Commentator · Philosopher · Cao Wei
王弼 Wáng Bì
Thinker of the learning of the mystery in the 魏 Wèi dynasty. His commentaries on 道德經 dào dé jīng Classic of the Way and Virtue and 易 yì Book of Changes became the standard ones. The text this app follows is his. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeWang Bi (Wáng Bì) lived 226–249 under the 曹魏 (Cao Wei). He was a leading figure of 玄學 ("learning of the mystery"), and his 老子注 and 周易注 became the standard commentaries.How this was made
In the disputes
- 250 disputes in this site's data with a reading of 王弼's
- 55 where 王弼 holds a reading no one else here shares
- 1 of 7 disputes with a verdict where the verdict favors 王弼
Characteristic readings
Where 王弼 holds a reading no one else here shares, holds an outlier reading, or a verdict favors 王弼. Deep divides first. Each opens the dispute on its chapter.
- 4Does 其 "its" or "his" in the four lines point to the Way, to the practitioner, or to oneself first and then other people?
- 10In 抱一 "holding the One," what is the One?
- 10Is 專氣 "relying on the breath" or "holding the breath in"?
- 10Must clarity that reaches all four ways be without action, as 王弼's text has it, or without a knowing mind, where the text reads 無知 "without knowing"? For 河上公, the line says no one can know the Way that fills the world.
- 10Who 「生之,畜之」 "gives them birth and rears them": the Way, the sage, or, for 王弼, one who just leaves their source unblocked?
- 14In 「執古之道」 "hold to the ancient Way," is 古 "ancient" antiquity, or, for 蘇轍, non-being?
Reads most differently from
王道 Wáng Dào · 1487–1547 80% differ
- 20Is the learning cut off in 「絕學」 "cut off learning" learning as such, or only a false, worldly learning, with a true one kept?Deep divide
- 21Is 閱 "to endow," "to tell," "to see pass," or "to survey," and does the Way do it or the sage?Deep divide
- 28What is without limit in 「復歸於無極」 "returns to the limitless": what cannot be exhausted, an endless life, knowing that reaches every limit, or the emptiness of constant virtue?Deep divide
- 36In the four opening lines, who means to act, and who is 之 "him, it"? An opponent the ruler brings down, a thing about to contract, or the sage's own mind?Deep divide
- 36What are the state's 利器 "sharp tools," and what is it to show them to 人 "others"? Rule without punishment, the ruler's power, softness itself, or weapons as a figure for this subtle insight?Deep divide
- 15Is the word 蔽 "to cover," as 王弼's text writes it, or 敝 "worn, old"?Minor split
- 21Is 從 "to follow" or "to come from": does great virtue follow only the Way, or come only from it?Minor split
- 21Is 眾甫 "the many beginnings," "all things beautiful," or the many things themselves?Minor split
韓非 Hán Fēi · c. 280–233 BCE 80% differ
- 53What is 「朝甚除」 "the court is well cleared": palace buildings kept spotless, a court crowded with lawsuits, or a court purging abuses with ever harsher laws?Deep divide
- 59In 「治人事天」 "governing men and serving heaven," are 人 "men" and 天 "heaven" the people and heaven above, an outward and an inward task, or human desire and one's heavenly nature?Deep divide
- 60Where does the virtue go, and who are the parties to 交 "mutually"? Is it the people, people and ghosts both, spirit and sage, or the sage above?Deep divide
- 26What do 重 "heavy," 輕 "light," 靜 "still" and 躁 "restless" stand for: all things, a ruler's power and post, a way of acting, or the body and the passions?Minor split
- 38What do 無以 "nothing by which" and 有以 "something by which" mean before 為 "act": no motive, nothing acted on all round, no use, no presuming, or acting within non-being?Minor split
- 53Is 盜夸 "robbers' flaunting" a display of stolen gains, or flaunting that teaches robbery? Or should it read 盜竽 "the robbers' pipe"?Minor split
- 59Is 嗇 "husbandry," the farmer at his work, or "sparing use"? The word comes again in the next line.Minor split
- 60Who are 兩 "the two," and does 相傷 "harm" mean harming the people or harming each other?Minor split
河上公 Héshàng Gōng · legendary 65% differ
- 1What is 有名 "the named," the mother of the ten thousand things?Deep divide
- 1What are 兩者 "the two" that come out together?Deep divide
- 1What does it mean that both are called 玄 "dark"?Deep divide
- 2Is 「美之為美」 "beauty as beauty" beauty counted as beauty or one's own beauty shown off, and is 惡 "ugliness" or "ruin"?Deep divide
- 3What fills the belly in 「實其腹」 "fill their bellies": food for the people, or the Way and the spirits held within?Deep divide
- 3Are the 智者 "clever," the 知者 "knowing" of the 河上公 and 傅奕 texts, men who know how to act but dare not, or deep thinkers who do not speak lightly?Deep divide
- 4Does 其 "its" or "his" in the four lines point to the Way, to the practitioner, or to oneself first and then other people?Deep divide
- 4Is 「湛兮似或存」 "limpid, it seems perhaps to be there" said of the still man who lasts long, as 河上公 reads it, or of the Way itself?Deep divide
- 6Is 谷 "valley" a figure for the empty center, the verb "nourish," or the formed thing beside the formless 神 "spirit"? 陸德明 reports a 河上公 text with 浴 "bathe," which he glosses as "nourish."Deep divide
- 6What is 門 "the gate" of the dark female, and is it any place at all?Deep divide
- 8Whose are the seven goods: water's, people's or the sage's as 李贄 and 憨山德清 read them, or, for 吳澄, the lesser goods the multitude choose?Deep divide
- 10In 抱一 "holding the One," what is the One?Deep divide
- 10Is 專氣 "relying on the breath" or "holding the breath in"?Deep divide
- 10Must the ruler of the fourth line be without cleverness, or keep his kindness unknown, or, in the text 呂惠卿, 憨山德清 and others read, be 無為 "without action"?Deep divide
- 10What is 天門 "the gate of heaven"?Deep divide
- 10Must clarity that reaches all four ways be without action, as 王弼's text has it, or without a knowing mind, where the text reads 無知 "without knowing"? For 河上公, the line says no one can know the Way that fills the world.Deep divide
- 10Who 「生之,畜之」 "gives them birth and rears them": the Way, the sage, or, for 王弼, one who just leaves their source unblocked?Deep divide
- 13How is 「貴大患若身」 "value great calamity like the body" built, and what is the great calamity?Deep divide
- 13Who is the man who 「貴以身為天下」 "values his person as the world," and what does he get?Deep divide
- 14Is 「無狀之狀」 "the shape of the shapeless" the shape of a thing that has none, or the shapes the shapeless One gives all things?Deep divide
- 15In 「濁以靜之」 "murky, by this still it," is 濁 "murky" the master's own murkiness, with which he stills things, or the muddy water that is stilled? The same question returns in 「安以久動之」 "at rest, by lasting, move it."Deep divide
- 19What do 聖 "sageliness" and 智 "wisdom" name here: real excellences, the sages' making of culture, or a counterfeit?Deep divide
- 19What do 仁 "humaneness" and 義 "rightness" name here: real goods of people, or an outward show of them?Deep divide
- 19What are 巧 "skill" and 利 "profit" here: useful skill and benefit, real goods that robbers exploit, or fraud and greed?Deep divide
- 20Is the learning cut off in 「絕學」 "cut off learning" learning as such, or only a false, worldly learning, with a true one kept?Deep divide
- 20Who are the people in 「人之所畏」 "what people fear," and what do they fear: people at large, whose fears the speaker shares; the man of the Way, who fears a ruler who has not cut off learning; or the harms people ought to fear?Deep divide
- 21Is 閱 "to endow," "to tell," "to see pass," or "to survey," and does the Way do it or the sage?Deep divide
- 22Is 少 "little" taking little for oneself, repaid with more, or having few things, down to the One, which reaches the root?Deep divide
- 22Is 見 "to show off," so that 明 "bright" means shining out, or 見 "to see," seeing by oneself or seeing oneself, so that 明 means clear sight?Deep divide
- 23Is 希言 "rare speech" the Way's speech too faint to hear, a person's sparing speech, or "seldom speaking of" the self-so?Deep divide
Reads most like
陸希聲 Lù Xīshēng · d. 895 62% alike
- 53What is 「朝甚除」 "the court is well cleared": palace buildings kept spotless, a court crowded with lawsuits, or a court purging abuses with ever harsher laws?Deep divide
- 17Is it 下 "those below" or 不 "not": do the people know the best ruler is there, or not? 憨山德清 reads 下 as a step down to the next age.Minor split
- 35Who goes in 「天下往」 "all under heaven goes": does the world come to the one who holds the great image, or does he go out into the world?Minor split
- 53Is 盜夸 "robbers' flaunting" a display of stolen gains, or flaunting that teaches robbery? Or should it read 盜竽 "the robbers' pipe"?Minor split
- 2What is it that 不去 "does not depart"?Outlier
- 17Is 之 "him" or "it": do the people know the ruler is there, or the Way? The same question runs through the three rungs that follow.Outlier
- 17Does 而 "and" join love and praise on one rung, or break between two ages? 憨山德清 counts two ages here.Outlier
- 35Are 樂與餌 "music and food" what stop a passing traveler, or, as 河上公 reads it, is it delight in the Way's beauty, so that the One, fleeting as a guest, stays?Outlier
呂惠卿 Lǚ Huìqīng · 1032–1111 55% alike
- 1What is 有名 "the named," the mother of the ten thousand things?Deep divide
- 1Is 欲 "desire," a noun, or "to wish," a verb, in this phrase and the next?Deep divide
- 3Are the 智者 "clever," the 知者 "knowing" of the 河上公 and 傅奕 texts, men who know how to act but dare not, or deep thinkers who do not speak lightly?Deep divide
- 4Is 「湛兮似或存」 "limpid, it seems perhaps to be there" said of the still man who lasts long, as 河上公 reads it, or of the Way itself?Deep divide
- 10In the line on washing and clearing, what is 玄覽 "dark seeing"?Deep divide
- 10Must the ruler of the fourth line be without cleverness, or keep his kindness unknown, or, in the text 呂惠卿, 憨山德清 and others read, be 無為 "without action"?Deep divide
- 13How is 「貴大患若身」 "value great calamity like the body" built, and what is the great calamity?Deep divide
- 17Is it 悠 "remote" or 猶 "hesitant," and whose words are prized: the best ruler's, kept few, or the faithless ruler's, still multiplied?Deep divide
- 19What is 有所屬 "something to attach to": the plainness in the next line, or the three things the world attaches its order to?Deep divide
- 20Is the learning cut off in 「絕學」 "cut off learning" learning as such, or only a false, worldly learning, with a true one kept?Deep divide
- 20What is 荒 "wild" or "vast": the distance between the speaker and common ways, the sage's boundless vastness, or wild excess that never ends?Deep divide
- 20Who are the people in 「人之所畏」 "what people fear," and what do they fear: people at large, whose fears the speaker shares; the man of the Way, who fears a ruler who has not cut off learning; or the harms people ought to fear?Deep divide
- 21Is 閱 "to endow," "to tell," "to see pass," or "to survey," and does the Way do it or the sage?Deep divide
- 22Is 少 "little" taking little for oneself, repaid with more, or having few things, down to the One, which reaches the root?Deep divide
- 23Is 希言 "rare speech" the Way's speech too faint to hear, a person's sparing speech, or "seldom speaking of" the self-so?Deep divide
- 26Is the 君 "lord" that the restless lose the ruler's seat, the lord within, or, for 蘇轍, the restless minister's lord?Deep divide
- 28Is the sage employed or employing, is 之 "it" the vessels or what has not yet scattered, and is 官長 "official and head" the sage himself, an office he holds without owning, or officials set over the scattered?Deep divide
- 30In 「果而不得已」 "resolute, with no choice," is 不得已 "having no choice" the condition of right action, or a state one should not be pressed into?Deep divide
- 32Is the sweet dew an image of how things settle uncommanded, or heaven's answer to a ruler who holds the Way?Deep divide
- 38What is 不德 "not virtue": not counting one's virtue as virtue, not teaching the people by virtue, or getting nothing?Deep divide
- 42What do 一 "one," 二 "two" and 三 "three" name? Stages of qi, steps of naming, yang and yin and their meeting, or the harmonizing breath and yin and yang?Deep divide
- 44Is 亡 "loss" losing one's own person, or lacking the thing one wants?Deep divide
- 45Is 大成 "great completion" a ruler who has greatly completed the Way, or the great completing itself, which takes no fixed shape? The same question runs through 大盈 "great fullness" and the pairs after it.Deep divide
- 47Is 名 "to name" or "to become known": does the sage name things he has not seen, or become known while he stays still?Deep divide
- 53What is 「朝甚除」 "the court is well cleared": palace buildings kept spotless, a court crowded with lawsuits, or a court purging abuses with ever harsher laws?Deep divide
- 58What does 「其無正」 "it has no correct" say: it holds nothing up as correct, he does not set himself upright, there is no fixed correct, or, as a question, is there no one to set it right?Deep divide
- 58In 「正復為奇,善復為妖」 "the correct again becomes the odd, the good again becomes the uncanny," whose correct and good become what: rule that ends in surprise warfare, upright subjects turned deceitful, values that shift, or the correct taken for the strange?Deep divide
- 65Is 反 "to turn back" or "contrary"? Does dark virtue turn back with things to the genuine and the root, or is it contrary to things?Deep divide
- 67Is 不肖 "resembling nothing" or "unworthy," like a fool? It comes twice, and 肖 "resemble" or "worthy" once more after it.Deep divide
- 70Whose 無知 "no knowing" is it: the hearers' failure to know, or the speaker's own not-knowing?Deep divide
蘇轍 Sū Zhé · 1039–1112 53% alike
- 1What is 有名 "the named," the mother of the ten thousand things?Deep divide
- 1What are 兩者 "the two" that come out together?Deep divide
- 1What does it mean that both are called 玄 "dark"?Deep divide
- 4Is 「湛兮似或存」 "limpid, it seems perhaps to be there" said of the still man who lasts long, as 河上公 reads it, or of the Way itself?Deep divide
- 6Is 谷 "valley" a figure for the empty center, the verb "nourish," or the formed thing beside the formless 神 "spirit"? 陸德明 reports a 河上公 text with 浴 "bathe," which he glosses as "nourish."Deep divide
- 6What is 門 "the gate" of the dark female, and is it any place at all?Deep divide
- 10In the line on washing and clearing, what is 玄覽 "dark seeing"?Deep divide
- 10What is 天門 "the gate of heaven"?Deep divide
- 14Is 「無狀之狀」 "the shape of the shapeless" the shape of a thing that has none, or the shapes the shapeless One gives all things?Deep divide
- 17Is it 悠 "remote" or 猶 "hesitant," and whose words are prized: the best ruler's, kept few, or the faithless ruler's, still multiplied?Deep divide
- 18Do benevolence and rightness appear after the great Way is dropped, or are they why it is dropped? 王安石 reads 「六親不和,有孝慈」 "when the six relations are not in harmony, there are filial piety and kindness" the same way.Deep divide
- 19What are 巧 "skill" and 利 "profit" here: useful skill and benefit, real goods that robbers exploit, or fraud and greed?Deep divide
- 20What is 荒 "wild" or "vast": the distance between the speaker and common ways, the sage's boundless vastness, or wild excess that never ends?Deep divide
- 20Who are the people in 「人之所畏」 "what people fear," and what do they fear: people at large, whose fears the speaker shares; the man of the Way, who fears a ruler who has not cut off learning; or the harms people ought to fear?Deep divide
- 22Is 少 "little" taking little for oneself, repaid with more, or having few things, down to the One, which reaches the root?Deep divide
- 25Is 自然 "the self-so" the unnamed ultimate the Way follows, or the Way's own being so of itself, so that it models nothing?Deep divide
- 30In 「果而不得已」 "resolute, with no choice," is 不得已 "having no choice" the condition of right action, or a state one should not be pressed into?Deep divide
- 32Is the sweet dew an image of how things settle uncommanded, or heaven's answer to a ruler who holds the Way?Deep divide
- 32In the simile, is the Way the river and sea that the streams return to, the streams that make a sea that cannot turn back into them, or a mutual flow between the Way and people?Deep divide
- 33What does not perish at death, and is 壽 "long life" life after death or plain long life?Deep divide
- 38What is 不德 "not virtue": not counting one's virtue as virtue, not teaching the people by virtue, or getting nothing?Deep divide
- 45In the lines on agitation, cold, stillness and heat, is 勝 "to overcome" or "to reach the extreme"?Deep divide
- 47Is 名 "to name" or "to become known": does the sage name things he has not seen, or become known while he stays still?Deep divide
- 49Whose heart does the sage 渾 "blur" or "merge," and how: his own made dim, the people's made one, or hearts made thick and simple?Deep divide
- 53What is 施 "to put forth" here: doing things, boastful display, or bestowing teaching on others?Deep divide
- 59What is 「有國之母」 "the mother of the state"? What keeps the state secure, thrift itself, or the Way, with the state taken as the body?Deep divide
- 60Where does the virtue go, and who are the parties to 交 "mutually"? Is it the people, people and ghosts both, spirit and sage, or the sage above?Deep divide
- 62Are these fine words and honored deeds the Way's own, praised and practiced, or ordinary goods that the Way surpasses?Deep divide
- 72What, and whose, is 所居 "where they dwell": stillness, the heart, one's nature, the people's dwelling, or daily surroundings?Deep divide
- 73What does the sage find hard in 「猶難之」 "still finds it hard": daring, killing the evildoer, or Heaven's unknowable will?Deep divide
Where readings diverge most in the commentary
A dispute counts when it has 2 or more readings. People are counted as reading differently when their readings are in different camps, and not when one of them holds only an outlier reading. Each person is listed on the side that wins in the disputes they share (at least 10), by its share of them.
Works by 王弼
In 78 chapters
Each row is a dispute or note that names 王弼. It opens the chapter on it.
道經 Chapters 1–37 · Dào Jīng 36
- 1 What is 有名 "the named," the mother of the ten thousand things? Does 妙 "subtlety" mean the utmost of the minute, or the essential? Is 徼 "the end things return to," "a byway" or "the edge of things"? What are 兩者 "the two" that come out together? What does it mean that both are called 玄 "dark"? Is 欲 "desire," a noun, or "to wish," a verb, in this phrase and the next? 王弼 explains why the text says 謂 "to call" and not 名 "to name." He says 玄 is what 「不可得而名」… Own reading
- 2 Is 相和 "answer each other," like 相隨 "follow each other," a pair answering both ways, or those below answering those above? What is it not to 居 "dwell," here and in the next line? What is it that 不去 "does not depart"? Is 「美之為美」 "beauty as beauty" beauty counted as beauty or one's own beauty shown off, and is 惡 "ugliness" or "ruin"? 王弼 likens beauty and ugliness to joy and anger, and good and not good to right and wrong The text of 王弼 reads 較 "measure" here The 傅奕 text reads 「萬物作而不為始」 "the ten thousand things arise and he does not act as their… Own reading
- 3 Is 賢 "the worthy" real ability, to be used but not exalted, or the glib, polished worthies of the vulgar world, to be given no pay or office? Does 「不見可欲」 "the desirable not seen" mean desirable things are put away, as 河上公 says, or that they stay but the ruler does not see them as desirable, as 呂惠卿 and 蘇轍 say? Does 其 "their" or "his" in the four clauses mean the people's heart, belly, will and bones, or the sage's own, governed in the same act as his state? What fills the belly in 「實其腹」 "fill their bellies": food for the people, or the Way and the spirits held within? Are the 智者 "clever," the 知者 "knowing" of the 河上公 and 傅奕 texts, men who know how to act but dare not, or deep thinkers who do not speak lightly? 王弼 explains the four parts by what they hold The 傅奕 text ends 「則無不為矣」 "then nothing is left undone." The texts of 王弼 and 河上公 end on 治… Own reading
- 4 Is 沖 "empty" like the 盅 "empty vessel" of the 傅奕 text, or "the middle," or "yin and yang in harmony"? Is 或 "always," a hedging "perhaps," or "once more," like the 傅奕 text's 又 "again"? Is 宗 "the ancestor" of the ten thousand things, or "the master" they depend on? Does 其 "its" or "his" in the four lines point to the Way, to the practitioner, or to oneself first and then other people? Is 「湛兮似或存」 "limpid, it seems perhaps to be there" said of the still man who lasts long, as 河上公 reads it, or of the Way itself? Is 象 "seems," a hedge like 或 "perhaps," or a noun, "the images," which the Way comes before as it comes before the Lord? Is 帝 "the Lord" of Heaven, or "the Emperor," the ancient sovereign 黃帝? Own reading
- 5 In both lines, is 芻狗 "fodder and dogs," two things, or "a straw dog," one object honored at the rite and thrown away after? Is 橐籥 "a bellows and a pipe," two hollow things, or "a bellows," one device with two parts? In the line on the empty bellows, is 屈 "exhausted," "pent up" or "bent to others"? Is 數 "the reckoning," the course by which much speech must run out, or 數 "often," so that much speech often runs dry? Is the 中 "center" that one keeps the inside where virtue is nursed, the empty hollow that never runs out, or a state of neither being nor non-being? Own reading
- 6 Is 谷 "valley" a figure for the empty center, the verb "nourish," or the formed thing beside the formless 神 "spirit"? 陸德明 reports a 河上公 text with 浴 "bathe," which he glosses as "nourish." What is 門 "the gate" of the dark female, and is it any place at all? Is 勤 "toil," so that it is used without labor, or "deliberate effort," so that it never runs out and responds with no mind? Own reading
- 7 Does 「不自生」 "they do not live for themselves" mean that heaven and earth do not seek life, do not give life to themselves, are not born, or do not produce things? Whose 私 "private ends" does the sage bring about: his own, with his person first and surviving, or other people's? 王弼 defines 無私 "having no self-interest" as 「無為於身」 "doing nothing on behalf of one's own… Own reading
- 8 In 「幾於道」 "comes near the Way," does water come near the Way itself, or, for 吳澄, the goodness of one who has the Way? Does the line read 正 "setting right," as the 王弼 and 河上公 texts do, or 政 "government," as the 傅奕 text does? Whose are the seven goods: water's, people's or the sage's as 李贄 and 憨山德清 read them, or, for 吳澄, the lesser goods the multitude choose? The 傅奕 text writes the line with 人 "people," where 王弼's text has 仁 "humaneness." Own reading
- 9 Does 已 "stop" mean the act of stopping, or a man with no virtue and no merit? What does 持 "hold" mean, and how does it stand to 盈 "fill"? What does 揣 "work to a point" or "gauge" mean, and how does it stand to 梲 "sharp"? 王弼's text writes 梲 "sharpen" here 王弼's notes on these two lines repeat the ends of the first two 王弼 explains Heaven's way by the seasons Own reading
- 10 In 抱一 "holding the One," what is the One? Is 專氣 "relying on the breath" or "holding the breath in"? In the line on washing and clearing, what is 玄覽 "dark seeing"? Must the ruler of the fourth line be without cleverness, or keep his kindness unknown, or, in the text 呂惠卿, 憨山德清 and others read, be 無為 "without action"? What is 天門 "the gate of heaven"? Must clarity that reaches all four ways be without action, as 王弼's text has it, or without a knowing mind, where the text reads 無知 "without knowing"? For 河上公, the line says no one can know the Way that fills the world. Who 「生之,畜之」 "gives them birth and rears them": the Way, the sage, or, for 王弼, one who just leaves their source unblocked? In 「長而不宰」 "raises them and does not rule them," is 宰 "to master" or "to carve up"? Is 載 "dwell," "ride," "carry," "renew" or "begin," and is 營魄 "a dwelling," "both souls," or one soul alone? Should the sage 為雌 "be the female," answering and not leading, or, where the text reads 無雌 "without the female," be free of the female's receiving and storing? 王夫之 prints 玄鑑 "the dark mirror" where the texts of 王弼, 河上公 and 傅奕 read 玄覽 "the dark… 王弼 says that wherever 玄德 "dark virtue" is spoken of, 「皆有德而不知其主,出乎幽冥」 "it is always virtue… Own reading
- 11 王弼 says the one hub can hold thirty spokes together because it is empty Quoted
- 12 Is 爽 "to go wrong," so the palate errs, or "to be lost," so the mouth is lost? 陸德明 records both glosses. Is conduct "obstructed," as 王弼 says, or "harmed," as 河上公 says? The 河上公 text and the 傅奕 text both write 田獵 "hunting" here, with 田 for 畋 "to hunt," the… 王弼 defines the two ways of living Own reading
- 13 Is favor the lowly one, as in 「寵為下」 "favor is lowly," or disgrace, as in 「辱為下」 "disgrace is lowly"? How is 「貴大患若身」 "value great calamity like the body" built, and what is the great calamity? Who is the man who 「貴以身為天下」 "values his person as the world," and what does he get? 王弼 says the great calamity is 「榮寵之屬」 "glory and favor and their kind." He says it is… 傅奕's text puts the two verbs the other way round Own reading
- 14 In 「執古之道」 "hold to the ancient Way," is 古 "ancient" antiquity, or, for 蘇轍, non-being? Is 「無狀之狀」 "the shape of the shapeless" the shape of a thing that has none, or the shapes the shapeless One gives all things? Own reading
- 15 Who are 四鄰 "the neighbors on four sides": states attacking a ruler from every side, or neighbors who might find a wrongdoer out? Is 徐 "with care" or "slowly, little by little"? The same word returns in the next line's 「徐生」 "come to life by degrees." Is the word 蔽 "to cover," as 王弼's text writes it, or 敝 "worn, old"? In 「濁以靜之」 "murky, by this still it," is 濁 "murky" the master's own murkiness, with which he stills things, or the muddy water that is stilled? The same question returns in 「安以久動之」 "at rest, by lasting, move it." 傅奕's text reads 「古之善為道者」 "those of old who were good at practicing the Way." 王弼's and… 王弼 says all these "like"s show that the masters' look cannot be given a shape or a name 王弼's text reads 「儼兮其若容」 "grave, they are like their bearing." The 河上公 text reads 「儼兮其若客」… Own reading
- 16 Is 篤 "firm" how firmly stillness is kept, or a second practice beside it, 篤厚 "earnest, honest conduct"? In 「萬物並作」 "the ten thousand things arise together," are the things born, do they stir into motion, or do they stand ranged before the watcher's eyes? In 「吾以觀復」 "I watch the return," whose return is it: the things' own return to where they began, or the watcher's mind, which does not stir? Is 王 "king" here, as 河上公 and the later commentators take it, or 全 "whole," as 王弼's own note implies? And is the king a man or the constant itself? Is 殆 "danger," so the man is safe to the end of his life, or 盡 "used up," so the body dies but the Way does not end? The text of 傅奕 reads 「靖曰復命」 "stillness is called returning to destiny," where 王弼's has 是謂… The 河上公 text prints 萎 "wither" where 王弼's has 妄 "reckless." Its own commentary still… Own reading
- 17 Is 太上 "the highest" a rank, the best kind of ruler, or a time, the ruler of high antiquity? Is it 下 "those below" or 不 "not": do the people know the best ruler is there, or not? 憨山德清 reads 下 as a step down to the next age. Is 之 "him" or "it": do the people know the ruler is there, or the Way? The same question runs through the three rungs that follow. Does 而 "and" join love and praise on one rung, or break between two ages? 憨山德清 counts two ages here. Is it 悠 "remote" or 猶 "hesitant," and whose words are prized: the best ruler's, kept few, or the faithless ruler's, still multiplied? 王弼 explains the line with the body Own reading
- 18 Whose 智慧 "cleverness" is this, and how does it breed 大偽 "great falsehood"? Do benevolence and rightness appear after the great Way is dropped, or are they why it is dropped? 王安石 reads 「六親不和,有孝慈」 "when the six relations are not in harmony, there are filial piety and kindness" the same way. 王弼 names the six relations 王弼 gives the rule behind the last two lines 王弼 and 蘇轍 both end their notes on these lines with fish 傅奕's text reads 貞臣 "upright ministers," where 王弼's has 忠臣 "loyal ministers." Quoted
- 19 What is 有所屬 "something to attach to": the plainness in the next line, or the three things the world attaches its order to? Is it 少私 "little selfishness" or 少思 "few thoughts"? What do 聖 "sageliness" and 智 "wisdom" name here: real excellences, the sages' making of culture, or a counterfeit? What are the three, and what is 文 "refinement": the wording of three bare sayings, ornament as against substance, or a refinement the world thinks it lacks? What do 仁 "humaneness" and 義 "rightness" name here: real goods of people, or an outward show of them? What are 巧 "skill" and 利 "profit" here: useful skill and benefit, real goods that robbers exploit, or fraud and greed? The 傅奕 text ends this line 「而未足也」 "and not yet enough," where this text has 不足 "not… 王夫之 prints 「絕學無憂」 "cut off learning and have no cares" as the last words of this chapter Own reading
- 20 Is the learning cut off in 「絕學」 "cut off learning" learning as such, or only a false, worldly learning, with a true one kept? What is 荒 "wild" or "vast": the distance between the speaker and common ways, the sage's boundless vastness, or wild excess that never ends? Is the speaker 泊 "still and placid," as 河上公's text has it with 怕 "still," or vast and open, as 王弼 says? Is the speaker 儽儽 "weary," like a destitute man with nowhere to go, or 乘乘 "riding on and on," clinging to nothing? Is the speaker 沌沌 "muddled," undifferentiated and making no distinctions, or 純純 "unmixed"? Is the common people's 察察 "sharp-eyed" being minutely discriminating, or being urgent and hasty? Is the speaker 飂 "blown along," drifting with nowhere to stop, or, reading 寂 "silent," still as if with nowhere to stop? What do the others all have in 「有以」 "have something": a use to put themselves to, purposeful action, or something to rely on? How is 食母 "feeding mother" construed: the nursing mother, using the Way, being fed by the mother, or nourishing the mother? Who are the people in 「人之所畏」 "what people fear," and what do they fear: people at large, whose fears the speaker shares; the man of the Way, who fears a ruler who has not cut off learning; or the harms people ought to fear? 王弼 opens his note with a line from the lower book 王夫之 prints this line as the end of chapter 19, which closes 「見素抱樸,少思寡欲,絕學無憂」 "show… The 傅奕 text reads 「美之與惡」 "the beautiful and the ugly," where 王弼's text reads 「善之與惡」 "the… 王夫之 prints this line as 「忽兮若晦」 "dim, as if dark." He has 晦 "dark" where 王弼's text has 海… 王弼 ends his note with 「故曰我獨欲異於人」 "so it says, I alone wish to be different from others,"… Own reading
- 21 Is 孔 "great" or "empty"? Is 從 "to follow" or "to come from": does great virtue follow only the Way, or come only from it? Is 信 "verification," "trustworthiness," or "timely response"? Is 閱 "to endow," "to tell," "to see pass," or "to survey," and does the Way do it or the sage? Is 眾甫 "the many beginnings," "all things beautiful," or the many things themselves? Is 此 "this," what was said above, or "now"? Does 「其名不去」 "its name does not go" mean its name never leaves, that it is named "not departing," or that its renown never fades? 王弼's text reads 「自古及今」 "from antiquity to now," and his own note quotes the line in that… Own reading
- 22 What is 曲 "bent": yielding to others, not showing one's brightness, bending round to reach every thing, or any bent thing, which must come whole? Is 少 "little" taking little for oneself, repaid with more, or having few things, down to the One, which reaches the root? Is 見 "to show off," so that 明 "bright" means shining out, or 見 "to see," seeing by oneself or seeing oneself, so that 明 means clear sight? 王弼 explains each of the first four sayings by one of the four 「不自」 "not himself" lines… 王夫之 prints this line as 「少則多」 "little, then much." The text of 王弼, the 河上公 text and the… Own reading
- 23 Is 德 "virtue" here, or is it 王弼's 得 "getting"? The same question comes back in 「同於德」 "one with virtue" and 「德亦樂得之」 "virtue too gladly gets him." What is 失 "loss": the loss that comes of having much, losing people by relying on oneself, failing in one's own deeds, or worldly folk without the Way and virtue? Does the third clause read 「失亦樂得之」 "loss too gladly gets him," as the 王弼 text has it, or 「失亦樂失之」 "loss too gladly loses him," as the 河上公 text has it? Is 希言 "rare speech" the Way's speech too faint to hear, a person's sparing speech, or "seldom speaking of" the self-so? In 「道者同於道」 "one of the Way is one with the Way," is 道者 "one of the Way" the seeker himself, or the people the sage meets and is one with? In 「道亦樂得之」 "the Way too gladly gets him," does the Way gladly take the man, or does the man gain the Way? In 「信不足焉,有不信焉」 "good faith falls short, and there is distrust," whose good faith falls short, and whose distrust follows? The 傅奕 text writes 得 "getting" where 王弼's text has 德 "virtue" Own reading
- 24 Is 在道 "in the Way" a matter of judging these acts by the Way, or of placing such men in the way of governing a state? Is 餘食 "leftover food" the leftovers of a meal, food beyond one's fill, or surplus pay and food gathered by greedy officials? Is 贅 "wart" or "greed," and is 行 "conduct" or 形 "the body"? 王弼 reads the man on tiptoe as a figure for pushing ahead 王弼 gives 郤至 as his example for these lines Own reading
- 25 Is 混成 "blended completion" the thing's own forming in a blend, or does the blended thing complete the ten thousand things? Is 寥 "empty and without form" or "far and remote"? Is 殆 "danger," so that it never comes to harm, or "exhaustion," so that it never runs out? In 「遠曰反」 "far is called returning," does the Way return by standing alone, come back to be found within the person, or is its going far itself the return? Is 域 "the realm" the undesignated, which holds all four, or the bounded world within the six directions? Is 自然 "the self-so" the unnamed ultimate the Way follows, or the Way's own being so of itself, so that it models nothing? Is it a chain, earth modeling heaven and heaven the Way? Or does it read 「人法地地,法天天,法道道」 "models earth, earthly; heaven, heavenly; the Way, Way-like," with the king becoming like each, as in 「君君臣臣」 "lord as lord, minister as minister"? 王弼 explains 「吾不知其名」 "I do not know its name" by the thing itself 王弼 separates 名 "a name" from 字 "a style." He writes 「名以定形,字以稱可」 "a name fixes a form The 傅奕 text reads 「人亦大」 "man too is great," where 王弼's has 「王亦大」 "the king too is great."… 王弼 explains why the king counts among the great Own reading
- 26 Does the light lord lose 本 "the root," his gravity and so his life? Or does he lose 臣 "his ministers," as the 河上公 text reads? Is the 君 "lord" that the restless lose the ruler's seat, the lord within, or, for 蘇轍, the restless minister's lord? What do 重 "heavy," 輕 "light," 靜 "still" and 躁 "restless" stand for: all things, a ruler's power and post, a way of acting, or the body and the passions? Own reading
- 27 What is the sage's 善救 "good saving": keeping people and things from harm, waking them by passing on his light, or a saving that claims no method? Is the not-good man the good man's 資 "resource" because the good man draws on him, or because at root he is the same stuff as the good? Is not valuing the teacher and not cherishing the resource a fault, so that the man is lost for all his cleverness, or the sage's height, which even the clever are lost about? 王弼 reads the five opening lines as one point Where 王弼's text has 數 "to count," the 河上公 text reads 計 "to reckon," as 陸德明 records Own reading
- 28 What is without limit in 「復歸於無極」 "returns to the limitless": what cannot be exhausted, an endless life, knowing that reaches every limit, or the emptiness of constant virtue? Is 足 "whole, complete," or, as 河上公 says, 止 "to come to rest"? Is the sage employed or employing, is 之 "it" the vessels or what has not yet scattered, and is 官長 "official and head" the sage himself, an office he holds without owning, or officials set over the scattered? 王弼 explains the three stanzas with a later chapter's line 「反者道之動也」 "reversal is the… Own reading
- 29 Is the 神器 "spirit vessel" a formless thing put together, the people, or a world with a spirit presiding over it? Does the line read 挫 "pressed down," as in 王弼's text, or 載 "borne," as in the 河上公 text? And against 隳 "topple," is 載 "secure," "borne up and completed," or 焦竑's "beginning"? 王弼 pairs each forbidden verb with a permitted one Own reading
- 30 Who is 善 "the good one" in 「善有果而已」 "the good one has his result, and no more": a man skilled at using troops, or a man who has the Way? What does 果 "result" mean here and in the five lines that repeat it: bringing through, resolute daring, deciding, or defeating the enemy? In 「果而不得已」 "resolute, with no choice," is 不得已 "having no choice" the condition of right action, or a state one should not be pressed into? Is 壯 "vigor" the full vigor of growth, after which all things age, or 王弼's violent surge of martial force? Is 「不道早已」 "against the Way, early ended" a statement that such things soon end, or a charge to stop them early? Who does the aiding in 「以道佐人主者」 "one who aids the ruler of men by the Way": a minister who aids the ruler, or the ruler who aids himself by the Way? Whose business is 其事 "his affairs," and what returns in 好還 "is apt to return": calamity on the user of arms, the man of the Way to non-action, or the ruler to blaming himself? The 河上公 and 傅奕 texts read 「善者」 "the good one" where 王弼's text has 「善有」 "the good one… Own reading
- 32 Does 常 "constant" say the Way is always nameless, name chapter 1's constant Way, or go with 名 "name," so that it has no constant name? None can make it a subject, or none dares? 河上公's text reads 不敢 "dares not" where 王弼's reads 莫能 "none can." Is the sweet dew an image of how things settle uncommanded, or heaven's answer to a ruler who holds the Way? What is even of itself: the people, whom no one commands, or the dew, which no one directs yet reaches everything alike? What is 始 "the beginning," and what does 制 "cut" or "rule" do? Do names arise once the block is cut and offices set up, or does the Beginning, the Way, rule the named? Does 「名亦既有」 "names, once they exist" say that names lead on to more names, or that named things all have desires, as 河上公 reads it with 既 "all"? Will one also know to stop, or does 河上公's text say 「天亦將知之」 "Heaven too will know him"? His text also reads 「知之所以不殆」 "knowing him is why there is no danger" for the next words. In the simile, is the Way the river and sea that the streams return to, the streams that make a sea that cannot turn back into them, or a mutual flow between the Way and people? 王夫之 prints this line as 「樸雖小,天下不敢臣」 "though the block is small, no one in the world dares… Own reading
- 33 What is the 所 "place" one does not lose: a place, what one received from heaven, or one's nature? Is 久 "lasting" a length of time, or, for 鳩摩羅什, a state beyond birth? What does not perish at death, and is 壽 "long life" life after death or plain long life? Own reading
- 34 Is 氾 "overflowing" a flood spilling everywhere, a thing drifting, or a thing tied to nothing? Does 「其可左右」 "it can go left and right" mean the Way reaches every side, or that it is near at hand, at one's left and right? Is it 衣養 "clothes and nourishes," as in 王弼's text, with 傅奕's 衣被 "clothes and covers" close to it, or 愛養 "loves and nourishes," which 陸德明 reports for the 河上公 text? Who is 無欲 "without desire": the world or the Way? Or does the Way simply hold nothing to desire? Do 「可名於小」 "can be named small" and 「可名為大」 "can be named great" name the Way truly in two respects, or do they cancel, leaving it neither small nor great? Is it 不為主 "it does not act as their master," as in the 王弼 and 河上公 texts, or 不知主 "they do not know their master," as in the 傅奕 text and 王夫之's? Is 為大 "make oneself great" or "do the great thing," taking on great matters head-on? The editions write this word four ways Both early commentaries say why things return to the Way 陸德明 reports that the 河上公 text opens this line with 「是以聖人」 "therefore the sage," where… Own reading
- 35 Who goes in 「往而不害」 "going, it takes no harm": the ten thousand things going to the great image, or a person going out among things? Does 不足 "not enough to" mean the Way does not please the eye or ear, or, with 河上公's gloss, that the formless Way cannot be seen at all? Who goes in 「天下往」 "all under heaven goes": does the world come to the one who holds the great image, or does he go out into the world? Are 樂與餌 "music and food" what stop a passing traveler, or, as 河上公 reads it, is it delight in the Way's beauty, so that the One, fleeting as a guest, stays? 王弼 calls the great image 「天象之母」 "the mother of the images of heaven." He says it is not… The 傅奕 text reads 出言 "comes out as words" for 出口 "comes out of the mouth." 王弼 and 呂惠卿… 既 means 盡 "to use up" here, not "already." 憨山德清 says so outright Own reading
- 36 In the four opening lines, who means to act, and who is 之 "him, it"? An opponent the ruler brings down, a thing about to contract, or the sage's own mind? What are the state's 利器 "sharp tools," and what is it to show them to 人 "others"? Rule without punishment, the ruler's power, softness itself, or weapons as a figure for this subtle insight? Own reading
- 37 Is 「無名之樸」 "the nameless block" the ruler's means, so the people too lose desire, or is it the thing one must not desire? The repeated 「不欲」 "not desire" splits the same way. Quoted
德經 Chapters 38–81 · Dé Jīng 42
- 38 What is 不德 "not virtue": not counting one's virtue as virtue, not teaching the people by virtue, or getting nothing? What does 下德 "lower virtue" name: every virtue that has to act, or the rulers of a later age? 河上公 reads 上德 "highest virtue" likewise as the rulers of high antiquity. What is 前識 "foreknowing": knowing ahead of others, claiming to know what one does not, or knowledge drawn from the objects before one? What do 無以 "nothing by which" and 有以 "something by which" mean before 為 "act": no motive, nothing acted on all round, no use, no presuming, or acting within non-being? Who bares the arm, and what are 扔 "pull" and 之 "them": forcing those who do not answer, quarreling, paying each other back, or the sage keeping on with courtesy? The 河上公 and 傅奕 texts read 仍 "keep on." 王弼 keeps a place for benevolence, rightness and ritual The 傅奕 text reads two lines differently Own reading
- 39 Is 昔 "of old" or "at the beginning"? What is the One that heaven, earth and the rest obtain? In 「貴以賤為本」 "the noble takes the lowly as its root," is the lowly root the formless One, or humble station and labor? The same goes for the high and its base. What does 致 "bring about" or "push to the end" do in this line, and what is 之 "it"? The 傅奕 text reads 「其致之一也」 "what they come to is one," as do the texts of 憨山 and 王夫之. Own reading
- 40 What is the 反 "reversal" that is the Way's movement? What is the 有 "being" that all things are born from, and that is itself born from 無 "non-being"? Own reading
- 41 Is it 纇 "knotted" or 類 "of a kind": does the level Way look uneven, or does the man of the Way look like everyone else? The 河上公 and 傅奕 texts read 類. Is the 偷 "slack" or "steal" of established virtue slack and makeshift, acting by stealth, or open to being robbed and emptied? Does 渝 "change" mean he seems to change, or seems faded like colors gone dull? The 傅奕 text reads 輸 for 渝. 焦竑 keeps 渝 with 王弼's text. Is 希 "rare" a sound that cannot be heard, or one heard seldom, like thunder that waits its time? Is 方 "square" or "space": a great square with no sharp corners, or great space with no fixed quarter? Is the 貸 "loan" of the Way a lasting gift that truly completes, or a short loan and a completion only for now? The 傅奕 text reads 輸 for 渝 "change." 焦竑 reports that 傅奕's notes give 輸 as the ancient… Own reading
- 42 Is 沖 "empty," the void each thing holds? Or is 沖氣 "the 沖 breath" the primal qi in all things, or the one breath between yin and yang? In 「我亦教之」 "I also teach it," do I teach the same lesson others teach, or do I teach the many the reverse? What do 一 "one," 二 "two" and 三 "three" name? Stages of qi, steps of naming, yang and yin and their meeting, or the harmonizing breath and yin and yang? Is 教父 "teaching father" the violent man as the start of teaching, the maxim honored as "father," or a herald's wooden bell? Own reading
- 44 Is 亡 "loss" losing one's own person, or lacking the thing one wants? In 厚亡 "heavy loss," what is lost: the hoard itself, to those who seek and attack it, or one's own highest wealth? In 「甚愛必大費」 "loving too much must cost greatly," love of what, and what does it cost? 傅奕's text reads 其愛 "his love" where 王弼's has 甚愛 "loving too much." 傅奕's line has no word… 傅奕's text ends this line with 不盡 "is not used up," where 王弼's and 河上公's have 不殆 "meets no… Own reading
- 45 Is 大成 "great completion" a ruler who has greatly completed the Way, or the great completing itself, which takes no fixed shape? The same question runs through 大盈 "great fullness" and the pairs after it. In the lines on agitation, cold, stillness and heat, is 勝 "to overcome" or "to reach the extreme"? 傅奕's text reads 「知清靖以為天下正」 "know clarity and calm, and so be the standard for the world."… Own reading
- 46 Does 「天下有道」 "the world has the Way" mean its ruler has the Way, or everyone in it? The same holds for 「天下無道」 "the world lacks the Way." 傅奕's text reads 「卻走馬播」 "the running horses are sent back to sow," where 王弼's has 「卻走馬以糞」… 河上公's and 傅奕's texts have one more line before this one, 「罪莫大於可欲」 "no crime is greater… Own reading
- 47 Is 名 "to name" or "to become known": does the sage name things he has not seen, or become known while he stays still? 王弼 explains how one can know the world without going out 傅奕's text adds 可以 "can" to both lines Before an adjective, 彌 means "the more." Used twice, as in this chapter's 「其出彌遠,其知彌少」… Own reading
- 48 What is it that learning adds to day by day? 傅奕's text makes the subjects people Own reading
- 49 What is 德善 "virtue's goodness," and its twin 德信 "virtue's trust": the people made good, the sage's own goodness, or a goodness all share? How is the sage among men: 歙歙 "with no master" in 王弼's text, 怵怵 "in dread" in 河上公's, or 惵惵 "eagerly striving" in 憨山's? Is 注 "use" or "fix": do the people use their ears and eyes, or fix them, and on what? Does the sage 孩 "child" the people by making them childlike or by treating them as children? Or do they become childlike of themselves? Whose heart does the sage 渾 "blur" or "merge," and how: his own made dim, the people's made one, or hearts made thick and simple? 王弼 gives the reason for the sage's reserve 王弼 pictures the ideal ruler with 冕旒 "the hanging strings of his ceremonial cap" filling… Own reading
- 50 Is 十有三 "three in ten" or "thirteen"? Does 「以其生生之厚」 "because they live life too thickly" explain the third group alone, or all three groups, nine in ten? Do 出 "go out" and 入 "go in" mean being born and dying, desires going out and in, or one movement out of life into death? 王弼 gives an image for this excess of living The 河上公 text reads 「不避甲兵」 "does not avoid armor and weapons," where the 王弼 text has… Own reading
- 51 What is the 德 "virtue" that rears things: what each thing gets of the Way, the One spreading qi, or the Way at work? Does the line read 養 "nourishes," as the 王弼 and 河上公 texts do, or 蓋 "covers," as the 傅奕 text does? Who shapes in 「物形之」 "things shape them": things, the One, or the formless Way and virtue showing through things? Is it that no one gives the Way and virtue rank, as 傅奕's 爵 "rank" has it, or that the Way commands nothing and things answer it of themselves? Is 「亭之毒之」 "completes and ripens them," as the 河上公 text's 「成之熟之」 "completes them and ripens them" has it? Is it "weighs and measures them"? Or is 亭 "to set apart"? 王弼 reads the four opening clauses as stages in order The 王弼 and 河上公 texts read 「養之覆之」 "nourishes them and shelters them," where the 傅奕 text… Both early commentaries read 玄 "dark" here as hidden from sight Own reading
- 52 Is 子 "the child" the One, or the ten thousand things that grow from the Way? What is the 兌 "opening" to be stopped up: the eyes, the mouth, the delighting heart, or the place desire springs from? What is the 門 "gate" to be shut: the mouth, the eyes and ears, or the door desire passes through? Is it 「守柔曰強」 "holding to the soft is called strength," or, as 河上公's text writes, 「守柔日強」 "holding to the soft, one grows strong by the day"? Is it 習常 "practicing the constant," or 襲常 "cloaking the constant" or "carrying it on unbroken"? What are the light and the brightness: the Way made plain to the people and a return to not prying, or one's own light sent out and turned back within? Own reading
- 53 What is 施 "to put forth" here: doing things, boastful display, or bestowing teaching on others? Is 盜夸 "robbers' flaunting" a display of stolen gains, or flaunting that teaches robbery? Or should it read 盜竽 "the robbers' pipe"? What is 「朝甚除」 "the court is well cleared": palace buildings kept spotless, a court crowded with lawsuits, or a court purging abuses with ever harsher laws? 王弼 reads the three lines as cause and effect 焦竑 tells 文 "pattern" from 采 "color." He writes 「青赤為文色絲為采」 "blue and red make pattern… Own reading
- 54 Does 脫 "come loose" mean slipping from one's own grasp, or being wrested away by someone else? Does 此 "this" in 「以此」 "by this" point to the observing just described, or to the one truth the sage holds? In 「以身觀身」 "by the self, observe the self," repeated for family, village, state and world, what observes what, and to what end? The 河上公 text reads 「其德有餘」 "its virtue has a surplus," and the note of 王弼 also says 有餘… Own reading
- 55 Does the infant 全作 "grow whole," as 王弼's text reads, or does its 朘 "member" 作 "rise," as in the 河上公 text, written 䘒 "member" in its heading and by 陸德明? Is it 「益生曰祥」 "adding to life is called an ill omen," or, with the 河上公 text's 日 "day," "adding to life, one grows bigger by the day"? The same 曰 "is called" or 日 comes back in 「心使氣曰強」 "the mind driving the qi is called strong." Own reading
- 56 王弼's text prints 分 "division," and the 河上公 and 傅奕 texts read 紛 "tangles." What is being untied: the source of contention, knotted resentment, or a jumble of thoughts? 王弼 reads 「和其光,同其塵」 "soften the light, merge with the dust" as removing grounds for… The six "cannots" are three pairs 王弼 says of the closing line 「無物可以加之也」 "there is nothing that can be added to him." 河上公… Own reading
- 57 What are the people's 利器 "sharp instruments": implements of profit, power and schemes, or worthy men? Who are the 人 "men" with many skills: the people at large, or the rulers and lords? Are the 奇物 "strange things" that arise crooked doings, or strange and costly objects? Is it 法令 "laws and decrees," as 王弼's text reads, or 法物 "fine things," as 河上公's text reads? Is 以正 "by the correct" correction by set-up rules that ends in war, the regular way proper to governing, or Heaven bringing an upright man to rule? 王弼 reads the chapter as root against branches 王弼 explains this line by quoting what he calls 「上章」 "the chapter above" 傅奕's text reads 「民多知慧」 "the people have much knowledge" for 「人多伎巧」 "men have many… Own reading
- 58 What does 缺缺 "lacking" say about the people under prying rule: want, rivalry, broken wholeness, or worry? In 「人之迷」 "people's delusion," whose delusion has lasted so long: people at large, or the rulers? Is 廉 "clean, incorrupt," or "edged, angular" like a corner? Is 不燿 "not shining" about not shining a searching light on people's hidden faults, or not dazzling them with one's own brightness? Does 「孰知其極」 "who knows its utmost?" ask where fortune's turning ends, or what the utmost of good government is? 王弼 takes the next words, 「其無正」 "it has nothing correct," as the answer. What does 「其無正」 "it has no correct" say: it holds nothing up as correct, he does not set himself upright, there is no fixed correct, or, as a question, is there no one to set it right? In 「正復為奇,善復為妖」 "the correct again becomes the odd, the good again becomes the uncanny," whose correct and good become what: rule that ends in surprise warfare, upright subjects turned deceitful, values that shift, or the correct taken for the strange? 王弼 says what prying government does 王夫之 prints the line as 「其無正邪」 "it has nothing correct." Its last graph 邪 is a final… 王弼 gives three of the four closing lines a saying each The 河上公 text reads 「廉而不害」 "incorrupt, but does not harm," with 害 "harm" where 王弼 has 劌… Own reading
- 59 In 「事天」 "serve heaven," is 事 "to serve" heaven, or "to use" heaven's Way? Is 嗇 "husbandry," the farmer at his work, or "sparing use"? The word comes again in the next line. What is 服 "to submit" or "to gain," here and in the next line? Submitting to the Way, gaining it, others submitting, mastering oneself, or 復 "returning"? In 「莫知其極」 "no one knows its limit," here and in the next line, whose limit is it? One's own virtue's, or the Way's, which has no end? In 「治人事天」 "governing men and serving heaven," are 人 "men" and 天 "heaven" the people and heaven above, an outward and an inward task, or human desire and one's heavenly nature? What is 「有國之母」 "the mother of the state"? What keeps the state secure, thrift itself, or the Way, with the state taken as the body? The 傅奕 and 王夫之 texts read 吝嗇 "stingy, sparing" where the others have 嗇 "sparing," in both… 焦竑 records that one text writes 復 "return" for 服 "submit." 呂惠卿 and 憨山德清 both comment on a… The 王弼 text writes 柢 "root." The 河上公 commentary explains the line with 蔕 "stalk." A tree… Own reading
- 60 Whom does the sage not harm, the people or the spirits? 王弼's and 傅奕's texts read 「傷人」 "harm people," 河上公's has 傷 "harm" alone, and 焦竑 and 王夫之 print 「傷之」 "harm them," which 憨山 uses only when he quotes the line in his commentary. Who are 兩 "the two," and does 相傷 "harm" mean harming the people or harming each other? Where does the virtue go, and who are the parties to 交 "mutually"? Is it the people, people and ghosts both, spirit and sage, or the sage above? Own reading
- 61 Whom does the female of 「天下之牝」 "the female of all under heaven" stand for, the great state or the small states? When the small state stoops, in 「則取大國」 "then it takes the great state" and again in 「或下而取」 "some stoop and take," is it taken in by the great state, or does it win the great state over? Is the 大者 "great one" who ought to take the low place the great state, or whoever is great in the Way? 吳澄 reports a doubt about the doubled 牝 "female." He writes 「或曰牝字其一疑衍」 "some say that one… Two commentators say why the still female wins 王弼 reads 以 "because" here 王弼 explains the word order Own reading
- 62 What is the 奧 "inner place" the Way is to all things: a shelter, a storehouse, a room's inner corner, or warmth? What does honored conduct do to others: reach them, so that far-off people respond, or set its doer apart from them? Is 進 "advance" presenting the Way as one presents a gift, or putting it forth among the people? Is it 曰 "say" or 日 "day": "is it not said that…?" or "not by days"? Are these fine words and honored deeds the Way's own, praised and practiced, or ordinary goods that the Way surpasses? Are the Son of Heaven and the three dukes set up to serve the Way, or named among honours that fall short of it? Seek by the Way and get what you seek, or seek the Way itself and get it? 傅奕's text reads 驛馬 "post horses" where 王弼's has 駟馬 "a team of four." 王夫之 prints 驛馬 in his… 王弼 says 「此道」 "this Way" is 「上之所云也」 "the one spoken of above," the Way the chapter has… The 傅奕 text reads 求以得 "seek and so get" where the 王弼 and 河上公 texts read 以求得 "by it seek… Own reading
- 63 What is 味 "to taste" here: to ponder deeply, or to relish as one's flavor? Is 猶 "still," or is it 尤 "all the more," or 若 "as if"? How is 「大小多少」 "great, small, many, few" construed: greatness reached through the small, the small made great, all sizes met alike, freedom to be either, or the size of the grievance? Does the sage repay resentment with kindness, keep no resentment to repay, or meet it by following what the whole world shares? Own reading
- 64 The 王弼 text reads 輔 "assist," helping the self-so of things along. 焦竑 follows 韓非's text and reads 恃 "rely on." Does the sage help things along, or rely on them? 王弼 says the four opening lines all speak of taking care at the end Quoted
- 65 Is 愚 "simple" a simplicity the sage brings about in the people, or a benightedness they already have, which he recognizes? In 「以智治國」 "to govern the state by cleverness" and the line after it, is 智 "cleverness" the ruler's own method, or clever men employed to run the state? Is the first word of 「稽式」 "standard" 王弼's 稽 "the same," or 河上公's 楷 "model"? Is 反 "to turn back" or "contrary"? Does dark virtue turn back with things to the genuine and the root, or is it contrary to things? 傅奕's text writes 知 "to know" where 王弼's has 智 "cleverness." It reads 「以其多知也」 "because… 河上公's text is not the only one to read 楷式 "model" for 稽式 "standard." 焦竑 glosses 楷… 王弼's own note gives the line as 「能知稽式」 "able to know the standard," not 「常知」 "always… Own reading
- 66 The 王弼 text gives this sentence no subject Mentioned
- 67 Is it 老子's Way the world calls great, or 老子 himself? The 河上公 text has no 道 "Way." Is 不肖 "resembling nothing" or "unworthy," like a fool? It comes twice, and 肖 "resemble" or "worthy" once more after it. In 「儉故能廣」 "frugal, so able to be broad," what grows broad: the world's supply, the state, or the frugal man himself? Does compassion 「以戰則勝」 "win in battle," or is the army in good order, as the 傅奕 text has it with 陳 "array" and 正 "upright"? Does 成器長 "head of vessels" mean setting up finished vessels and heading things, heading the "finished vessels," or becoming head of the vessels? Is 「若肖,久矣其細」 "had it resembled things, it would long since have been small," or does it say clever men have long been with us and are petty men? 王弼 says 且 means 取 "take." They give up compassion and take up bravery 傅奕's text reads 是謂入死門 "this is called entering the gate of death," where 王弼's and 河上公's… Own reading
- 68 Is 力 "strength" in 「用人之力」 "the strength of employing men" the strength of the men employed, or the power of the one who employs them? 王弼 defines both main words of the first line Own reading
- 69 Is 扔 "to draw in" the enemy, or "to go up and close with" him? The 河上公 and 傅奕 texts write 仍 for 扔. Is it 輕敵 "making light of the enemy," or 無敵 "having no match," as the 傅奕 text reads? The repeated 輕敵 in the next phrase goes with it. Which treasure is nearly lost in 吾寶 "my treasure": the three treasures, one's own body, or compassion? In 行無行 "march with no ranks," is 行 "the battle ranks" one marches in, or 行 "putting into effect" a punishment? The 傅奕 text puts 「執無兵」 "grasping where there is no weapon" before the enemy phrase, so… The 傅奕 text reads 「抗兵相若」 "when raised arms are evenly matched," where 王弼's has 相加… Why does the one who grieves win? 王弼 says those who grieve surely cherish one another Own reading
- 70 Does 「天下莫能知」 "no one in the world can know them" mean no one knows these words, or that everyone knows them but no one knows the speaker? Whose 無知 "no knowing" is it: the hearers' failure to know, or the speaker's own not-knowing? Is 則 "then," so that I am precious, or "take as model," so that whoever models himself on me is noble? 王弼 says why the words are easy Own reading
- 71 In 「不知知」 "not knowing, knowing," is the second 知 "knowing" a false claim to know, the object of 不知 "not knowing," or the means by which one wrongly knows the Way's not-knowing? The 傅奕 text writes the first lines 「知不知,尚矣。不知知,病矣」 "to know not knowing is highest Own reading
- 72 Is it 狎 "treat lightly," as 王弼's text reads, or 狹 "narrow," as 河上公's does: a warning against carelessness or against cramping? What, and whose, is 所居 "where they dwell": stillness, the heart, one's nature, the people's dwelling, or daily surroundings? Is 見 "to show," so the sage does not display himself, or "to see," so he does not see his life as worth tending? Is 威 "might" the ruler's power, harm to life, or a majesty within, and what is the great one that comes? What is 所生 "what they live by": humility, the vital spirit, or one's own life? Who does not 厭 "reject" what in 「夫唯不厭,是以不厭」 "only by not rejecting, therefore not rejecting," and is it the same word both times? 王弼 ties this line back to the warnings at the start of the chapter Own reading
- 73 Does 「或利或害」 "either benefit or harm" give benefit to one case and harm to the other, or say each case can go either way? Is 「孰知其故」 "who knows the reason" a real question, answered "only the sage," or a rhetorical one: no one can know Heaven's reasons? What does the sage find hard in 「猶難之」 "still finds it hard": daring, killing the evildoer, or Heaven's unknowable will? In 「不言而善應」 "does not speak, yet answers well," who responds: the ten thousand things answering Heaven, or Heaven answering what people do? In 「不召而自來」 "comes of itself uncalled," what comes: the ten thousand things, or Heaven's requital? Is it 繟然 "relaxed, lenient" or 坦然 "level and easy"? The 傅奕 text reads 默然 "silently." 王弼 spells out how Heaven plans well Own reading
- 74 Who is 司殺者 "the one in charge of killing," whom the ruler must not stand in for? 王弼 defines 奇 "deviant" as the weird and deviant that throws the community into disorder Own reading
- 75 Whose lavish seeking of life makes the people take death lightly, the rulers' or the people's own? The 傅奕 text has 上 "those above" before 求生 "seeking life," and the 王弼 and 河上公 texts do not. Own reading
- 76 Does the line on the strong tree end in 兵 "weapons," as in 王弼's text, or in 共 "together," as in the 河上公 and 傅奕 texts? And which of its three readings does 共 take? Does 「強大處下,柔弱處上」 "the strong and great dwell below, the soft and weak above" describe the parts of a tree, or a general order of position and rank? 王弼 says an army made strong to do violence in the world is hated by all things, so it… The 傅奕 text reads 「故堅強處下」 "so the hard and stiff dwell below," where 王弼's text has 強大… Own reading
- 78 Is 易 "replace," "change" or "take lightly"? And does 其 "it" state a fact about water or give a warning? Where 王弼's text reads 「莫之能勝」 "nothing can beat it," 傅奕's text reads 「莫之能先」 "nothing can… Mentioned
- 79 Is 和 "reconciling" a great resentment making peace after the harm, or settling the score by legal retribution? Is 徹 "go through" about watching others' faults, getting through to everyone, or the 周 tax? Own reading
- 80 Is 「小國寡民」 "a small state with few people" a state that really is small, or a large state the sage treats as small? Own reading
- 81 What does the sage have more of in 「己愈有」 "he himself has all the more," and in the next line's 「己愈多」 "he himself has ever more": the honor and allegiance of things, or his own virtue and wealth? Where 王弼's text reads 「善者不辯」 "the good do not dispute," 傅奕's text reads 「善言不辯,辯言不善」 "good… Own reading
Connected
Named in this entry
Named in the entries for
- 河上公 Héshàng Gōng
- 老子道德經章句 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhāng jù
- 老子道德經注 lǎo zǐ dào dé jīng zhù
- 陸德明 Lù Démíng
- 經典釋文 jīng diǎn shì wén
- 鍾會 Zhōng Huì
Same era Three Kingdoms to Sui · 220–618