙志堅) ch. 41The question is real: 王弼 has 一貸之則足以永終其德 ("one loan suffices for ever"), while 趙志堅 has 貸者暫借非長與也 ("a temporary loan").How this was made
善貸 Commentary 王夫之 starts from an ordinary good lender
On the whole chapter
Context 憨山德清 says this chapter is about a Way beyond ordinary feeling
Context 王夫之 ends his essay back at the top scholar
Chinese text Published sourceThe 王弼 text of the Dao De Jing (王弼本) — published text.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made Legge Published sourceJames Legge, The Tâo Teh King, in The Sacred Books of the East, vol. 39 (1891) — published translation.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made Carus Published sourcePaul Carus, The Canon of Reason and Virtue (1913) — published translation.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made
The disputes and notes were summarized and translated by machine from the Chinese commentaries: 河上公 Héshàng Gōng's 老子道德經章句 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhāng jù, 王弼 Wáng Bì's 老子道德經注 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhù, 焦竑 Jiāo Hóng's 老子翼 lǎo zǐ yì and the commentaries it gathers, 憨山德清 Hānshān Déqīng's 老子道德經解 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng jiě, 王夫之 Wáng Fūzhī's 老子衍 lǎo zǐ yǎn and 陸德明 Lù Démíng's 老子音義 lǎo zǐ yīn yì. Each carries a small mark that says whether it has been checked against the source (how this was made), so rely on the Chinese quoted with each one. If something looks wrong, use the report link under it.
Chinese text Published sourceThe 王弼 text of the Dao De Jing (王弼本) — published text.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made
Legge Published sourceJames Legge, The Tâo Teh King, in The Sacred Books of the East, vol. 39 (1891) — published translation.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made
Scholars of the highest class, when they hear about the Tao, earnestly carry it into practice. Scholars of the middle class, when they have heard about it, seem now to keep it and now to lose it. Scholars of the lowest class, when they have heard about it, laugh greatly at it. If it were not (thus) laughed at, it would not be fit to be the Tao.Therefore the sentence-makers have thus expressed themselves:--
'The Tao, when brightest seen, seems light to lack;
Who progress in it makes, seems drawing back;
Its even way is like a rugged track.
Its highest virtue from the vale doth rise;
Its greatest beauty seems to offend the eyes;
And he has most whose lot the least supplies.
Its firmest virtue seems but poor and low;
Its solid truth seems change to undergo;
Its largest square doth yet no corner show
A vessel great, it is the slowest made;
Loud is its sound, but never word it said;
A semblance great, the shadow of a shade.'
The Tao is hidden, and has no name; but it is the Tao which is skilful at imparting (to all things what they need) and making them complete.
James Legge, The Tâo Teh King, in The Sacred Books of the East, vol. 39 (1891)
Carus Published sourcePaul Carus, The Canon of Reason and Virtue (1913) — published translation.Named, not validated: this site reproduces it as printed.How this was made
When a superior scholar hears of Reason he endeavors to practise it.When an average scholar hears of Reason he will sometimes keep it and sometimes lose it.
When an inferior scholar hears of Reason he will greatly ridicule it. Were it not thus ridiculed, it would as Reason be insufficient.
Therefore the poet says:
"The Reason-enlightened seem dark and black,
The Reason - advanced seem going back,
The Reason - straight - levelled seem rugged and slack.
"The high in virtue resemble a vale,
The purely white in shame must quail,
The staunchest virtue seems to fail.
"The solidest virtue seems not alert,
The purest chastity seems pervert,
The greatest square will rightness desert.
"The largest vessel is not yet complete,
The loudest sound is not speech replete,
The greatest form has no shape concrete."
Reason so long as it remains latent is unnamable. Yet Reason alone is good for imparting and completing.
Paul Carus, The Canon of Reason and Virtue (1913), chapter title “Sameness in Difference”
What the commentators say about chapter 41
Commentators have argued over this chapter for 2,000 years. Here is where they disagree, and what else they note.
These summaries and translations were made by machine from the Chinese commentaries: 河上公 Héshàng Gōng's 老子道德經章句 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhāng jù, 王弼 Wáng Bì's 老子道德經注 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhù, 焦竑 Jiāo Hóng's 老子翼 lǎo zǐ yì and the commentaries it gathers, 憨山德清 Hānshān Déqīng's 老子道德經解 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng jiě, 王夫之 Wáng Fūzhī's 老子衍 lǎo zǐ yǎn and 陸德明 Lù Démíng's 老子音義 lǎo zǐ yīn yì. Each carries a small mark that says whether it has been checked against the source (how this was made), so rely on the Chinese quoted with each one. If something looks wrong, use the report link under it.
Disputes 7
- Deep divide Choosing a camp changes what the saying teaches.
- Minor split The camps take the words differently, but the point holds.
- Outlier One camp, with an outlier reading against it.
Readings that end up saying the same thing are grouped in a camp. Each reading keeps its letter, oldest first: . The filled letter, , marks the reading this site's word definitions follow.
貸且 Is the 貸 dài "loan" of the Way a lasting gift that truly completes, or a short loan and a completion only for now? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 老子翼 (趙志堅) ch. 41The question is real: 王弼 has 一貸之則足以永終其德 ("one loan suffices for ever"), while 趙志堅 has 貸者暫借非長與也 ("a temporary loan").How this was made
若存若亡 Is 「若存若亡 ruò cún ruò wáng」 "as if he kept it, as if he lost it" keeping the Way and losing it to desire, or half believing and half doubting? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 河上公章句 and 老子翼 (陸希聲) ch. 41The question is fair: 河上公 has 欣然而存之…而復亡之 ("gladly keeps it, then loses it again"), while 陸希聲 has 疑信相半 ("doubt and belief half and half").How this was made
若纇 Is it 纇 lèi "knotted" or 類 lèi "of a kind": does the level Way look uneven, or does the man of the Way look like everyone else? The 河上公 Héshàng Gōng and 傅奕 Fù Yì texts read 類. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注, 河上公章句, 傅奕古本, 音義 ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 reads 纇 and glosses 纇,㘨也 ("a knot"), while 河上公 and 傅奕 read 類 and 河上公 says 若多比𩔖 ("seems one of the many").How this was made
若偷 Is the 偷 tōu "slack" or "steal" of established virtue slack and makeshift, acting by stealth, or open to being robbed and emptied? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 老子翼 (蘇轍, 焦竑), 憨山解, 河上公章句 ch. 41The question is fair: 蘇轍 has 外若偷惰 ("outwardly idle"), 憨山 潛行密用 ("acts in secret") and 河上公 若可偷引使空虚 ("could be drained empty").How this was made
若渝 Does 渝 yú "change" mean he seems to change, or seems faded like colors gone dull? The 傅奕 Fù Yì text reads 輸 shū for 渝. 焦竑 Jiāo Hóng keeps 渝 with 王弼 Wáng Bì's text. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 老子翼 (蘇轍, 焦竑), 河上公章句, 傅奕古本 ch. 41The question is fair: 蘇轍 has 外若渝也 ("seems changeable"), 河上公 若五色有渝 ("like faded colors"), and 傅奕 reads 質真若輸.How this was made
希聲 Is 希 xī "rare" a sound that cannot be heard, or one heard seldom, like thunder that waits its time? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 河上公章句 ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 has 不可得聞之音也 ("a sound that can't be heard"), while 河上公 has 猶雷霆待時而動 ("like thunder waiting its time").How this was made
1 smaller point
方無隅 Is 方 fāng "square" or "space": a great square with no sharp corners, or great space with no fixed quarter? Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against 王弼注 and 老子翼 (呂惠卿) ch. 41The question is fair: 王弼 has 方而不割 ("square, yet not cutting"), while 呂惠卿 reads 無南無北 ("no south, no north").How this was made
Notes 11
Context 憨山德清 says this chapter is about a Way beyond ordinary feeling
Context 王夫之 ends his essay back at the top scholar
上士 Commentary Two commentators name 顏回 as the model of the top scholar
下士 Commentary 陸希聲 sorts the three scholars with a line from 易 Book of Changes
大笑 Commentary 焦竑 quotes 君平
建言 Quotation The lines after 建言 "set sayings" are older sayings that 老子 quotes
進道 Text The 傅奕 text puts the level-Way line before 「進道若退」 "the advancing Way seems to retreat."…
若辱 Commentary Two commentators say why great whiteness must take dirt
渝 Text The 傅奕 text reads 輸 for 渝 "change." 焦竑 reports that 傅奕's notes give 輸 as the ancient…
大器 Background 河上公 likens the great vessel to the 九鼎 "nine cauldrons" and the 瑚璉 "ritual vessels," which…
善貸 Commentary 王夫之 starts from an ordinary good lender
People cited
Disciples
Rulers and ministers
Others in the text
Other scholars and writers
Works cited
The Laozi and its commentaries
Other classics
Dictionaries and philology
Philosophers and miscellanies
Commentators
3 more