Commentary on the Analects · early Yuan, c. 1280s
四書辨疑 Sì Shū Biàn Yí
Discerning Doubts in the Four Books
A Yuan book of doubts about Zhu Xi's Four Books commentaries. Checked by a machineChecked 2 times by machine, most recently on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeI checked the hook for 四書辨疑 against what I know of its subject, and the claim is right.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeI checked the hook against what I know of 四書辨疑. It is accurate.How this was made
Unsigned early-元 Yuán critique of 朱熹 Zhū Xī's Four Books commentaries, attributed by the Four Treasuries (四庫 Sì Kù) editors to 陳天祥 Chén Tiānxiáng; in some 300 entries it prefers leaving doubts open to strained interpretation. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledge of the work and the kinds listCommentaries on the Analects fits Chen Tianxiang's critique of the Four Books commentaries.Earlier versions · changed since validatedClaude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeChecked Discerning Doubts in the Four Books: the author, the date (early Yuan, c. 1280s) and the description in the line agree with own knowledge, and the pinyin of the tokens is right.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeChecked the title, author, date and description of 四書辨疑 against my own knowledge, plus the pinyin of each token; they agree.How this was made
Commentaries on the Analects · Named in 78 passages, 71% of the time in the disputes. In the notes, for commentary (10) · parallel passages (7) · context (6).
In 78 passages
Each row is a dispute or note that names 四書辨疑. It opens the passage on it.
學而 Book 1 · Xué Ér 7
- 1.2 Mencius has the same sense as this chapter Quoted
- 1.3 Who the man of 巧言令色 is: a pleaser who polishes words and face, a schemer whose charm hides intent to harm, or a counterfeit who talks humaneness and wears its look. What 鮮 "seldom" leaves: a thin share of humaneness in each such man, a few such men truly humane, or, said gently, none at all. Quoted
- 1.4 Whether 忠 is giving all that is in oneself, or a heart with nothing selfish or hidden, set apart from 信 as heart from speech. Quoted
- 1.6 Is 行 the noun "conduct", read xìng, in the departing tone, as the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) has it, or the verb "to do", read xíng, in its ordinary tone, as written? This settles the word and its tone only. Is "strength to spare" (有餘力則) a condition, so that study of 文 waits until the duties are done, or only an order of importance, with the duties as the root? Quoted
- 1.7 Who says he has not learned: other people, the man himself, or no one, because he truly has not? Quoted
- 1.8 Does 不如己 rank people, and if so must a friend surpass you or merely equal you; or does it mean one not of your kind? Quoted
- 1.12 Is 用 the "function" paired with ritual's "substance" (體), or simply the use of ritual in practice? Quoted
為政 Book 2 · Wéi Zhèng 5
- 2.3 What 格 means at the end of 有恥且格: set right, arrive at the good, come, be reverent (恪), or change (革). Quoted
- 2.7 The Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) reads the two 養 of this passage in… Quoted
- 2.10 Is 以 here "to use, put to use" (用) or "to do" (爲)? Does 由 mean the course a man has passed along (his track record), or the source his intention comes from? Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) warns against judging a man by his present… Quoted
- 2.20 Does the Master give 康子 a method for producing these effects, or name duties whose effects come unsought? This decides how each measure bears on its effect (the three 則), not what 孝 means or where the last clause breaks. Quoted
- 2.23 朱熹 explains 馬融's terms for what was reduced and added Quoted
八佾 Book 3 · Bā Yì 3
- 3.5 Which way does the comparison run, and how are 有, 亡 and the two 之 phrases read: are the 夏 without rulers better or worse off than the 夷 and 狄 with them; do 有 and 亡 mean honoring and disowning the ruler; is 亡 "perish"; do 有 and 亡 mean having a worthy ruler, or a titled ruler and one who has lost his land; or are 夷狄之 and 諸夏之 the Annals' verdicts "treat as 夷狄" and "treat as 夏"? (Which peoples 夷狄 names is asked on 夷狄 itself.) Quoted
- 3.11 What does the palm image say is easy: the world's affairs, for one who knows the di, or knowing the di itself, which the pointing at his palm shows? (What 示 means is asked on 如示諸斯.) Quoted
- 3.26 Does 何以觀之 ask by what his conduct could still be judged, or say the sight is not worth looking at or esteeming? Quoted
里仁 Book 4 · Lǐ Rén 4
- 4.5 Is 去仁 the casting off of humaneness to chase riches, so that 君子去仁 continues the saying on riches and poverty, or does it open a separate saying on never leaving humaneness? Quoted
- 4.11 Is 刑 the law with its penalties, or the established models (典刑) one imitates? Who are 君子 and 小人 (two kinds of person, or ruler and people), whose are the 德 and 刑 (the gentleman's own, or those above), and how do the halves relate: side by side, explaining each other, or, for 王闓運, the ruler's care that penalties fit winning the people to his kindly rule? Quoted
- 4.15 Are loyalty and reciprocity the one thread itself, terms borrowed to make it plain, or a lower answer for disciples who could not grasp it? Quoted
- 4.25 What are the "neighbors" virtue is sure to have: people its virtue draws, worthy neighbors who nurture it, requital, or even unlike others won over? 皇侃 and 陳天祥 both tie the neighbors to 5.3, where the Master says of 子賤 Quoted
公冶長 Book 5 · Gōngyě Cháng 5
- 5.14 程樹德 observes that this is the only chapter of the Analects that records the good conduct… Quoted
- 5.20 Is 三 the plain count three, set against the 再 "twice" that follows, or, as 陳天祥 argues from an old reading of it in the departing tone, does it mean that 文子 deliberated more than three times? The Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) also reads 三 in the departing tone, which is the reading 程樹德 rejects, but 朱熹's own words, 每事必三思, don't say whether he means more than three times. What Confucius's reply says of 文子 is decided under 再. What does Confucius's "twice" say of 文子: enough for a worthy man; a jibe that a third deliberation breeds selfish motives; a check on 文子's own excess; or a verdict on the praise of him, granting him two deliberations or denying he managed even two? Whether 三 is a strict count is decided under 三. Sent as envoy to 晉, 文子 first asked for the rites to use if he met with a death, and took… Quoted
- 5.21 What kind of "stupidity" did 武子 show when the state lacked the Way: feigned dullness that hides his ability, or devoted service in danger that only looks foolish? 武子 served Duke Chéng of Wèi (衛成公), who lost his state for a time and later recovered it Quoted
- 5.22 Does 簡 mean "great" (孔安國), "careless in affairs" (朱熹), or stand for 獧, "the scrupulous"? Is 斐然成章 praise, a pattern already formed and worth seeing, or blame: reckless compositions, or mere patterned writing made into chapters? This decides whether the Master is longing for the ardent or curbing them. Whose not knowing is it? Do the young men not know how to trim their work, or does Confucius say that he does not know how to cut them to shape? Quoted
- 5.26 Is 施勞 "displaying one's own merit", a second clause against self-display beside 伐善, or "laying toilsome tasks on others"? Whose act is each clause: does Confucius give the aged rest, keep faith with friends and cherish the young (之 = them), or do the aged rest in him, friends trust him and the young cherish him (之 = me)? Quoted
雍也 Book 6 · Yōng Yě 3
- 6.10 What was 伯牛's illness: leprosy, as the old 漢 account has it, or something else? Why did Confucius take 伯牛's hand through the window instead of entering? Quoted
- 6.16 Does 不 govern the second 有 (lacking both qualities), or is 而有 "yet having" (lacking glibness but having beauty)? Two further readings keep the construal of the Collected Explanations of the Analects (集解) but change the referent (Duke Líng (靈公)) or the sense (a parable); a fifth reads "if not the one, then the other" and takes 免 as ridding the age of both. Quoted
- 6.19 Is the first 生 "being born", so that people are born upright, or "living" in the same sense as the second 生? And if it is living, is it living out one's natural span, or simply living among men in this world? Is 罔 deceit (falsifying the upright way), plain lack of uprightness, or one-sidedness, all yang or all yin? Quoted
述而 Book 7 · Shù Ér 6
- 7.2 What does 何有於我 say of the three practices: that only he has them, that they are easy, that he lacks them, that they are nothing special, or something else? And is 於 "in" or "like"? Quoted
- 7.12 Is 可 in 可求 (and in the matching 不可求) a matter of right (may one seek it?) or of fate (can seeking get it?), and is the first clause a real condition or a hypothetical? Quoted
- 7.22 Is 之 in 改之 the companion who falls short, whom I draw up with good and so reform, or the not-good, which I correct? Quoted
- 7.25 Is 行 conduct practiced outwardly, distinct from 忠 and 信 kept within as the root, or the general name for every good one does, so that 忠 and 信 fall inside it? Quoted
- 7.28 Is "I have none of this" modest speech, or a plain claim to be free of reckless making? Quoted
- 7.34 晁說之 says that people at the time were calling the Master a sage and humane, and that he… Quoted
泰伯 Book 8 · Tài Bó 6
- 8.2 吳棫 took these lines for the words of 曾子, but early sources give them to Confucius Quoted
- 8.3 程子, quoted in the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注), explains 免 through the… Quoted
- 8.11 朱熹 holds that the two vices always go together 吝 is the 吝 of 吝嗇, "stingy" Quoted
- 8.14 For a man out of office, what does 謀 bar: taking the business on himself (telling when asked is allowed), planning with intent to act (thinking and talking are not barred), laying down particular measures (general principles are not), or plain planning, so strictly that even thought should stay within one's post? Or is the saying an occasioned remark, not a settled rule? Quoted
- 8.17 Do both clauses concern one object, either learning still being pursued or learning already held? Or does 如不及 reach for the new while 失之 guards what is already learned? Quoted
- 8.20 Whose virtue is "the virtue of 周": King Wén's (文王), who held two-thirds of the realm and still served 殷, or the 周 house's under King 文 and King Wǔ (武王) alike? Which age was richest in talent? It turns on whether 際 is the 堯–舜 juncture or "after 唐 and 虞", and whether 於 means "compared with", "than", "in" or "and". Quoted
子罕 Book 9 · Zǐ Hǎn 4
- 9.1 Are the two 與 "and", listing 命 and 仁 with 利 as things seldom spoken of, or a verb or preposition ("grant to men", "side with", "follow", "together with") that changes how 命 and 仁 stand to 罕言? Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) lists sayings on the decree 王若虛, quoted by 陳天祥, holds that the Master did speak of profit, and often of humaneness… Quoted
- 9.8 What Confucius does to the two ends: brings them out, reaches to them, or first puts them back to the questioner. Quoted
- 9.13 Is 沽之哉, said twice, an assent, "Sell it!", or a rhetorical question, "How should I sell it?", declining to put the jade up for sale? Each reading takes both 沽之哉 the same way. Quoted
- 9.30 Is 權 a departure from the constant norm (經) that still ends in accord with the Way, as the 漢 reading has it, or a weighing of light and heavy that never reverses the norm? This decides what 權 means; whether the received order of the steps stands is decided on 可與共學,未可與適道;可與適道,未可與立;可與立,未可與權. Quoted
鄉黨 Book 10 · Xiāng Dǎng 4
- 10.2 Is his manner with the senior grandees (誾誾) centered and correct, genial yet remonstrating, or harmonious and glad? The same two words describe disciples in 11.13 Quoted
- 10.8 Does 不及亂 let him drink to intoxication short of unruly conduct, or does 亂 cover any disturbance drink brings, so that he stopped at mellowness? Quoted
- 10.10 Do 語 and 言 name two different kinds of speech (replying to others against speaking for oneself), or is the change of word only a matter of style? Quoted
- 10.16 To whom did Confucius say "I, Qiū, do not yet understand it; I dare not taste it" (丘未達,不敢嘗): to the giver, through the messenger who came, or to others after he had withdrawn, with the record compressing the scene into a single 曰? Confucius calls himself 丘 before his disciples elsewhere too Tasting a gift of food was part of the rite Quoted
先進 Book 11 · Xiān Jìn 3
- 11.12 What "life" must one know first: how life comes to be, how to conduct one's life, or, for 康有爲, where life comes from in the cycle of rebirth? Quoted
- 11.21 陳天祥, in Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑), reads this passage with 15.23 and… Quoted
- 11.24 Whom the two would follow in 從之者: the Jì clan (季氏) they serve, or anyone at all. This also decides whether the Master's reply about regicide is aimed at the 季. Quoted
顏淵 Book 12 · Yán Yuān 5
- 12.7 In 民無信不立, is 信 the people's own good faith and 立 their standing, or the government's being trusted by the people and 立 the state's standing? In the earlier 民信之 all take the people as trusting the ruler. Quoted
- 12.8 Is 惜乎夫子之說君子也 one clause, regretting how 棘子成 speaks of the gentleman? Or does 君子也 judge his words to be a gentleman's? 朱熹 says 棘子成 spoke because he hated the excess of ornament in his day 陳天祥 says the warning has the same sense as 19.25 Quoted
- 12.12 Is 片言 one party's plea, heard without the other side's, or half a statement: the few words 子路 speaks, which men accept before he finishes? Does 折 mean to decide the case, or to break down a guilty man's false plea so that he submits? Whether 子路 is the judge or a party to the suit is a separate question, about the whole phrase 片言可以折獄. Quoted
- 12.22 What had 樊遲 failed to grasp, and why: only the point of 知人, how all-embracing love and discriminating knowledge fit together, or the method of practicing both — or was the trouble his times, when hereditary ministers kept rulers from appointing the men they knew? Does "make the crooked upright" (使枉者直) speak of humaneness, so that the reply covers both 仁 and 知, or is it only the effect of knowing others? The readings differ on how the crooked are made upright: transformed, or spurred by the choice of the upright. 朱熹 says 子夏 marveled because the words embrace more than wisdom (歎其所包者廣,不止言知). Quoted
- 12.23 In 善道之, is 道 the verb 導, to guide or lead him, or does it simply mean to speak to him (言)? Quoted
子路 Book 13 · Zǐ Lù 3
- 13.1 Is 先 "first" (first guide them by virtue), "go before them" in one's own person, "put one's own toil first", or, with 先之勞之 read as one clause (俞樾), going before the people in the same act as taking on their toil? And so what does 之 stand for? Quoted
- 13.21 Is the 狷 man one whose knowledge falls short but who holds fast more than enough (朱熹), or one whose temperament makes him decline things he is able to do, which has nothing to do with knowledge (陳天祥)? This also decides the repeat in 狷者. 陳天祥 argues from 有所不為 that it means refraining by choice (能爲而不爲), and he says that 朱熹's "knowledge falls short" (知未及) would make it refraining for want of ability. 朱熹 himself does not gloss 有所不為. Quoted
- 13.23 Is 同 simply being alike, with petty men liking the same things, or fawning conformity to others? The same question governs the repeat in 小人同. 陳天祥's Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) finds the gloss of 和 in the Collected… Quoted
憲問 Book 14 · Xiàn Wèn 6
- 14.10 陳天祥 finds 朱熹's note, that poverty is hard to live in and wealth easy, silent on… Quoted
- 14.12 Who speaks the words after this 曰, and does this 曰 belong in the text? The Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) glosses it as Confucius speaking again, yet cites 胡寅 for 子路, adding "whether this is so is unclear". Quoted
- 14.16 In 如其仁 (said twice; the repeat reads alike), does 如 mean "be a match for" (with "who" understood), "nearly, resembling", or "this was" (乃), or is 如其仁 a provisional, noncommittal expression? And is 其 管仲 or 召忽? Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) calls this second 曰 superfluous Quoted
- 14.17 Do the common man and woman who keep petty faith and hang themselves unknown stand for 召忽, who died for Prince Jiū (公子糾), or for nameless people? Quoted
- 14.24 What do "for oneself" (為己) and "for others" (為人) contrast: practice against mere talk, inner attainment against reputation, one's own person against borrowed learning, or governing oneself against governing others? Quoted
- 14.32 Does 棲棲 picture Confucius hurrying from state to state with no settled place (皇皇), clinging in attachment (依依), as the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) glosses it, or, for 俞樾, a groomed and dignified bearing (濟濟)? 畝 calls Confucius by his personal name, 丘 Quoted
衛靈公 Book 15 · Wèi Líng Gōng 3
- 15.10 Do 賢 "worthy", said of the great officers, and its counterpart 仁 "humane", said of the officers, differ in sense, or are they one sense, the change of word being mere variation? Quoted
- 15.12 Is 遠 "far" in space or far in time? The paired 近 splits the same way: trouble right at hand, or trouble soon. Quoted
- 15.25 Whose straight way is it, and what is "straight"? 馬融 and those after him: the Three Dynasties' rulers, in dealing with this people. 陳天祥: a separate saying in which the people walked it themselves. 郭象: the straight way is leaving all to the world without intent. 簡朝亮: the people's own, born straight and shown in their impartial verdicts on men, today as of old. Quoted
季氏 Book 16 · Jì Shì 1
陽貨 Book 17 · Yáng Huò 5
- 17.3 Whether 不移 says the lowest stupid cannot be moved, or only that they are not moved, by their own refusal, though they could be. Quoted
- 17.5 Promise or refusal, and which 東周? A 周 revived here in the east; the decayed Eastern 周, which with 其 or 乎 as denial he would not make; 成周, which with 爲 in the departing tone (as 鄭叔友 also reads it), "assist", he would help; a rival 周 he would not set up; King Píng's (平王) restoration; or 費 raised up as a new 周, as Kings Wén (文王) and Wǔ (武王) rose from 豐 and 鎬. 公山弗擾 was steward (宰) of the Jì clan (季氏), says 孔安國 Why did he wish to go? 程子, in the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注), says the… Quoted
- 17.12 What is soft within the man stern in look: a fawning heart, so that he is a hidden flatterer, or plain weakness, so that he is a coward behind his severity? Is 小人 the common people, from whom the wall-boring thief is drawn? Or is it the morally petty, of whom the thief is one kind? 孔安國's and 皇侃's bare 小人 (a small man with a thief's heart, a small man stealing) decide neither. Is 窬 "to climb over" a wall, so that 穿窬 names two kinds of break-in? Or is it an opening (= 竇) that the thief bores through, so that 穿窬 is one act? Every reading takes 穿 as "bore through". The closing gloss in 皇侃's Subcommentary (皇疏), "窬 means a hole" (窬,竇也), comes after 江熙's words and may be his or 皇侃's. 陳天祥 glosses 諸 as 之, "him", and restates 譬諸 as 譬之於, "to liken him to" Quoted
- 17.14 Who casts off whom in 德之棄? Men of virtue may cast off the man who repeats on the road what he heard there (德 = the virtuous), he may cast off his own virtue, or (皇侃) both may be true at once. 陳天祥's "old subcommentary" (舊疏) is worded differently from Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) printed here and lacks its clause on casting off one's own virtue; 梁章鉅 replies by citing Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary. Quoted
- 17.16 Is 疾 a one-sided endowment of vital energy, an inborn temperament (朱熹), or a blemish in the people's conduct that follows the customs of the age (陳天祥)? Quoted
微子 Book 18 · Wēi Zǐ 1
子張 Book 19 · Zǐ Zhāng 2
- 19.4 What are the "small ways": the rival schools' doctrines, useful crafts such as farming and divination, or skills and arts short of the great Way? 焦循's claim that the gentleman shuns clinging rather than the small ways turns on how he reads 泥. 陳天祥 traces 朱熹's counting of farming and gardening among the small ways to 13.4, where the… Quoted
- 19.18 The Discerning Doubts in the Four Books (四書辨疑) gives two answers to why it was hard Quoted
堯曰 Book 20 · Yáo Yuē 2
Connected
Named in this entry
Named in the entries for