Commentator · Liang
皇侃 Huáng Kǎn
His subcommentary was lost in China and recovered from a Japanese copy. Checked by a machineChecked 2 times by machine, most recently on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeI checked the hook for 皇侃 against what I know of its subject, and the claim is right.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeI checked the hook against what I know of 皇侃. It is accurate.How this was made
Author of Subcommentary on the Analects (論語義疏 Lún Yǔ Yì Shū), lost in China and recovered from Japan; it preserves many lost early commentaries. Checked by a machineChecked by a machine on 13 Nov 2026.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledge of the person, against taxonomy.roles"Commentator" fits Huang Kan (Huáng Kǎn), author of the 論語義疏 ("Subcommentary").Earlier versions · changed since validatedClaude Opus 5.5 machine · 13 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeChecked the name, romanization, dates (488–545), dynasty, works and identity of 皇侃 against my own knowledge, and the pinyin of the tokens. All of it checks out.Claude Opus 5.5 machine · 12 Nov 2026ConfirmedChecked against own knowledgeChecked the name Huang Kan, the dates (488–545), the dynasty and the identification in the line, including the works named and their pinyin; all of it agrees with the standard record.How this was made
In the disputes
- 373 disputes in this site's data with a reading of 皇侃's
- 50 where 皇侃 holds a reading no one else here shares
- 15 of 123 disputes 程樹德 judges where his verdict favors 皇侃
Characteristic readings
Where 皇侃 holds a reading no one else here shares, holds an outlier reading, or 程樹德's verdict favors 皇侃. Deep divides first. Each opens the dispute on its passage.
- 1.12Does 有所不行 complete 小大由之 (ritual alone fails) or open the next clause (harmony alone fails)?
- 2.5What 無違 tells 孟懿子 not to go against: anything at all, principle, ritual, his father's charge to learn ritual, or, with 違 also meaning to fall short, anything owed to parents
- 2.16Is 已 a final particle, or the verb "to stop"?
- 4.26What 數, here and in the friends clause, means: doing too often (in remonstrance, or in any dealings), counting up one's merits, counting out a man's faults to his face, or 僭, lacking trust.
- 9.23Does 聞 mean being heard of in the world (repute), or having heard the Way?
- 13.3What 名 does Confucius mean to rectify (and so the later 名): the names of all affairs, written graphs, or the titles confounded in 衛's succession? Under the graphs reading, 言 (in 言不順 and the rest) becomes written sentences. How he would have rectified them, by installing Prince Yǐng (公子郢) or by reconciling father and son, is a dispute of method, not of the words.
Reads most differently from
孔廣森 Kǒng Guǎngsēn · 1752–1786 (birth also given as 1753) 82% differ
- 2.16What are the 異端, the "differing ends"?Deep divide
- 11.20Does the reply describe the good man, who does not merely (or need not) follow the old tracks yet does not enter the chamber, or set a condition: if he does not tread the tracks, he cannot enter either? If it describes him, does he go beyond the tracks by founding something new, or need no tracks because of himself he does no evil? What Zizhang asked is decided at 之道.Deep divide
- 11.20What did 子張 ask: the conduct by which a man counts as good, the course a good man should take, or (if 之道 is an interpolation) simply about the good man?Deep divide
- 15.3What does Confucius's "No" (非也) deny: that he learns much at all, or only that learning much and keeping it in mind is his way?Deep divide
- 15.3What is the one, and what is it to thread? Readers name a single root, one principle reached by long study, a method of learning, practice, reciprocity with others, innate knowledge, or unmixed virtue. Whether 非也 denies learning much is decided at 非.Deep divide
- 9.27Are the ode lines the Master's own citation in praise of 子路, or the start of a separate record of the lines 子路 recited?Minor split
- 10.4Is the place he resumed the ruler's empty place, passed on entering, or his own station among the officials?Minor split
- 10.5Is 享禮 one rite, the presentation of gifts that follows the mission, or two: the presentation (享) and the host's entertaining the guest with sweet wine (禮)?Minor split
- 16.12What 斯 "this" in 其斯之謂與 points to: virtue, as the two cases show it; a saying lost from before the line; or the lines of 16.11 on seeking one's aim. The 德/得 variant in 民無德而稱焉 depends on the answer.Minor split
李翱 Lǐ Áo · 772–836 (death also dated 838 or 841) 82% differ
- 2.4Is Heaven's decree one's fated lot, the principle behind things, union with Heaven's virtue, or Heaven's charge to oneself?Deep divide
- 14.24What do "for oneself" (為己) and "for others" (為人) contrast: practice against mere talk, inner attainment against reputation, one's own person against borrowed learning, or governing oneself against governing others?Deep divide
- 14.37Are 作者 those who took up the withdrawals just described, or men who acted and created? Which seven men they were is decided under 七人.Deep divide
- 1.13Does 復 mean carrying out one's word, going back over it, or returning to the root?Minor split
- 2.11What 故 and 新 are, and whether the new comes out of the old.Minor split
- 10.6Which day is 吉月: the first of each month, any day of auspicious rites, a miscopy of 告月 (the temple court, or, for 俞樾, the officials' notice of the coming new moon), or the New Year month?Minor split
- 15.6What does 參 mean in 見其參於前? The candidates are standing thick (森), the team's side horses (驂), joining oneself (相參), squarely facing one (直), or, by emendation to 厽, piled up (絫).Minor split
- 19.11Is 閑 "law, rule", or a barrier marking a limit that one goes out and in across?Minor split
- 19.19What 情 is and what one must not be pleased at: the facts of an offense and one's skill in getting them, or the plight of the scattered people and the punishing of them.Minor split
鄭汝諧 Zhèng Rǔxié · 1126–1205 80% differ
- 2.5What 無違 tells 孟懿子 not to go against: anything at all, principle, ritual, his father's charge to learn ritual, or, with 違 also meaning to fall short, anything owed to parentsDeep divide
- 11.1Are "rustics" and "gentlemen" Confucius's own description of the two cohorts, the labels his contemporaries gave them, or the classes that rites and music reached in each age?Deep divide
- 11.21Is 與 the question particle (歟), with the passage joined to 11.20 and naming three kinds of good man? Or is it the verb "side with, approve", making this a separate saying against judging men by their talk? Whether 色莊 is a virtue or a façade is a separate question.Deep divide
- 14.12Who speaks the words after this 曰, and does this 曰 belong in the text? The Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) glosses it as Confucius speaking again, yet cites 胡寅 for 子路, adding "whether this is so is unclear".Deep divide
- 4.25What are the "neighbors" virtue is sure to have: people its virtue draws, worthy neighbors who nurture it, requital, or even unlike others won over?Minor split
- 6.28Does 厭 mean cast off, stop up, press down (read 壓), crush as a nightmare does, or weary of? Whom Heaven acts on follows from the readings of 否.Minor split
- 16.12What 斯 "this" in 其斯之謂與 points to: virtue, as the two cases show it; a saying lost from before the line; or the lines of 16.11 on seeking one's aim. The 德/得 variant in 民無德而稱焉 depends on the answer.Minor split
- 18.1What was the Viscount of 微's leaving: going over from 殷 to 周, quitting the court for his own fief, or quitting his post and fleeing? All read 去 as leaving; they differ on what the leaving was. (No one glosses the 之 of 去之 separately.)Minor split
Reads most like
包咸 Bāo Xián · c. 6 BCE–65 CE 93% alike
- 2.8Whose countenance is hard: the parents' looks the son must follow, or the son's own face?Deep divide
- 4.22Does 出 mean words coming out (being spoken), overstepping in general (管同), or going out of one's station (出位, 王闓運)?Deep divide
- 11.1Who are the "earlier" and "later" to rites and music (先進, 後進): generations of officers, men studying, ages of antiquity, the Master's disciples, or men who reached office by different roads?Deep divide
- 11.1Are "rustics" and "gentlemen" Confucius's own description of the two cohorts, the labels his contemporaries gave them, or the classes that rites and music reached in each age?Deep divide
- 11.26What is Dian describing: bathing and taking the breeze on a spring outing, a rain sacrifice, an offering of food, or going along the river?Deep divide
- 12.10Is wishing a man's life or death itself the delusion, since fate decides it, or does the delusion lie in loving and then hating the same man?Deep divide
- 14.37Are 作者 those who took up the withdrawals just described, or men who acted and created? Which seven men they were is decided under 七人.Deep divide
- 15.25Who made the trial, and on whom? 包咸, 皇侃 and 朱熹: Confucius tests the man he praises. 毛奇齡: the chapter is about raising and setting aside officials, who are tried before use. 包慎言 (drawing on 班固's Book of Hàn (漢書) treatise): the three dynasties already made the trial on this people, and the next sentence states it.Deep divide
- 15.26Is the horse clause a second practice Confucius saw, a simile, a figure for a fault, or the very 闕文 the first clause names (劉安世), and so what does 今亡 say? Those who take it as a practice also split on its purpose: training or sharing. 葉夢得's suspicion, reported by 翟灝, that the seven characters are interpolated is a textual question, not a construal.Deep divide
- 15.33What does 之 refer to in 知及之 and in the 之 that follow 守, 得, 失 and the repeated 知及之, 仁能守之? Is it the office gained, the moral principle, or the people? 朱熹 also takes 涖之 and 動之 as the people.Deep divide
- 18.8Does 放言 mean setting speech aside, no longer talking of the world's affairs, or giving free rein to speech?Deep divide
- 20.1Promise or warning? 困窮 can be "reach to the utmost" or "distress and want", and 永終 "long endure" or "end forever"; the readings pair them differently.Deep divide
- 1.5Is 使民以時 about timing public labor to spare farm work, or employing people in every task at its season?Minor split
- 2.7Who supports whom: do dogs and horses serve men, get fed by men, support their own kind, or stand for people?Minor split
- 3.22What 管仲's 三歸 were: wives, a terrace, a terrace that housed the wives, a fief, sacrificial victims, a treasury, or a household with three establishmentsMinor split
- 4.18Is 幾 the manner of the remonstrance (faint, gentle) or its moment (at the first faint sign of a fault)?Minor split
- 4.22Is 言 the words one speaks, or doctrine expounded and committed to writing?Minor split
- 6.1Whose seat 南面 names: a feudal lord's, the Son of Heaven's, or that of any office-holder who presides over the people. This decides what office Confucius says 雍 was fit for.Minor split
- 6.7What do the "three months" say about 顏回: a long but finite stretch in which his mind still sometimes strays, a span that shows a constancy lasting all his life, or no counted span at all but a figure for a mind standing firm?Minor split
- 6.20What is the "it" (之) in all four places, the thing one knows, loves and delights in: learning (學問), or "this Way" (此道), which 朱熹's Classified Conversations (語類) speaks of as "this principle" (此理)?Minor split
- 7.1Who is 老彭: one man or two, and which? A worthy of 商, 彭祖, 老耼 with 彭祖, 老子 himself, or a place at 老子's side?Minor split
- 7.28Is the 作 done without knowing the composing of writings and doctrines, or any action at all?Minor split
- 8.13What do 危 and 亂 name? For 包咸, disorder (亂) is regicide and parricide, and danger (危) is its omen. For 朱熹, disorder is misrule, and danger is the peril in which a man in office must give his life. Both take 不入 as declining to go there from outside and 不居 as leaving.Minor split
- 9.10When he passes them, does 趨 mean that he quickens his pace, or that he goes up to them?Minor split
- 10.4Whose place did he pass: the ruler's empty standing place at court, the ministers' ranked positions in the courtyard, or, at a state mission, the host ruler's place in the temple courtyard? 鄭玄's note, "where the ruler bows", is claimed for all three.Minor split
- 15.6What does 參 mean in 見其參於前? The candidates are standing thick (森), the team's side horses (驂), joining oneself (相參), squarely facing one (直), or, by emendation to 厽, piled up (絫).Minor split
- 15.6Which part of the chariot is the 衡 that the virtues lean on: the yoke (軛), or the crossbar at the carriage front (式)?Minor split
- 15.26Is 史 the scribe, the officer in charge of writing, or, as 宋翔鳳 suggests, the writing of graphs itself, of the kind of the 漢 史書 and 史篇, rather than a chronicle? Both sides take 闕文 as a blank left for a graph that was not known.Minor split
- 16.1Is 相 an assistant or minister in general, one who supports his lord, or specifically the attendant who leads a blind man?Minor split
- 18.7What the old man carried on his staff: a bamboo basket, or a field implement for weeding.Minor split
孔安國 Kǒng Ānguó · fl. 2nd c. BCE 87% alike
- 1.7Does 易色 mean trading love of beauty for love of worth, changing one's facial expression, or making light of beauty? This settles what 易 and 色 mean.Deep divide
- 1.7Whose worth and whose looks: is the clause a maxim for everyone about regard for worthy men, or a precept for husband and wife, a mate valued for virtue over looks?Deep divide
- 3.7Does 必也射乎 name archery as the one place the junzi contends, the place his freedom from contention shows most, or (with a stop after 必也, which then closes the clause before it) the place where others' contention is seen?Deep divide
- 3.13Whom do the 奧 and the stove stand for, and what is 賈 after when he quotes the saying?Deep divide
- 3.18Is 以為 "regard as", so that men mistake full ritual service for flattery, or "use as, make into", so that men turn ritual itself into a means of flattery?Deep divide
- 3.25Why is the 武 not yet perfectly good?Deep divide
- 4.6Whose person is shielded, and from what: inhumane people's wrongs against the hater himself, their harm to the humane man, or (with 其為仁矣 read as "the way he practices ren") inhumane deeds touching his own person?Deep divide
- 4.7Is 黨 a man's class or kind, or his partiality for those close to him; and is the 仁 that observing faults reveals the observer's, the erring man's, or (仁 read as 人) simply the man?Deep divide
- 11.20Does the reply describe the good man, who does not merely (or need not) follow the old tracks yet does not enter the chamber, or set a condition: if he does not tread the tracks, he cannot enter either? If it describes him, does he go beyond the tracks by founding something new, or need no tracks because of himself he does no evil? What Zizhang asked is decided at 之道.Deep divide
- 11.26In 毋吾以也, is 以 "on account of" (do not hold back because I am older) or "employ" (no one employs me)?Deep divide
- 12.12Is 片言 one party's plea, heard without the other side's, or half a statement: the few words 子路 speaks, which men accept before he finishes?Deep divide
- 14.24What do "for oneself" (為己) and "for others" (為人) contrast: practice against mere talk, inner attainment against reputation, one's own person against borrowed learning, or governing oneself against governing others?Deep divide
- 14.35What does 下學而上達 describe: studying human affairs and coming to know Heaven's decree; plain self-cultivation that of itself reaches what is above; Confucius's work on the Spring and Autumn (or on all the classics) reaching up to Heaven; or a commoner's praise and blame reaching the kingly way of governing?Deep divide
- 15.16One clause or two? Either 不曰 governs both cries and 者 marks the man who does not say the doubled cry, or the line breaks after the first 如之何 and 如之何者 marks the point at which the cry is raised (孔安國: the calamity already formed). 梁章鉅 takes the quotation in the Luxuriant Dew of the Spring and Autumn Annals (春秋繁露), "a man who does not say 'What is to be done, what is to be done?'" (人而不曰「如之何,如之何」者), to be presumably the source of the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注); 程樹德 reads 陸賈's 無如之何者 as one clause too.Deep divide
- 16.2Is 議 the commoners' criticism of the government, which they have no cause for when the Way prevails (孔安國), or planning state policy, which under the Way commoners take no part in because worthies hold office (方觀旭)? 方觀旭 also takes 庶人 more widely, to include clerks, runners and even retainers.Deep divide
- 17.3Whether 不移 says the lowest stupid cannot be moved, or only that they are not moved, by their own refusal, though they could be.Deep divide
- 18.5Is the couplet about Confucius' own course, past and to come, or about the past and coming ages? And does the second line say he can still turn back, ask a question that expects no, or promise that the coming age can still be put in order (追 = "put in order" (治))?Deep divide
- 19.14What 而止 rules out: grief run to excess that harms the mourner (孔安國), or mourning carried past grief into ritual form and ornament (楊時, 朱熹). 朱熹 then faults 子游's 而止 itself as too lofty and as slighting fine detail.Deep divide
- 20.3What 命 is: the allotted lot of straits and success, or the nature Heaven confers on man. 黄式三 and 李顒 hold the two together.Deep divide
- 1.11Is 三年 the literal three-year mourning term, or a stock number for "a long time" that could stretch to a lifetime?Minor split
- 1.15Does the poor man delight in the Way (the Old Analects text reads 樂道), simply delight (the 魯 text's bare 樂), or love music (樂)?Minor split
- 3.12Which spirits does 祭神 name: the hundred spirits in general, or the household gods a great officer sacrificed to? (Whether the couplet records Confucius's own practice or quotes an old saying is asked on the two lines together.)Minor split
- 3.18Whose service is meant: anyone who serves his ruler with the full rites, or Confucius himself?Minor split
- 3.21Are pine, cypress and chestnut the trees planted at the altars, or the woods of the altar tablets?Minor split
- 5.19What does 未知 say: that the Master does not know whether the man had ren, that the man was not yet wise (知 read as 智), or that the Master knew nothing of these old events and so would not judge? The same question governs the second 未知, said of 陳文子.Minor split
- 5.26Is 無憾 the owner's freedom from resentment when friends wear out his things, or, as 殷仲堪 puts it, using friends' things as one's own with no sense of obligation arising, which he calls the height of friendship?Minor split
- 6.26Is the 仁 in "there is 仁 in the well" a humane man, a stand-in for 人 "a person", or humaneness itself, the chance to rescue?Minor split
- 7.16Does 疏 here mean vegetables (some copies write 蔬) or coarse grain? And if it is grain, is it 糲 rice or 稷, which 程瑤田 and 劉寶楠 identify as sorghum?Minor split
- 7.28Next to what knowing: the born knower's, true knowledge of principle, the composing sage's, or the mind's own innate knowing?Minor split
- 8.20Which age was richest in talent? It turns on whether 際 is the 堯–舜 juncture or "after 唐 and 虞", and whether 於 means "compared with", "than", "in" or "and".Minor split
邢昺 Xíng Bǐng · 932–1010 85% alike
- 1.12Is 和 music, the partner that ritual needs, or the unhurried ease of ritual's own working?Deep divide
- 1.12Does 有所不行 complete 小大由之 (ritual alone fails) or open the next clause (harmony alone fails)?Deep divide
- 2.16What are the 異端, the "differing ends"?Deep divide
- 3.18Is 以為 "regard as", so that men mistake full ritual service for flattery, or "use as, make into", so that men turn ritual itself into a means of flattery?Deep divide
- 6.28Is 否 the plain "not" of a conditional oath, a noun for wrongdoing, or 否 "blocked"; and if "not", what does it deny: the visit's purpose, doing what the moment asked, rectifying names, or what he disallows?Deep divide
- 7.17Whose faults, and of what kind: personal faults of conduct, the faults of students of the Changes (易), errors in Confucius's exposition of the Changes, overshooting the mean, or the hexagram Great Excess (大過)?Deep divide
- 9.22What do the stages of sprout, flower and grain stand for: a life cut off early (顏淵's), learning that stops short of completion, or literary flower without the fruit of conduct?Deep divide
- 9.23Does 聞 mean being heard of in the world (repute), or having heard the Way?Deep divide
- 9.23Who knows, and what is set against what: the young against Confucius as he is now, the young's future against today's hopes for them, or the days to come against today as a warning?Deep divide
- 10.17Does 不 negate 問馬 ("he did not ask about the horses"), close the Master's question as 否 ("hurt or not?"), or stand alone as the reply "No", after which he asked about the horses?Deep divide
- 10.27What the Master's 時哉 says: that the pheasant has its season while men do not, "so it is", or a warning that its moment is running out.Deep divide
- 11.1Who are the "earlier" and "later" to rites and music (先進, 後進): generations of officers, men studying, ages of antiquity, the Master's disciples, or men who reached office by different roads?Deep divide
- 11.1Are "rustics" and "gentlemen" Confucius's own description of the two cohorts, the labels his contemporaries gave them, or the classes that rites and music reached in each age?Deep divide
- 13.25Is 說 "to please" (悅), with others trying to win the gentleman over, or 說 "to speak", the gentleman's own speech, or 說 "to persuade"? The same question governs the other five 說 in the passage, and with it who acts in 說之不以道.Deep divide
- 14.12Who speaks the words after this 曰, and does this 曰 belong in the text? The Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) glosses it as Confucius speaking again, yet cites 胡寅 for 子路, adding "whether this is so is unclear".Deep divide
- 15.16One clause or two? Either 不曰 governs both cries and 者 marks the man who does not say the doubled cry, or the line breaks after the first 如之何 and 如之何者 marks the point at which the cry is raised (孔安國: the calamity already formed). 梁章鉅 takes the quotation in the Luxuriant Dew of the Spring and Autumn Annals (春秋繁露), "a man who does not say 'What is to be done, what is to be done?'" (人而不曰「如之何,如之何」者), to be presumably the source of the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注); 程樹德 reads 陸賈's 無如之何者 as one clause too.Deep divide
- 15.26Is the horse clause a second practice Confucius saw, a simile, a figure for a fault, or the very 闕文 the first clause names (劉安世), and so what does 今亡 say? Those who take it as a practice also split on its purpose: training or sharing. 葉夢得's suspicion, reported by 翟灝, that the seven characters are interpolated is a textual question, not a construal.Deep divide
- 19.11Who or what are 大德 and its pair 小德 (which splits the same way): men of greater and lesser virtue, the great and small points of a man's conduct, or the sage and the worthy whom a learner approaches?Deep divide
- 1.12Is 用 the "function" paired with ritual's "substance" (體), or simply the use of ritual in practice?Minor split
- 3.18Whose service is meant: anyone who serves his ruler with the full rites, or Confucius himself?Minor split
- 5.19What does 未知 say: that the Master does not know whether the man had ren, that the man was not yet wise (知 read as 智), or that the Master knew nothing of these old events and so would not judge? The same question governs the second 未知, said of 陳文子.Minor split
- 7.1Who is 老彭: one man or two, and which? A worthy of 商, 彭祖, 老耼 with 彭祖, 老子 himself, or a place at 老子's side?Minor split
- 7.17What does 五十 denote: Confucius's age, a miscopied 卒, a miscopied 吾 "I", the number fifty of the Changes (易), or "five or ten" years?Minor split
- 9.14Which peoples are the nine Yí (九夷): the 夷 of the east at large, the 夷 under 楚 near 陳 and 蔡, or small states by 魯 that had sunk to 夷 ways? (Who the gentleman is is decided under 君子.)Minor split
- 9.20Whose slackness does 不惰 deny: the Master's in speaking to 回, or 回's in receiving the words? And if 回's, is it slackness in hearing or in practice?Minor split
- 10.4Is the place he resumed the ruler's empty place, passed on entering, or his own station among the officials?Minor split
- 10.24Does 居 mean being at home, or sitting? 崔適 argues that 寢, only one part of home life, cannot be paired with home life as a whole.Minor split
- 10.24Is the word 容, formal bearing, or 客, the graph 陸德明 gives? The variant changes what he refrained from at home.Minor split
- 10.27Is 梁 a bridge on the hillside, or 粱, the millet the pheasant was eating as Confucius walked in the hills?Minor split
- 12.1What do 克 and 己 mean here: restraining one's person, overcoming selfish desire, reproaching oneself, taking a charge upon oneself, or, for 俞樾, being able (克 = "can" (能)) to bring one's person back to ritual? The question is the same for both occurrences of 克己.Minor split
Where readings diverge most in the commentary
A dispute counts when it has 2 or more readings. People are counted as reading differently when their readings are in different camps, and not when one of them holds only an outlier reading. Each person is listed on the side that wins in the disputes they share (at least 10), by its share of them.
Works by 皇侃
In 345 passages
Each row is a dispute or note that names 皇侃. It opens the passage on it.
學而 Book 1 · Xué Ér 15
- 1.1 What 時 in 時習 means: at set times, daily, constantly, or at the moment that fits. Who fails to know what in 人不知: others fail to recognize the gentleman, people fail to understand his teaching, or the rulers of the age fail to recognize Confucius. 說 here is the word later written 悅, "to delight" Own reading
- 1.2 Two definitions of 孝 stand side by side in the commentary: serving parents well, and the affection for kin that comes by nature. No commentator argues one against the other. Whether 犯上 means defying one's superiors, or confronting them with frank remonstrance, which a filial man does only reluctantly. What 為仁之本 claims, and which word carries the claim: 仁 (what humaneness is), 爲 (being it or practicing it), or 本 (a root, or a first stage). Mentioned
- 1.3 What 鮮 "seldom" leaves: a thin share of humaneness in each such man, a few such men truly humane, or, said gently, none at all. Mentioned
- 1.4 Whether 傳 is what I hand on to others, what I received from my teacher, or (as the 魯 text's 專) the specialty I profess. Mentioned
- 1.5 Is the 人 one loves the same as the 民 one employs, or a wider group? Is 使民以時 about timing public labor to spare farm work, or employing people in every task at its season? 皇侃 gives the Son of Heaven ten thousand chariots and the feudal lords a thousand… Own reading
- 1.6 At 7.25 the Master teaches "the refinements, conduct, loyalty and good faith" (文、行、忠、信)… Quoted
- 1.7 Is the first 賢 "to esteem as worthy", or "to surpass in worth"? This settles the verb only. Does 易色 mean trading love of beauty for love of worth, changing one's facial expression, or making light of beauty? This settles what 易 and 色 mean. Whose worth and whose looks: is the clause a maxim for everyone about regard for worthy men, or a precept for husband and wife, a mate valued for virtue over looks? Own reading
- 1.8 Does 不如己 rank people, and if so must a friend surpass you or merely equal you; or does it mean one not of your kind? Is 固 "benighted" (蔽), so that learning is the cure, or "firm" (堅固), so that a man without gravity learns nothing that holds? Does 主 mean "draw close to" people who are loyal and true, "lodge with them as host", or "take as mainstay" loyalty and good faith in oneself? Is 過 one's own fault, to be reformed, or a mistake in choosing a friend, undone by changing the friend? Own reading
- 1.9 Whether 終 is a death, to be met with care in mourning, or the end of any undertaking, to be handled as carefully as its start. Whether 追遠 is sacrifice to forebears long dead, or a general faithfulness that keeps long-past things and old ties in mind instead of forsaking them for the new. Mentioned
- 1.10 In 聞其政, does 聞 mean being made party to each state's government, consulted by its ruler, or coming to know what that government is like? In 抑與之與, does 與 mean "give" (was it given to him?) or "join with" (did the rulers take him in to govern alongside them)? Own reading
- 1.11 Is 三年 the literal three-year mourning term, or a stock number for "a long time" that could stretch to a lifetime? Taking 父之道 as the father's way that the son keeps, what does it cover: whatever he did, faults included; what should change but can wait; only a right way; or his government? When a ruler died, his heir kept the mourning silence (諒闇) and left government to the… Own reading
- 1.12 Is 用 the "function" paired with ritual's "substance" (體), or simply the use of ritual in practice? Is 和 music, the partner that ritual needs, or the unhurried ease of ritual's own working? Do 小 and 大 mean matters small and great, or small states and great states dealing with each other by ritual? Does 有所不行 complete 小大由之 (ritual alone fails) or open the next clause (harmony alone fails)? 由 means "to use" (用), as 邢昺 and 皇侃 gloss it Own reading
- 1.13 Does 復 mean carrying out one's word, going back over it, or returning to the root? What are 因 and 親 here: closeness kept with those one holds close, reliance on someone fit to be close to, marriage ties that keep one's proper kin, love built on the root of one's own kin, or building on the clauses before, with 親 as nearness to ritual and rightness or closeness to one's teacher? Or are those held close ruler, teacher and friend, who are not kin by birth? 皇侃 illustrates good faith that is not fitting with 尾生 皇侃 gives examples of deference that misses ritual and so brings disgrace Quoted
- 1.15 Does the poor man delight in the Way (the Old Analects text reads 樂道), simply delight (the 魯 text's bare 樂), or love music (樂)? What are 往 and 來: what was said and what was left unsaid, the Master's word and 子貢's reply, or the higher state and where it comes from? Mentioned
- 1.16 Should the second clause read 患不知人, "fret at not knowing others", or 患不知, "fret at one's own not knowing", with 人 treated as a later addition? Mentioned
為政 Book 2 · Wéi Zhèng 19
- 2.1 Does governing by virtue mean ruling by non-action, and is 德 the ruler's own virtue or the virtuous men he employs? Mentioned
- 2.2 Is 思 "thought" or only an opening particle; is 邪 depravity or "dawdling" (徐); and what is it that has no 邪: thinking itself, the Poems, the readers they shape, or the beholder's own mind? Mentioned
- 2.3 What 德 is here: moral virtue, a listed set of six virtues, or each person's getting his own nature. Is 禮 a set of institutions and graded distinctions, or the embodying of one's own feelings? Mentioned
- 2.4 Is the "I" Confucius' literal account of his own progress, or a pattern framed for learners? What did he stand firm in at thirty: accomplished learning, ritual, or his own footing? Is Heaven's decree one's fated lot, the principle behind things, union with Heaven's virtue, or Heaven's charge to oneself? Is 從 "to follow", read as written, or 縱 "to give the heart free rein"; and does the clause break after 欲, with 所欲 the object of 從, or after 心, making 所欲, "what he desired", the subject of 不踰矩? Wherever the clause breaks, what is the square (矩) he did not overstep: the standard in general, the reciprocal measure (絜矩), or the Mean handed down from 堯 and 舜? Does setting the will on learning at fifteen mean entering the greater learning (大學)? Fifteen was the age of the 成童, the full-grown youth Own reading
- 2.5 What 無違 tells 孟懿子 not to go against: anything at all, principle, ritual, his father's charge to learn ritual, or, with 違 also meaning to fall short, anything owed to parents Whether the threefold 以禮 is aimed at the three houses' usurpation of ritual Own reading
- 2.6 Whoever's illness is meant, is 疾 bodily illness only, or does it also take in moral failings: stalled virtue, bad company, flaws in word and deed? Who worries over whose illness, the parents over the son's or the son over his parents', and what does "only" ask of the son? Quoted
- 2.7 Who supports whom: do dogs and horses serve men, get fed by men, support their own kind, or stand for people? Quoted
- 2.8 Whose countenance is hard: the parents' looks the son must follow, or the son's own face? Is 曾 "then", read like 增, or "ever", read like 層? Own reading
- 2.9 What the Master saw after 回 withdrew: his private talks with fellow disciples, or his own conduct at leisure and alone? The first sentence can be broken in two places Mentioned
- 2.10 Is 以 here "to use, put to use" (用) or "to do" (爲)? Does 由 mean the course a man has passed along (his track record), or the source his intention comes from? 視, 觀 and 察 are three degrees of looking Quoted
- 2.11 Whatever the old (故) is, what does 溫 do to it: go over it and draw it out, reheat it, or store it up? A teacher of other men, or does this learning itself become one's teacher? What 故 and 新 are, and whether the new comes out of the old. Own reading
- 2.13 Who or what "follows": his own words coming after the deed, or later ages following his words? The Summary of the Rules of Propriety (曲禮) has the rule "no wasteful words" (不辭費) Quoted
- 2.14 What quality 周 names in contrast to 比: a moral virtue (loyalty and good faith), breadth of reach, completeness of principle, or close association grounded in what is right. 比 is not always bad Own reading
- 2.15 The Later Cases of Mr. Huáng (黃氏後案) takes 學 here as "reading books" (謂讀書也), the 學 of… 包咸 takes 罔 as "blank" (罔然) Quoted
- 2.16 Does 攻 mean to work at or study (治), to attack (攻擊), or to rub and polish into order (錯, 摩)? What are the 異端, the "differing ends"? Is 已 a final particle, or the verb "to stop"? Own reading
- 2.17 Whether Confucius offers to teach 子路 what knowing is, asks whether 子路 knows what he has been taught, or tells him to keep the teaching in mind. 女 here is the pronoun "you", the word also written 汝 Own reading
- 2.18 The Collected Interpretations of the Analects (集釋) doesn't mark where 皇侃's quotation of… Mentioned
- 2.20 What is the ruler's 孝 in 孝慈: filial devotion to his own parents, love for the people, or a miswritten graph? Mentioned
- 2.22 What is the 輗? It may be the crossbar at the end of the ox cart's shaft, or a pin that passes through the shaft end and fastens the crossbar. What is the 軏? It may be the upcurving hook at the end of the horse carriage's shaft, or a pin fixed at the shaft end that fastens the crossbar. Mentioned
八佾 Book 3 · Bā Yì 16
- 3.1 Book 3 is titled "Eight Rows" (八佾) after this passage Mentioned
- 3.3 Whether the saying speaks of any man without 仁, laments a non-humane man in power, or was aimed at the Jì clan's (季氏) usurpation of ritual and music Own reading
- 3.4 Is the "root" of ritual the plain substance that frugality and grief show, simply not failing, or an inner root such as humaneness? Own reading
- 3.5 Which way does the comparison run, and how are 有, 亡 and the two 之 phrases read: are the 夏 without rulers better or worse off than the 夷 and 狄 with them; do 有 and 亡 mean honoring and disowning the ruler; is 亡 "perish"; do 有 and 亡 mean having a worthy ruler, or a titled ruler and one who has lost his land; or are 夷狄之 and 諸夏之 the Annals' verdicts "treat as 夷狄" and "treat as 夏"? (Which peoples 夷狄 names is asked on 夷狄 itself.) Quoted
- 3.7 Does 必也射乎 name archery as the one place the junzi contends, the place his freedom from contention shows most, or (with a stop after 必也, which then closes the clause before it) the place where others' contention is seen? Does 下 close the first phrase (揖讓而升下, bowing on both ascent and descent) or open the second (下而飲, come down and then drink)? Archery marked a man's life from birth Quoted
- 3.8 Does Zixia "draw out" the Master by bringing out his meaning, or by saying something new to him? Does 後素 mean that the white is laid on last to finish the colors, or that painting comes after the plain ground? Quoted
- 3.12 Which spirits does 祭神 name: the hundred spirits in general, or the household gods a great officer sacrificed to? (Whether the couplet records Confucius's own practice or quotes an old saying is asked on the two lines together.) 皇侃 says the two lines are not Confucius's own words, and that they too were prompted by… Quoted
- 3.13 Was 賈 a man of 周 who came out to take office in 衛, or a native of 衛 whose clan name 王孫 goes back to 康叔? Whom do the 奧 and the stove stand for, and what is 賈 after when he quotes the saying? Mentioned
- 3.17 Who announces the new moon to whom: the lord in his temple, or the Son of Heaven to the lords? What was the 餼 sheep: a live victim, raw meat, or provisions for a royal envoy? Compare 10.6 Own reading
- 3.18 Whose service is meant: anyone who serves his ruler with the full rites, or Confucius himself? Is 以為 "regard as", so that men mistake full ritual service for flattery, or "use as, make into", so that men turn ritual itself into a means of flattery? Quoted
- 3.19 Are the two clauses conditional, the minister's loyalty answering the ruler's ritual, or two duties each side owes on its own? Own reading
- 3.20 Is 淫 joy carried past its measure, or wanton indulgence in the lady's beauty? (Whose joy the line means is asked on the whole line.) Is 傷 grief carried so far that it harms harmony, or a lessening of love? (Whose grief the line means, and the sense "harm done to the good" that comes with reading it as the consort's, is asked on the whole line.) Whose joy and grief does the line praise, and is 關雎 the ode or its music: the ode's own longing and fulfilment, a grief over the age, the 毛 and 魯 schools' two readings, a three-piece musical suite, the hearers' feelings, or the consort's as she seeks worthy women? (The senses of 淫 and 傷 are asked on those words; only the consort reading's 傷, harm done to the good, is decided here.) Mentioned
- 3.21 Are pine, cypress and chestnut the trees planted at the altars, or the woods of the altar tablets? 后 means "ruler" (君) Quoted
- 3.22 What 管仲's 三歸 were: wives, a terrace, a terrace that housed the wives, a fief, sacrificial victims, a treasury, or a household with three establishments Quoted
- 3.25 What does "perfectly beautiful" praise: the music's sound and form, or the change of rule's accord with the people? The second 盡美 is read the same way. Why is the 武 not yet perfectly good? Own reading
- 3.26 Does 何以觀之 ask by what his conduct could still be judged, or say the sight is not worth looking at or esteeming? Own reading
里仁 Book 4 · Lǐ Rén 13
- 4.2 In 知者利仁, is 利 to find humaneness advantageous, to crave it, or to practice it by effort rather than by nature? 包咸 says that only one whose nature is humane "embodies it of himself" (自然體之), and so… Quoted
- 4.3 Do 好人 and 惡人 mean judging what people love and hate, loving and hating along with people, or the humane person's own right loving and hating of people? Mentioned
- 4.5 Is 去仁 the casting off of humaneness to chase riches, so that 君子去仁 continues the saying on riches and poverty, or does it open a separate saying on never leaving humaneness? Own reading
- 4.6 What is it that nothing can surpass: the lover of ren and his virtue, or ren itself in his esteem? Are the one who loves ren and the one who hates its lack two different people, or one person? Whose person is shielded, and from what: inhumane people's wrongs against the hater himself, their harm to the humane man, or (with 其為仁矣 read as "the way he practices ren") inhumane deeds touching his own person? Own reading
- 4.7 Is 黨 a man's class or kind, or his partiality for those close to him; and is the 仁 that observing faults reveals the observer's, the erring man's, or (仁 read as 人) simply the man? Mentioned
- 4.11 Is the 惠 the small man cherishes some benefit for himself, or, as 俞樾 reads it, the kind ruler of another state, whom the people go over to when their own ruler turns to punishment? 包咸's gloss, kindness and favor, fits either side.) Who are 君子 and 小人 (two kinds of person, or ruler and people), whose are the 德 and 刑 (the gentleman's own, or those above), and how do the halves relate: side by side, explaining each other, or, for 王闓運, the ruler's care that penalties fit winning the people to his kindly rule? Compare 12.19 Mentioned
- 4.15 What 貫 means and what the "one" is: a governing principle, one mind, practice, reaching others, sincerity, or a source that branches out? Quoted
- 4.18 Is 幾 the manner of the remonstrance (faint, gentle) or its moment (at the first faint sign of a fault)? Is 勞 the son's own toil in remonstrating, his anxiety, hardship the parents inflict on him, or his urging them on? Compare 13.18 For a ruler, the 檀弓 gives the reverse rule A son's remonstrance has a set limit Own reading
- 4.19 Whether 方 means "constancy" (常) (his travels keep a fixed pattern), or direction: a declared destination he keeps to. The Summary of the Rules of Propriety (曲禮) gives the rule for a son Quoted
- 4.21 What the joy and the fear respond to, and whether they arise together or answer different cases. Own reading
- 4.22 Is 古者 the people of antiquity, with no period named, or specifically the people of the 殷 period? Is 言 the words one speaks, or doctrine expounded and committed to writing? Does 出 mean words coming out (being spoken), overstepping in general (管同), or going out of one's station (出位, 王闓運)? Quoted
- 4.25 Is virtue "not alone" because its possessor never lacks companions, or because a virtue never stands single, inner and outer virtue coming together? What are the "neighbors" virtue is sure to have: people its virtue draws, worthy neighbors who nurture it, requital, or even unlike others won over? 皇侃 and 陳天祥 both tie the neighbors to 5.3, where the Master says of 子賤 Own reading
- 4.26 What 數, here and in the friends clause, means: doing too often (in remonstrance, or in any dealings), counting up one's merits, counting out a man's faults to his face, or 僭, lacking trust. Own reading
公冶長 Book 5 · Gōngyě Cháng 16
- 5.1 Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) records a tale from a book called the Explanations of the… Quoted
- 5.2 Earlier expositors, 皇侃 reports, ranked one man above the other to explain why Confucius… Quoted
- 5.4 What calling 子貢 a 瑚璉 says of him: that he is the precious kind of vessel, or a precious vessel of narrow, temple-bound use and so not much to praise. Which dynasty used which name is not at issue here. Mentioned
- 5.6 Whose trust is 信: Kai's own assurance, the people's or the age's trust in him, or his trust in 魯's ruler? Quoted
- 5.7 Is riding a raft out to sea a real plan, and to where? A supposition that voices grief? Or a figure for the way's failing? (What 材 means is decided under 無所取材.) Mentioned
- 5.10 What did 宰予 do: sleep by day (a real lapse, or one staged to prompt teaching), have his chamber painted (晝 read 畫), limit his effort to rest, or keep to his inner chamber by day? Quoted
- 5.11 孔安國 glosses 慾 as "having many passions and desires" (多情慾), and 朱熹 as "having many… Quoted
- 5.12 What lies beyond 子貢's reach: stopping others from imposing on him, not imposing on others as spontaneous humaneness, or being faultless on both sides? (黄式三's answer, which follows from his sense of 加, is under 加.) Mentioned
- 5.13 What is the Master's 文章 that all could hear: his refinement made visible in bearing and speech, or the texts he taught? And if texts, all six books, or only the Odes, Documents, ritual and music? Mentioned
- 5.17 Who respects whom: does 之 point to the people 晏平仲 dealt with, or to 晏平仲 himself, as in the Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本) text 久而人敬之? (How time bears on respect is decided under 而.) 孫綽, quoted by 皇侃, says that in friendship some "meet once under a tilted carriage cover… Own reading
- 5.19 What does 未知 say: that the Master does not know whether the man had ren, that the man was not yet wise (知 read as 智), or that the Master knew nothing of these old events and so would not judge? The same question governs the second 未知, said of 陳文子. Quoted
- 5.20 What does Confucius's "twice" say of 文子: enough for a worthy man; a jibe that a third deliberation breeds selfish motives; a check on 文子's own excess; or a verdict on the praise of him, granting him two deliberations or denying he managed even two? Whether 三 is a strict count is decided under 三. Mentioned
- 5.23 伯夷 and 叔齊 were the two sons of the lord of 孤竹 孤竹, the brothers' state, lay in the north Quoted
- 5.25 Is 足 here "to excess" (deference overdone), the foot (deference acted out in bowing and side-stepping), or "to satisfy" (deference that pleases others against ritual)? Mentioned
- 5.26 Is 衣 the verb "to wear", read in the departing tone, governing 輕裘, or the noun "robes", read in the level tone, one item in the set phrase 車馬衣裘, with 輕 a later addition? Is 無憾 the owner's freedom from resentment when friends wear out his things, or, as 殷仲堪 puts it, using friends' things as one's own with no sense of obligation arising, which he calls the height of friendship? Whose act is each clause: does Confucius give the aged rest, keep faith with friends and cherish the young (之 = them), or do the aged rest in him, friends trust him and the young cherish him (之 = me)? Own reading
- 5.28 Does 焉 close the first sentence ("there are such people there"), or, read as 安 "how", does it open the second clause as a question? 孫綽, quoted by 皇侃, reads this saying with 6.3 and 11.7, "there was 顏回, who loved learning"… Mentioned
雍也 Book 6 · Yōng Yě 18
- 6.1 Whose seat 南面 names: a feudal lord's, the Son of Heaven's, or that of any office-holder who presides over the people. This decides what office Confucius says 雍 was fit for. Mentioned
- 6.2 What does the Master's 簡 pick out in 伯子: an unburdensome, lenient way of dealing with those below, the ground of his "he will do"; or a crude plainness lacking cultured pattern (文), which he means to correct? Mentioned
- 6.3 Why does Confucius name just these two qualities: as what 顏回's love of learning consisted in, or to lodge a veiled rebuke of Duke Āi's (哀公) own faults? Quoted
- 6.4 子華 was sent to 齊 because he had a fine bearing (有容儀), 皇侃 says Quoted
- 6.7 What do the "three months" say about 顏回: a long but finite stretch in which his mind still sometimes strays, a span that shows a constancy lasting all his life, or no counted span at all but a figure for a mind standing firm? Quoted
- 6.9 The stewards of 費 had a record of revolt Quoted
- 6.13 What does 儒 name here (and again in 小人儒): a man long steeped in learning, or a teacher of the people? Own reading
- 6.15 皇侃 notes that in the six classics horses only draw carriages, and no text speaks of… Quoted
- 6.16 Does 不 govern the second 有 (lacking both qualities), or is 而有 "yet having" (lacking glibness but having beauty)? Two further readings keep the construal of the Collected Explanations of the Analects (集解) but change the referent (Duke Líng (靈公)) or the sense (a parable); a fifth reads "if not the one, then the other" and takes 免 as ridding the age of both. Mentioned
- 6.19 Discourses Weighed in the Balance (論衡), in its chapter Luck and Chance (幸偶), gives… Mentioned
- 6.20 What are knowing, loving and delighting: three depths of one's bent toward learning, or the steps of self-cultivation in the Great Learning (大學)? 饒魯's allocation runs on to 好 and 樂. What is the "it" (之) in all four places, the thing one knows, loves and delights in: learning (學問), or "this Way" (此道), which 朱熹's Classified Conversations (語類) speaks of as "this principle" (此理)? Quoted
- 6.21 Is 以上 (with its parallel 以下) "above" (and "below") the middling man, naming men of other grades? Or is 以 read as 而 and 上 in the rising tone, so the clauses speak of the middling man himself as he goes up or goes down? Whether 中人 itself means 中知 or 中庸 is a separate dispute. 皇侃 records his teacher's scheme of nine grades of men (師說云) Quoted
- 6.22 How do 先 and 後 relate hardship and gain: a sequence (the hard first, the gain after), one's place relative to others, or setting the gain aside; and whose is the hardship, the humane man's own or, for 王闓運, the people's? Mentioned
- 6.23 陸特進, quoted by 皇侃, divides the saying into three parts 知 here stands for 智, "wise" Mentioned
- 6.25 In what respect is the second 觚 "not a gu" (觚不觚), and what does the sigh point at? Mentioned
- 6.26 Is the 仁 in "there is 仁 in the well" a humane man, a stand-in for 人 "a person", or humaneness itself, the chance to rescue? Does 可逝 allow only that the gentleman can be got to go to the well, or that he may go even to his death when principle makes it fitting, or is 逝 to be read as 折, "be broken"? The Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本) reads 井有仁者焉, with 者 after 仁, and ends the question with 與… Quoted
- 6.27 Is the 文 the gentleman studies broadly the writings of the classics, or the whole patterned order of human life, from one's own person out to the world? Does 之 in 約之以禮 refer to the gentleman himself, who binds his own person with ritual, or to the culture (文) he has broadly learned? Is 畔 a loan for 叛, turning against the Way; the 畔 of 偏畔, leaning off to one side, so that 弗畔 means keeping to the middle Way; or short for 畔喭, hard conduct that fails in ritual bearing? Own reading
- 6.28 Is 否 the plain "not" of a conditional oath, a noun for wrongdoing, or 否 "blocked"; and if "not", what does it deny: the visit's purpose, doing what the moment asked, rectifying names, or what he disallows? Does 厭 mean cast off, stop up, press down (read 壓), crush as a nightmare does, or weary of? Whom Heaven acts on follows from the readings of 否. Own reading
述而 Book 7 · Shù Ér 24
- 7.1 What "making" does Confucius disclaim: newly instituting rites and music, which needs the throne, or originating anything new? Who is 老彭: one man or two, and which? A worthy of 商, 彭祖, 老耼 with 彭祖, 老子 himself, or a place at 老子's side? Who does the likening, and in what spirit: Confucius himself, modestly, or the vulgar age? Own reading
- 7.2 What does 何有於我 say of the three practices: that only he has them, that they are easy, that he lacks them, that they are nothing special, or something else? And is 於 "in" or "like"? Mentioned
- 7.4 What occasion does 燕居 name: idle hours free of business, sitting at leisure (居 = to sit), or the period when Confucius held no office? What do the paired words 申申 and 夭夭 describe: one easy manner, reverence followed by harmony, the straightening and bending of his body, or his teaching and its effect on the disciples? Mentioned
- 7.5 Does 久矣 close the first exclamation ("my decline has been long") or open the second ("long has it been that I have not dreamed of the Duke of Zhōu (周公)")? Whether the dreams were real is decided under 夢. Did Confucius really dream of the Duke of Zhōu (周公) in his prime and stop when old, or, since a sage has no imaginings, is "not dreaming" a figure for grief? Where 久矣 belongs is decided under 久矣. The Duke of Zhōu (周公) was a sage who served as minister rather than ruler Own reading
- 7.7 What threshold for being taught does 行束脩以上 set: a meat-bundle gift brought, an age reached, a boy's gift, self-discipline, or small duties done? Mentioned
- 7.10 Why did he not sing on a day he had wept? Did he refrain because singing and weeping in one day is irreverent toward ritual bearing, or could he not sing because the day's grief had not faded? This decides the force of 不 (would not or could not), not the sense of 哭, 則 or 歌. Mentioned
- 7.11 In 子路's 則誰與, is 與 "to have along, be together with" (俱), "to grant, approve" (許), or, as the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) reports of 皇侃, sounded like 餘, in the level tone, rather than in its ordinary value? For 沈驎士 the sense also decides at whom the Master's reply is aimed. Own reading
- 7.12 Which post is the whip-holder's: any mean, lowly job; the ruler's charioteer, salaried at court; or the Rites of Zhōu (周禮) market officer who guards the gate with a whip? Mentioned
- 7.14 Is 三月 sound text, and if so, does it measure his time studying the 韶 or the time he went without tasting meat? What does the exclamation point at (the music's beauty, the 韶 itself, or 齊), and is it praise or grief? Mentioned
- 7.16 Does 疏 here mean vegetables (some copies write 蔬) or coarse grain? And if it is grain, is it 糲 rice or 稷, which 程瑤田 and 劉寶楠 identify as sorghum? 皇侃 explains the passage with two other sayings 鄭玄 says that wealth and rank not got by righteousness are, like the floating cloud, "not… Quoted
- 7.17 Does 加 mean "add (years to my age)", or does it stand for 假 "lend, grant", for 假 read as 暇 "leisure", or for 假 as 借 "borrow", the years meant for office? What does 五十 denote: Confucius's age, a miscopied 卒, a miscopied 吾 "I", the number fifty of the Changes (易), or "five or ten" years? Whose faults, and of what kind: personal faults of conduct, the faults of students of the Changes (易), errors in Confucius's exposition of the Changes, overshooting the mean, or the hexagram Great Excess (大過)? Quoted
- 7.18 Is 執禮 a third subject beside the Odes and Documents, with 皆 covering all three? Or does the first sentence end at 詩書, so that 執禮 opens a new one and 皆 covers everything he said at rites? The sense of 執 is decided under 執禮 and the sense of 雅 under 雅言. 焦循's joining of the chapter to 7.17 is under 雅言. Mentioned
- 7.19 Why did 子路 give the Duke no answer? Could he find no words for the Master, or did he hold back because of what the Duke asked or wanted? Mentioned
- 7.21 Is 不 the plain negative, or a misread 示 "to show", so that the sage displayed these things in order to correct what disturbs the primal qi? What kind of speaking does 不語 deny: speaking of these topics, answering questions on them, debating them, or raising them oneself? Does 怪力亂神 name four separate topics, or two pairs, "prodigious strength" and "disorderly spirits"? This decides the grouping and scope of the objects; the kind of speaking denied is decided under 語. Own reading
- 7.22 Is 行 "walking together", three men going in company, or "conduct", the 行 of 言行? Is 之 in 改之 the companion who falls short, whom I draw up with good and so reform, or the not-good, which I correct? What are 善者 and 不善者: good and bad points in anyone's conduct, a good man and a bad man, or what the companions approve and dislike? Whose fault 改之 corrects is decided at 之. The Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本) and the Táng stone classics (唐石經) read 我三人行, "when I and two… Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) records the question why the number is three, not two Own reading
- 7.26 Is the 聖人 Confucius cannot see an enlightened ruler, or a sage, the highest grade of virtue above the 君子? 程樹德 reports that 何晏 read all four grades of the chapter as rulers, but 何晏's own note covers only this first saying. Does 善人 name a good man, one of moral worth, or a teacher, with the second saying turning from the ruler to the teacher? 王闓運's "this speaks of the teacher" (此言師) covers the whole second saying. 程樹德 reports that 何晏 took all four grades as the Son of Heaven and the lords. 程樹德's remark that 13.11's 善人爲邦百年 must still be read by position rests on another passage and decides nothing here. 皇侃 describes the man of constancy as one who, "though unable to do good, holds to what is… 亡 here stands for 無, "to lack", as 皇侃 glosses it Own reading
- 7.27 What did the Master refuse to use? A great line hung with many hooks, a rope hung with nets across the current, or is 綱 a miswriting of 網 "net"? 黄式三 finds three explanations of 弋, shooting with a cord Besides 孔安國's "roosting bird" (宿鳥), which 朱熹 repeats, 皇侃's Subcommentary (皇疏) records an… Quoted
- 7.28 Is the 作 done without knowing the composing of writings and doctrines, or any action at all? What does one record from seeing much: the good, as with hearing, or everything seen, good and bad? Next to what knowing: the born knower's, true knowledge of principle, the composing sage's, or the mind's own innate knowing? 識 here means "to record" (記), as 朱熹 glosses it Own reading
- 7.29 What can the Master not vouch for: the man's conduct of former days, or what he will do after he departs? Mentioned
- 7.30 When I desire 仁 and it "arrives", is it a near way reached by practicing it, the mind's own virtue found present when sought, or is the desire itself 仁 and its arrival? Mentioned
- 7.35 Is the "praying" Confucius says he has long done his habitual conduct, which already accords with the spirits, or actual prayer, so that his reply refuses outright a rite that was not his to use? Mentioned
- 7.36 皇侃 says that the man who is insubordinate and overrides others "will certainly be harmed… Quoted
- 7.37 Does 戚戚 describe the small man's worry and fear, or a cramped, shrunken bearing set against the gentleman's breadth (蕩蕩)? Mentioned
- 7.38 Who is warm yet stern: Confucius himself (子), or, in 皇侃's text, "the gentleman" (君子)? Own reading
泰伯 Book 8 · Tài Bó 11
- 8.1 What "empire" did 泰伯 yield: one he foresaw for 昌, a mere state named from 周's later rise, a hundred-li state that utmost virtue could make an empire, 商's empire, which he would not take (so that 讓 is declining to take rather than ceding one's own); or, for 程頤, none, since he yielded 周 on the empire's account; or, for 歸有光, simply the state, "state" and "empire" being interchangeable names? 仲雍 went into hiding with 泰伯, yet only 泰伯 is praised Quoted
- 8.4 In 皇侃's Subcommentary (皇疏), someone asks why the text writes 言曰 and does not simply name… Mentioned
- 8.6 Is 與 the final particle 歟, so that 君子人與?君子人也 is a question and its answer? Or is it the conjunction "and", so that the words form one clause, "a gentleman-man and a gentleman", in a text without the second 人? 陸德明's text has 君子也, without the second 人, and notes that one text has it Own reading
- 8.11 What is "the rest" that is not worth looking at: the talent and excellence themselves, or the rest of his conduct? Mentioned
- 8.13 Is 善 a verb meaning to make one's own Way good (perfecting it through learning), a verb meaning to love (好), matching 好學, or the moral good set against evil, kept to even unto death? (守死 is read alike by all three.) What do 危 and 亂 name? For 包咸, disorder (亂) is regicide and parricide, and danger (危) is its omen. For 朱熹, disorder is misrule, and danger is the peril in which a man in office must give his life. Both take 不入 as declining to go there from outside and 不居 as leaving. Own reading
- 8.16 What does 吾不知之 say: that Confucius cannot make these men out, that the sage declines to pry into them, or that he rejects them outright? Mentioned
- 8.17 Do both clauses concern one object, either learning still being pursued or learning already held? Or does 如不及 reach for the new while 失之 guards what is already learned? Mentioned
- 8.18 What does 不與 deny? 舜 and 禹's part in seeking the throne, their concern with it once held, their handling of affairs in person, their claim to an achievement that was all 堯's (王闓運), or Confucius' share in their age? Mentioned
- 8.19 Does 蕩蕩 describe the breadth and reach of 堯's virtue, or a formlessness that leaves nothing to name? Mentioned
- 8.20 Who is the woman counted among King Wǔ's (武王) ten: the Cultured Mother (read as his mother 太姒), his wife 邑姜, no woman at all, or is the text 有殷人焉, "a man of 殷"? Which age was richest in talent? It turns on whether 際 is the 堯–舜 juncture or "after 唐 and 虞", and whether 於 means "compared with", "than", "in" or "and". The old texts write 參 for 三 here Quoted
- 8.21 Are the 溝洫 禹 toiled over the ditches of the well-field farmland, or his draining of the land's small waters into the rivers so the people could settle: flood work, not farm works? Mentioned
子罕 Book 9 · Zǐ Hǎn 20
- 9.1 Does 罕 mean "seldom", or is it a loan for 軒, "openly, manifestly", so that the line says he spoke of these things openly? What kind of speaking was rare: taking these up in teaching, saying of men that they had them, or raising them unprompted? Is 利 a good, "the harmony of what is right" (Heaven's benefiting of things), or profit and gain set against rightness? Are the two 與 "and", listing 命 and 仁 with 利 as things seldom spoken of, or a verb or preposition ("grant to men", "side with", "follow", "together with") that changes how 命 and 仁 stand to 罕言? In 皇侃's list, the Master does not grant humaneness to 子路 and 冉求 in 5.8, or to the Chief… Own reading
- 9.4 Whether 絕…毋 describes the Master as wholly without the four, records him forbidding them to learners, or says he cut off the "do not" itself. (What each fault means is decided under 意, 必 and 固.) 皇侃 takes up an objection Quoted
- 9.6 Which state's Grand Steward put the question to 子貢: 吳, 宋, 陳 or 魯? In 不多也, is Confucius saying a gentleman ought not to be versatile, or only that he need not be? Quoted
- 9.8 Which 知 Confucius disclaims, and whether "I have none" is modesty, a denial of holding back, or a literal statement of emptiness. What the two ends are: the matter's extremities (end and beginning, root and branch), the moral poles good and bad, or opposed extremes between which the mean is found. Mentioned
- 9.10 In 見之, does the Master see the three kinds of person, or is the man presented to the Master (見 as in "the followers presented him" (從者見之)), set against 過之, the Master passing him? (俞樾 also takes the first 見, in 子見, to hold both senses.) When he passes them, does 趨 mean that he quickens his pace, or that he goes up to them? Own reading
- 9.12 Whose 臣 did 子路 make of the disciples: a great officer's household retainers, a ruler's ministers befitting the Sage, or the "lesser retainers" of a lord's funeral rites? Is the 閒 of 病閒 a gap in the illness, the 閒 of 安閒 "at ease", or a word read in the departing tone? (The first two both claim the note "read as the character stands" in the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) and in 朱熹.) Own reading
- 9.13 Is 沽之哉, said twice, an assent, "Sell it!", or a rhetorical question, "How should I sell it?", declining to put the jade up for sale? Each reading takes both 沽之哉 the same way. Mentioned
- 9.14 Which peoples are the nine Yí (九夷): the 夷 of the east at large, the 夷 under 楚 near 陳 and 蔡, or small states by 魯 that had sunk to 夷 ways? (Who the gentleman is is decided under 君子.) Mentioned
- 9.15 What did setting the music right correct, and so what is the 雅 and 頌's "place": the Odes' order, their class and rite, the tones they are sung to (with 雅 and 頌 still the poems), pitch alone (with 雅 and 頌 not poems at all), or their use in performance? Own reading
- 9.16 What does 何有於我 say of these duties: that he cannot manage them, that they are all he has, that there is no self in them, since all men have them, or, spoken in reverse, that the men of his day neglect them? Is 不為酒困 a fourth duty in the list, or the point of all three clauses before it: not being overcome by wine at court, at home or in mourning? 馬融 glosses 困 as "thrown into disorder" (亂) 皇侃 also records an anonymous account (一云) Own reading
- 9.17 鄭玄 glosses 逝 as "to go" (往): all that goes is like the river's flow. But what is it that goes, and is the line a lament or praise? The years of a life, the unbroken flux that is the Way's substance, or the water's unfailing onward flow held up as a model? Quoted
- 9.20 Whose slackness does 不惰 deny: the Master's in speaking to 回, or 回's in receiving the words? And if 回's, is it slackness in hearing or in practice? Own reading
- 9.21 Is 進 顏回's continuing progress in cultivation, or the daily showing of his exemplary conduct, with no further growth implied? Mentioned
- 9.22 What do the stages of sprout, flower and grain stand for: a life cut off early (顏淵's), learning that stops short of completion, or literary flower without the fruit of conduct? 宦懋庸 says the exclamation 有矣夫, "there are such cases!", shows that such cases do not… Quoted
- 9.23 Does 聞 mean being heard of in the world (repute), or having heard the Way? Who knows, and what is set against what: the young against Confucius as he is now, the young's future against today's hopes for them, or the days to come against today as a warning? Own reading
- 9.24 Does 巽與 describe the words as gentle and deferential, or is 與 a verb, "to grant", so that 巽與之 means granting him approval with deference? Mentioned
- 9.26 Does 匹 in 匹夫 come from husband and wife being matched as a pair, or from the silk measure in which one 兩 makes one 匹? Own reading
- 9.27 Is 忮 harm one does to others, or harm that befalls oneself? Is 求 coveting gain, or demanding completeness of others? Are the ode lines the Master's own citation in praise of 子路, or the start of a separate record of the lines 子路 recited? Own reading
- 9.28 Is 後彫 withering only a little, the pine and cypress little harmed when great cold kills the other trees? Or withering late: they do wither, but new branches come before the old leaves fall? 皇侃 quotes Master Lín (琳公) 何晏 takes 歲寒 as "a year of great cold" (大寒之歲), when all the other trees die Quoted
- 9.29 Which anxiety is the benevolent man free of: fretting over being encroached on by others, since he encroaches on no one, or anxiety with no object named, kept away by his settled inner virtue? 知 is the word for wisdom here 繆協, quoted by 皇侃, says the brave man "sees what is right and does it, and does not fear… Own reading
鄉黨 Book 10 · Xiāng Dǎng 21
- 10.1 皇侃 says this book, from here to its end, records Confucius's conduct through his life 皇侃 says the Son of Heaven's domain had its 鄉 and 黨 inside the suburbs (郊), and its 遂 and… Quoted
- 10.2 Does 與與 describe a composed bearing that hits the mean, or his never forgetting to face toward the ruler? Quoted
- 10.3 What gait does 躩 describe: a wheeling, circling gait (盤辟), or quick steps (速)? Does 襜如 say that his robe swung front and back as he bowed, or that it stayed neat? Mentioned
- 10.4 Whose place did he pass: the ruler's empty standing place at court, the ministers' ranked positions in the courtyard, or, at a state mission, the host ruler's place in the temple courtyard? 鄭玄's note, "where the ruler bows", is claimed for all three. Does 升堂 mean going up onto the hall itself, or only mounting the steps of the hall stair, as 宋翔鳳 argues for an usher? Is 出 his coming away from the audience by stepping down from the hall, or his going out of the temple gate after each rite of a mission, a heading for the clauses that follow? Is the place he resumed the ruler's empty place, passed on entering, or his own station among the officials? The Summary of the Rules of Propriety (曲禮) gives the same rule for grandees and officers… 沒 here means "to exhaust, go to the end" (盡) 賈公彥's subcommentary to the Rite of Knights Meeting (士相見禮) says a commoner seeing the… Own reading
- 10.5 Which tablet does the envoy hold: his lord's own commission tablet (命圭), or a carved tablet (瑑圭) of lesser measure used on missions? Is 享禮 one rite, the presentation of gifts that follows the mission, or two: the presentation (享) and the host's entertaining the guest with sweet wine (禮)? By the Rites of Zhōu (周禮), 皇侃 says, a duke's jade token from the king was the huán tablet… The tablet itself was light The gifts laid out at the presentation were called the courtyard display (庭實) For the presentation the envoy held the bì disc (璧), not the guī tablet (圭) The private audience came on another day, after the public rites, when the envoy brought… Own reading
- 10.6 What color is 緅: a pale red of one dipping used to trim mourning robes, or a near-black of five dippings, of the dark class? On what occasion was the white robe over fawn fur worn: at court ceremonies, or in a year of calamity, robe and skirt all white? What dress is the yellow robe over fox fur: the dress of the year-end 蜡 sacrifice, or the leather-cap (韋弁) dress of war and missions? Which day is 吉月: the first of each month, any day of auspicious rites, a miscopy of 告月 (the temple court, or, for 俞樾, the officials' notice of the coming new moon), or the New Year month? Is an outer robe put over the unlined 葛 cloth before he goes out, or is the 葛 cloth itself worn outermost over an under-robe, brought out to show? Is 帷裳 the curtain-cut skirt of court and sacrificial dress, so that other skirts are tapered, or curtains themselves, 殺 meaning sewing with the seam hidden? 紅 is not the correct red, 赤, but its intermediate color Compare 17.18, where the Master says he hates purple for taking the place of vermilion… 絺綌 is cloth woven from 葛, the kudzu vine, 孔安國 says The Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本) and several other old texts, the Ashikaga edition (足利本)… 緇 is pure black, 玄 dipped once more in black Black robe over lamb's fur was a feudal lord's dress for the daily audience, 鄭玄 says, and… Whether the white robe over fawn fur was Confucius's own dress is disputed Compare 3.17, where 子貢 wants to do away with the sheep offered at the new-moon… Own reading
- 10.7 Is the 明衣 a cloth robe slipped on after the fast's bath while the body dries, the cloth garment worn next to the skin during the fast, a garment put on over the outside (俞樾), or, for 江聲, a garment left by one's parents? This decides which garment the 明衣 is; whether 明衣 and 布 instead make one phrase, the fast's bathing cloth, is decided on 明衣,布. Is 布 the material of a garment called the 明衣 ("a 明衣, of cloth"), or do 明衣布 make one phrase naming the fast's bathing cloth? Quoted
- 10.8 What is the 食氣 that meat must not overcome: the force of the grain (氣 as "nature"), the grain ration (氣 read as 餼), or the other dishes of the meal? Is 沽 "to buy", in parallel with 市, or does it describe the wine itself: wine brewed only a night or two, or poor wine? Is 市 "bought in the market", or a corruption of 𠂔 (胏), so that 市脯 is dried meat with the bone in? Is 厭 in the departing tone, "dislike" (he did not object to fine rice and finely cut mince), or in the level tone, "eat one's fill"? On the level tone, is fineness no condition of his eating his fill, or did he not eat his fill even of fine food? Both clauses turn on the same word. What makes the meat "not 正": cut out of square, jointed or set out against the ritual rule for the victim's parts, or slaughtered by an improper way? Each reading takes both 割 and 正 its own way. The 皇侃 and 邢昺 recensions put the line "at fasting he must change his food" (齊必變食), now in… 失飪 is missing the measure of raw and cooked, so that food is underdone or overdone Own reading
- 10.12 劉寶楠 gathers the mats named in the ritual texts Quoted
- 10.13 What is the "villagers' drinking": which rite, if any, or, reading 鄉 as 饗, pressing people to drink? By the rites a man used a staff at home at fifty and in the village at sixty Own reading
- 10.14 Which seasonal 儺 was the villagers' rite: the great 儺 of the twelfth month, or the spring 儺 of the third month? (The 魯 text's 獻 is called the same graph as 儺 in antiquity by 錢坫, a near-sound error by 陳鱣 and 阮元 and perhaps a loan by 劉寶楠. No one argues that it changes the sense.) The Rites of Zhōu (周禮) puts the 儺 in the charge of the 方相氏 Own reading
- 10.15 What 問人於他邦 describes: Confucius exchanging formal diplomatic inquiries with the ruler of a neighboring state, or sending a gift with his inquiry to a person, not a ruler, in another state. Own reading
- 10.17 Was the burnt 廄 Confucius's own household stable, or the state stable of 魯, the ruler's? Does 不 negate 問馬 ("he did not ask about the horses"), close the Master's question as 否 ("hurt or not?"), or stand alone as the reply "No", after which he asked about the horses? Quoted
- 10.18 The offering (祭) came before a ceremonial meal 鄭玄 says the attendant eats first at the prince's offering "as though tasting the food for… Quoted
- 10.19 皇侃 names the visiting ruler as Duke Āi (哀公) of 魯 In ordinary times, 毛奇齡 says, a gentleman always slept with his head to the east The court robe was laid over him Quoted
- 10.20 Confucius set off on foot, and his men yoked the carriage afterwards and followed him… Quoted
- 10.21 The same saying appears in 3.15 Quoted
- 10.24 Does 居 mean being at home, or sitting? 崔適 argues that 寢, only one part of home life, cannot be paired with home life as a whole. Is the word 容, formal bearing, or 客, the graph 陸德明 gives? The variant changes what he refrained from at home. 皇侃 says a man should sleep "lying aslant and slightly bent" (眠當欹而小屈), which 劉寶楠 takes to… Mentioned
- 10.25 Does 褻 mean someone seen often, or a meeting at leisure? The mourner, the man in the ceremonial cap and the blind man also appear in 9.10, and 朱熹… 皇侃 gives the reason for the courtesy Quoted
- 10.26 Did he not turn to look behind him (不內顧), or, in the text without 不, did he keep his gaze within bounds (內顧): ahead no farther than the yoke, to the side no farther than the hub? 皇侃 glosses 疾 here as "loud and hurried" (高急) Pointing from a high carriage would confuse those below (爲惑下人也), 皇侃 explains Own reading
- 10.27 Is 梁 a bridge on the hillside, or 粱, the millet the pheasant was eating as Confucius walked in the hills? What the Master's 時哉 says: that the pheasant has its season while men do not, "so it is", or a warning that its moment is running out. What Zilu did to the pheasant: served it up as food, set out food to snare it, seized it, or raised his hands in salute. What 色斯 means: a person's look that is seen, people's eyeing of the bird, or one word for the speed of rising. Whose rising and settling the opening clauses describe: Confucius's own conduct, a bird in general held up as a model, or the hen pheasant itself. What 嗅 was, and so who rose at 作: Confucius smelling, sighing or going through the three ritual urgings to eat (侑), or the pheasant smelling, crying, spreading its wings or glancing in alarm. The pheasant was anciently called an upright, stubborn bird (耿介之禽) that holds to death… The Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) reads 時哉 once, and notes that one text… Own reading
先進 Book 11 · Xiān Jìn 22
- 11.1 Who are the "earlier" and "later" to rites and music (先進, 後進): generations of officers, men studying, ages of antiquity, the Master's disciples, or men who reached office by different roads? Are "rustics" and "gentlemen" Confucius's own description of the two cohorts, the labels his contemporaries gave them, or the classes that rites and music reached in each age? Own reading
- 11.2 Which gate had none of the 陳–蔡 companions reached: the gate of office, the gate of better times, the Sage's gate of learning, or the Master's own door, where they no longer were? Mentioned
- 11.3 Are the ten named here only the disciples who were with the Master at 陳 and 蔡, or the finest of all his disciples, each set under his strength? An old text cited by the Supplement to the Collation of the Seven Classics (七經考文補遺) opens… Mentioned
- 11.4 皇侃 says a sage's teaching needs worthy men to draw it out Quoted
- 11.5 Does 間 mean disputing the family's praise, or finding fault? And if it means finding fault, is the fault found with 子騫 himself or with his parents and brothers? Own reading
- 11.6 包述, quoted by 皇侃, compares this match with 5.1, where Confucius gave his own daughter to… Mentioned
- 11.7 Duke Āi (哀公) asks the same question in 6.3 and gets a longer answer Quoted
- 11.9 Whether the cry says Heaven really is ruining Confucius, by taking the mate and helper it gave him, or says only that 顏淵's death was as though he himself had been undone, a figure of extreme grief. The repeated cry is read the same way. Mentioned
- 11.10 Is 慟 grief that goes beyond due measure, or a change and stirring of the countenance? The commentators apply it to the first 慟 and carry it to 子慟矣 and 有慟乎. 皇侃 places the scene at the 顏 home 繆協, also quoted by 皇侃, says the Sage does not err by going too far Quoted
- 11.12 What is 子路 asking about death: what lies ahead beyond this life, or how to meet death rightly? Do the two replies refuse 子路's questions, or answer them by pointing through men and life to ghosts and death? (What "life" and "death" mean is decided on 生 and 死.) Own reading
- 11.13 Does 誾誾 describe 閔子騫's centered correctness? Or, read as 齗齗, does it describe his unbending insistence on what is right? Does 侃侃, said of 冉有 and 子貢, mean genial and pleased (a loan for 衎衎)? Or does it mean firm and upright? Is 樂 genuine, so that the Master was pleased and then spoke (曰 or 子曰 lost before the remark)? Or is it a corruption of 曰, so that no pleasure is recorded? 朱熹 quotes 洪氏 that the Book of Hàn (漢書) has "said" (曰) before this line The prediction came true Own reading
- 11.15 The Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本), the Ashikaga edition (足利本) and other old texts read "Yóu's… 馬融 says 子路's playing "did not accord with the Yǎ and the Sòng" (不合雅頌) 皇侃 says Confucius knew 子路 "would surely not die of old age" (必不得以壽終), so he kept checking… 皇侃 takes this gate as "the gate into the deep recesses of sagely virtue" (聖德深奧之門), not… Quoted
- 11.16 Does 猶 make going too far just as faulty as falling short, since both miss the mean, or set the two level as endowments, neither ranked above the other? 師 is 顓孫師, known as 子張 商 is 卜商, known as 子夏 Own reading
- 11.17 Is 富 wealth, or "heavy" (厚), said of levies? On 翟灝's "heavy" reading, 周公 stands for the Duke of 周's statutes and levy rules. The other readings take 周公 as a person, and which Duke of 周 they mean is disputed too. Which Duke of 周 is the standard of comparison? 翟灝, who reads 富 as a heavy levy, takes 周公 to stand for the Duke's statutes and levy rules instead. Own reading
- 11.18 Is Zengzi's 魯 slowness of mind, or plain substance outweighing refinement? Is Zizhang's 辟 crookedness that glosses over faults, a polished manner without sincerity, or one-sidedness? Is 子路's 喭 the old binome 𠯘喭, hard and fierce conduct wanting in bearing, or 諺, coarse vulgarity? Mentioned
- 11.19 What 回 is near to: the sage's Way; by the Changes' parallel, the knowing of the incipient that only a sage has; or, for 蘇秉國, accepting the decree, which 賜 is said below not to accept. Whose 命 子貢 did not accept: the Master's teaching, Heaven's decree, a ruler's grant of rank or pay, an official commission to trade (俞樾), or, for 韓愈, the principle of nature and decree. One account in Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) takes the two words apart Commentators differ on whether this clause praises 子貢 or faults him Quoted
- 11.20 Does the reply describe the good man, who does not merely (or need not) follow the old tracks yet does not enter the chamber, or set a condition: if he does not tread the tracks, he cannot enter either? If it describes him, does he go beyond the tracks by founding something new, or need no tracks because of himself he does no evil? What Zizhang asked is decided at 之道. What did 子張 ask: the conduct by which a man counts as good, the course a good man should take, or (if 之道 is an interpolation) simply about the good man? Own reading
- 11.21 Is 與 the question particle (歟), with the passage joined to 11.20 and naming three kinds of good man? Or is it the verb "side with, approve", making this a separate saying against judging men by their talk? Whether 色莊 is a virtue or a façade is a separate question. Mentioned
- 11.22 What is it that one hears of and acts on: a matter of relieving the needy, or any right course of action? Mentioned
- 11.24 Whether 不可則止 means the minister leaves office when his remonstrance is refused, or that the ruler's wrong is checked and harm stops. Mentioned
- 11.25 Whom does 夫佞者, "those glib ones", point at: 子路, for his ready retort, or the glib officeholders of the age, whom 子路's reply was attacking? This also decides whether 子路's reply defends his choice of 子羔 or condemns the age. Mentioned
- 11.26 Does 乎爾 mean "than you", or does the clause end at 乎, with 爾 "you" opening the next clause? In 毋吾以也, is 以 "on account of" (do not hold back because I am older) or "employ" (no one employs me)? What dress is 端章甫: the court dress of the daily audience, an assistant's ritual cap, or, with 端 read as 冕, a crown? Does 與 mean that Confucius approves of 點, or that he is with him, sharing his aim? Is 也與 a real question put by 曾皙, or the Master's own rhetorical question, meaning "it was a state"? (The same holds for 唯赤則非邦也與.) Does 如 add a second occasion, the lords' audiences with the king, or point to 會同, a meeting of two rulers, as one of the temple's affairs? What is Dian describing: bathing and taking the breeze on a spring outing, a rain sacrifice, an offering of food, or going along the river? 皇侃 takes 莫春 as the third month of the 夏 calendar The Old Ceremonial of the Hàn (漢舊儀) has seventy-two dancers 雩 is the sacrifice to pray for rain Own reading
顏淵 Book 12 · Yán Yuān 14
- 12.1 What do 克 and 己 mean here: restraining one's person, overcoming selfish desire, reproaching oneself, taking a charge upon oneself, or, for 俞樾, being able (克 = "can" (能)) to bring one's person back to ritual? The question is the same for both occurrences of 克己. Mentioned
- 12.2 Does the maxim add a second matter, reciprocity, to the reverence shown in the two similes before it? Or is it Confucius's explanation of those similes, so that the answer is one teaching? This also decides what the similes illustrate. Do 大賓 and 大祭 name the Son of Heaven's own rites, the lords' court audiences and the 禘 and 祫 sacrifices? Or do they name a ruler's fine gathering with his ministers and a sacrifice of the state? Own reading
- 12.3 Is the benevolent man's halting speech all of his speech, or only his speaking about benevolence? The same question governs the reply: are 為之 and 言之 doing and speaking of 仁, or doing and speaking of anything? What is 訒: speech that is hard and held back, or speech halted because one cannot bear to say it? Own reading
- 12.5 Is 司馬牛's "I alone have none" said while his brothers still live but are doomed, so that he counts them as already lost, or after their revolt, when they had already fled or died? Is the Heaven with which wealth and rank rest the starry sky, whose star-images fix a man's rank, or the spontaneous course of the times one meets? Both sides take 命 alike, as the endowment fixed at birth. 皇侃 links this passage to 12.4, where Confucius told 司馬牛 that the gentleman does not… Quoted
- 12.6 What makes an accusation 膚受: is it only skin-deep, taken in skin-deep by the hearer, built up like grime on the skin, deep enough to reach the marrow, or pressing urgently on the body? The same question applies to the repeated 膚受. 朱熹's reading also makes 愬 the complainant's own grievance. Is 遠 a second quality beyond intelligence (lofty virtue), a foresight beyond intelligence that cuts slander off before it starts, or the far reach of the same intelligence named in the first clause? Own reading
- 12.7 Does 去食 mean the people going without food, at the risk of death, or the state forgoing its own grain by cutting outlays and levies? In 民無信不立, is 信 the people's own good faith and 立 their standing, or the government's being trusted by the people and 立 the state's standing? In the earlier 民信之 all take the people as trusting the ruler. 李充, quoted in 皇侃's subcommentary, cites Confucius's "hear the Way in the morning and die… Own reading
- 12.8 Do the two 猶 clauses (文猶質也,質猶文也) state 子貢's own thesis, that ornament and substance are equal and need each other? Or do they restate 棘子成's view, which the simile of the hides then refutes? The same holds for the second 猶. Is 惜乎夫子之說君子也 one clause, regretting how 棘子成 speaks of the gentleman? Or does 君子也 judge his words to be a gentleman's? 王引之 takes 以 here as "to use" (用) and 為 as a particle, so the phrase asks what use… 夫子 here is 子貢's address to 棘子成, as 皇侃 explains Own reading
- 12.9 What was the 徹 system that 有若 urges? All agree it took one part in ten. They differ on how it was raised: as pooled tillage, as 鄭玄's blend of gong and zhu, or as a tenth of the private fields with no public field. The Duke's 徹 in his reply is the same word. Whether 二 means two tenths is decided under 二. The Spring and Autumn Annals (春秋) records under Duke Xuān's (宣公) fifteenth year "the… Mencius names three systems Quoted
- 12.10 Is wishing a man's life or death itself the delusion, since fate decides it, or does the delusion lie in loving and then hating the same man? Quoted
- 12.12 Is 片言 one party's plea, heard without the other side's, or half a statement: the few words 子路 speaks, which men accept before he finishes? Does 宿 mean "in advance", so that 子路 made no promise beforehand, or "kept overnight", so that he never let a promise wait to be kept? Taking 片言 as one party's plea: is 子路 the judge who can settle a case after hearing one side, or the party whose own plea is enough for a judge to settle it? Own reading
- 12.20 Is 慮 thought or intent (馬融's "intent and thought" (志慮), 皇侃's "think of" (思)), or short for "on the whole" (無慮)? Both read 以下人 alike. 程樹德 calls 俞樾's view quite right but says 馬融's note is not mistaken either, and keeps both. The commentators gloss the Master's 達 (here and in the three 達 that follow) in ways that… Quoted
- 12.21 包咸 says the Rain Altar (舞雩) had "an altar, a cleared plot and trees" (壇墠樹木), so one could… Quoted
- 12.22 What had 樊遲 failed to grasp, and why: only the point of 知人, how all-embracing love and discriminating knowledge fit together, or the method of practicing both — or was the trouble his times, when hereditary ministers kept rulers from appointing the men they knew? Does "make the crooked upright" (使枉者直) speak of humaneness, so that the reply covers both 仁 and 知, or is it only the effect of knowing others? The readings differ on how the crooked are made upright: transformed, or spurred by the choice of the upright. 朱熹 says 子夏 marveled because the words embrace more than wisdom (歎其所包者廣,不止言知). Did the inhumane actually go far away, with the humane coming in their place, or were they transformed so that none were left, as though gone? The same question holds at the second 遠. Reading 遠 as transformation does not settle whether 使枉者直 is humaneness or wisdom. Own reading
- 12.23 蔡邕 uses this saying in his Discourse on Correct Association (正交論) The 皇侃 recension (皇本) and the Korean edition (高麗本) read 否, "if not", for 不可 Mentioned
子路 Book 13 · Zǐ Lù 18
- 13.2 In 焉知賢才, is 仲弓 anxious that he cannot know all the worthy men of his time (朱熹 supplies 盡), or does he ask how he can tell who the worthy are? (程子's charge that the question shows a narrow heart judges 仲弓; it is not a reading of 知.) 皇侃 says 仲弓 was about to go to 費 as steward of the 季 family's fief (將往費爲季氏采邑之宰) Quoted
- 13.3 What 名 does Confucius mean to rectify (and so the later 名): the names of all affairs, written graphs, or the titles confounded in 衛's succession? Under the graphs reading, 言 (in 言不順 and the rest) becomes written sentences. How he would have rectified them, by installing Prince Yǐng (公子郢) or by reconciling father and son, is a dispute of method, not of the words. Own reading
- 13.4 In 樊遲's request, is 稼 (with 圃 after it) the farmer's craft itself, farming as an art for teaching and governing the people (毛奇齡 adds that 學 was anciently also "to teach" (教)), or the Agriculturalist school's books? The reply's 焉用稼 follows the same choice. Mentioned
- 13.10 期 here means one full round of the year, and is the word also written 朞 可 here means "it would do", and no more 皇侃 ties both periods to the calendar Quoted
- 13.11 Are 殘 and 殺 two things (cruel men to be overcome, executions to be dropped), or is 殺 = 虐, so that 勝殘去殺 is one idea: acts of cruelty overcome and removed? Mentioned
- 13.14 Which court 冉有 was withdrawing from: the ruler of 魯's court, or the Jì clan's (季氏) private court. Quoted
- 13.15 What does 幾 mean here, at its repeat and in both 不幾乎: "near", "expect", or "end in"? Does 其幾也 belong to the denial ("a saying cannot be so 幾 as this") or stand alone, granting that something comes near? The repeat reads alike. Mentioned
- 13.16 皇侃 reads the two clauses as condition and result Quoted
- 13.18 Is 直躬 a description, "upright in his own person", the personal name of an upright man named 躬 (鄭玄's text reads 直弓), or a 楚 term for an upright man, used as his byname because his name was not handed down? 皇侃 says the Duke of Shè (葉公) meant to boast to Confucius (欲自矜誇於孔子) The Outer Commentary on the Hán Odes (韓詩外傳), New Arrangements (新序) and 皇侃, quoting the… Quoted
- 13.20 Is 果 resoluteness in doing what one sets out to do, or the completion of what is done? Does the text call the man of sure word a 小人, small in capacity, or should it read 之人? Mentioned
- 13.22 In 不可以作巫醫, is the man without constancy the one who cannot serve as shaman or physician, or the patient whom no shaman or physician can treat? Does 巫醫 name the shaman and the physician, the one dealing with the spirits and the other entrusted with life and death? Or is it one term (醫 being 巫) for those who divine, saying what the 卜筮 in the Black Robes (緇衣) version of the saying says? 崔適 equates the two wordings only in what they say of the inconstant man and does not say what 巫醫 denotes, so he takes neither side here. In 不占而已矣, who fails to divine? Either the Changes give no prognosis for a man without constancy, or he himself does not consult the prognostications. Quoted
- 13.24 皇侃 records another reading, an anonymous "one account" (一通) Mentioned
- 13.25 Is 說 "to please" (悅), with others trying to win the gentleman over, or 說 "to speak", the gentleman's own speech, or 說 "to persuade"? The same question governs the other five 說 in the passage, and with it who acts in 說之不以道. Own reading
- 13.26 What 泰 means here and again in 不泰: a calm, untroubled ease, or "getting through" (通), letting what one knows and can do pass through to the world. Own reading
- 13.27 Does 剛 mean freedom from desire, or hard strength, a will that does not bend? Is 訥 a natural slowness and dullness of speech, or a deliberate holding back of one's words? (黄式三's objection that 程子 wrongly takes all four qualities as natural endowments is decided here.) Quoted
- 13.28 Do 切切 and 偲偲 picture mutual pressing and reproof, or earnest, careful encouragement? The same doublets recur in the closing sentence. Mentioned
- 13.29 Is "seven" two triennial reviews done and a third begun, short of the full nine years (皇侃); a round odd number for a long time that is also the third and last review, the end of the term (吳嘉賓); or an error for "five"? What 亦可 concedes is under 亦. Is 亦可 a qualified "will also do", allowing seven years where nine is the full term, or "too ... can", saying that a good man, like the sage of 13.10, can complete his teaching in about twice the sage's time? The count itself is under 七. Own reading
- 13.30 What does the people's want of teaching consist in: drill in arms, moral teaching, or both? Mentioned
憲問 Book 14 · Xiàn Wèn 30
- 14.1 皇侃 gives examples on each side Quoted
- 14.5 Is the archer 羿 the lord of 有窮 who usurped the 夏 throne and was killed by his minister, or the 羿 of 堯's time who shot down the suns? Is 盪舟 pushing a boat along over dry land, or fighting from boats and capsizing the enemy's? Who Ao is, is decided at 奡. Own reading
- 14.6 Is 仁 humaneness, so that even a gentleman sometimes falls short of it? Or is it, as 韓愈 argues, a copying error for 備 "complete"? His emendation covers the second 仁 too. Mentioned
- 14.7 Is 勞 something done to the one loved, cheering and urging him on, or the lover's own toil of heart, anxiety on his behalf? Mentioned
- 14.9 Who took 伯氏's town, and for whom: 管仲 himself, rightly, as a confiscation, or Duke Huán (桓公), who took it to give to 管仲? What 駢邑 is: the town of Pián; 駢 as the Bó clansman's personal name, with 邑三百 his fief; or no place at all, but names registered side by side? 孔安國 and 鄭玄 make the Bó clansman (伯氏) a grandee of 齊 Quoted
- 14.11 朱熹 explains why the post would be easy Quoted
- 14.12 Who speaks the words after this 曰, and does this 曰 belong in the text? The Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) glosses it as Confucius speaking again, yet cites 胡寅 for 子路, adding "whether this is so is unclear". 臧武仲 is 臧孫紇, a grandee of 魯 The 荀子 says the men of 齊 "feared Zhuāngzǐ of Biàn (卞莊子) and did not dare pass through… 顏延之, quoted by 皇侃, ranks the second list below the first Quoted
- 14.13 What does Confucius doubt with 豈其然乎? It may be 公明賈's own account, that 文子 spoke, laughed and took only when it was timely, joyful and right; then 其然 and 豈其然 bear on one thing. Or it may be the earlier report that 文子 never spoke, laughed or took; then 其然 accepts 公明賈's correction. 皇侃 also records an anonymous account (一云) that reads 其然 as surprise. Own reading
- 14.15 The Discourses on Salt and Iron (鹽鐵論) quotes this saying and adds Mentioned
- 14.16 In 九合諸侯, is 九 a real count of nine assemblies, a graph standing for 糾 "superintend", or a round number meaning "very many"? Own reading
- 14.17 Do the common man and woman who keep petty faith and hang themselves unknown stand for 召忽, who died for Prince Jiū (公子糾), or for nameless people? Is 溝瀆 a common noun, a ditch, or the name of the place where 子糾 was killed (笙瀆, 生竇, 句瀆)? 管仲 had once shot at Duke Huán (桓公) and hit his belt hook The Comprehensive Discussions in the White Tiger Hall (白虎通), quoted by 皇侃, explains the 匹… Own reading
- 14.19 皇侃 takes up the question of how a duke without the Way had good ministers Quoted
- 14.20 Is speaking without shame (不怍) a sign of real substance within, or of brazen big talk? Or should the graph be 作, "rise", as 盧辯's quotation has it? And so what is the hard "doing" (為之): building that substance, carrying out one's words, or acting at all? 程樹德 only suggests that 盧辯's 作 may be a miscopying of 怍. Mentioned
- 14.23 What do 上達 and its counterpart 下達 reach, and does 達 mean attaining, advancing or understanding? On 上達 the readings mostly agree. They split on 下達: a fall into profit and the base, or a lower but lawful attainment, a trade or a technical art. That also decides who the 小人 is. Own reading
- 14.24 What do "for oneself" (為己) and "for others" (為人) contrast: practice against mere talk, inner attainment against reputation, one's own person against borrowed learning, or governing oneself against governing others? Mentioned
- 14.25 Does Confucius's cry 使乎 (said twice) praise 蘧伯玉's envoy or censure him? Is 使乎!使乎 the cry 使乎 said twice, or 使乎使, "envoy of envoys", closed by an exclamatory 乎? Both readings praise. Mentioned
- 14.26 Is the 位 that the gentleman's thought does not leave his office and allotted duties, or the resting place of his nature, which 焦竑 equates with the "resting in its place" (止其所) of the Changes (易), stillness amid thought? Only the second 位 is read two ways. The first 位, in the Master's saying, is office for everyone. Quoted
- 14.27 Is 恥其言而過其行 one matter, shame that one's words outrun one's deeds (而 read as 之, as the Huáng Kǎn recension (皇本) has it), or two, holding back in words and going beyond in deeds? Quoted
- 14.29 Is 我 Confucius speaking of himself (with 夫, where the text has it, a clause-opening particle), or is 夫 "the other" and 我 "oneself", making the line a general maxim? Whether 方 means comparing or faulting is decided at 方人. Mentioned
- 14.31 Is 不信 the other man's want of good faith, or other people's distrust of oneself? Does 是賢乎 praise the man of prior awareness or ask whether he can be worthy? And is he the same man who does not anticipate? Mentioned
- 14.34 皇侃 gives a practical reason against requiting injury with kindness Quoted
- 14.35 What does 下學而上達 describe: studying human affairs and coming to know Heaven's decree; plain self-cultivation that of itself reaches what is above; Confucius's work on the Spring and Autumn (or on all the classics) reaching up to Heaven; or a commoner's praise and blame reaching the kingly way of governing? 馬融 says Confucius "was not employed in his age, yet did not resent Heaven" (孔子不用於世,而不怨天) Quoted
- 14.36 Does 於公伯寮 end 景伯's first clause (季孫 misled by 公伯寮) or begin the next (as for 公伯寮, I can have him exposed)? This also settles whether 惑志 stands complete by itself. Own reading
- 14.37 Does 其次 (said three times) step down to lesser grades of worthy man, or only down the scale of withdrawal, with no ranking of merit? Are 作者 those who took up the withdrawals just described, or men who acted and created? Which seven men they were is decided under 七人. Own reading
- 14.38 Is 石門 a gate in the walls of the 魯 capital, or just the name of a place? The 皇侃 recension (皇本) repeats 石門 before 晨門, "the dawn gatekeeper of Stone Gate", and so… Quoted
- 14.39 Is the 己 of 斯己而已矣 the reflexive "himself" (he trusts only in himself; for 俞樾, he should act only for himself), or 已 "stop" (then he should simply give up)? The texts differ: the Tang Stone Classics and the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) have 己, 朱熹's text 已. What is the bearer 果 in: bold and rash in mocking Confucius without knowing his purpose, or resolute in forgetting the world? Or is 果 "truly" (誠), as 俞樾 reads it, Confucius's own sigh rather than a retort? In 末之難矣, what is or is not hard, and for whom? Is there nothing hard in living as the bearer does, is it hard to find among such men one who would not mock, or is 末之 an exclamation of its own on how small the bearer's view is? 何晏's note denies 難 ("no difficulty, because he cannot understand my Way") without saying what is not hard, so it decides none of these. The 難 "rebut" reading is only an anonymous alternative in the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文). Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) compares the bearer to 伯夷 and 叔齊, who held King Wǔ's (武王)… Deep water that wets the clothes stands for an affair past saving (以喻事不可救) Own reading
- 14.40 王夫之 says the rite had lapsed Quoted
- 14.42 Who are the 人 that self-cultivation settles: one's friends and kin, those like oneself, others as against oneself (graded out to all), or one's ministers as against the people? The readings also differ on the scope of 百姓: all others, or the common people. Is the clause about what 堯 and 舜 actually found (even they found it hard, or fretted over it), or is it an unreal condition: they would have been troubled had they tried to govern by self-cultivation, which they did not? What does 病 say 堯 and 舜 felt about settling the people: that it was difficult even for them, or that they still fretted over it, never deeming it complete? Mentioned
- 14.43 Is 俟 "to wait", so that 原壤 squatted waiting for Confucius? Or, read with 夷 as one rhyming binome close in sound to 倨肆, does 夷俟 mean squatting insolently? Everyone takes 夷 as the squat. In 長而無述, is 述 "to be spoken of", so that nothing in 原壤 is worth mention? Or is it, paired with 效 "to emulate", to follow or carry on a model, so that grown he had nothing emulated or carried on? Did Confucius strike Rang's shank with his staff? Or is 叩 a scribal error, so that he only pointed at it? 朱熹 says that 原壤 sang when his mother died (母死而歌), and calls him "presumably of Lǎozǐ's… Own reading
- 14.44 What does the questioner's 益者 ask: whether the boy, by carrying messages, is seeking to better himself, or whether he has already advanced in learning and so is favored by Confucius? Both readings take the Master's 求益 alike. Whether Confucius employed the boy at all is decided at 將命. 黨 is a district of five hundred households, 皇侃 says A youth sits in the corner and has no seat 先生 here is a grown man (成人), 包咸 says By ritual one walks behind a man of one's father's age (父之齒隨行) and in echelon with one of… Own reading
衛靈公 Book 15 · Wèi Líng Gōng 27
- 15.2 The 皇侃 and 邢昺 recensions begin this passage with "the next day he left" (明日遂行), and 高誘… Mentioned
- 15.3 What does Confucius's "No" (非也) deny: that he learns much at all, or only that learning much and keeping it in mind is his way? What is the one, and what is it to thread? Readers name a single root, one principle reached by long study, a method of learning, practice, reciprocity with others, innate knowledge, or unmixed virtue. Whether 非也 denies learning much is decided at 非. 皇侃 says people of the day saw how much Confucius knew, and held that he had learned many… Quoted
- 15.4 Does 知德者鮮 say that 子路 himself is scant in knowing virtue, or that men who know virtue are few? 陳澧 rests the question on what 者 refers to. Own reading
- 15.6 What does 參 mean in 見其參於前? The candidates are standing thick (森), the team's side horses (驂), joining oneself (相參), squarely facing one (直), or, by emendation to 厽, piled up (絫). Which part of the chariot is the 衡 that the virtues lean on: the yoke (軛), or the crossbar at the carriage front (式)? Own reading
- 15.8 皇侃 restates 知者 as "a man of wisdom" (有智之士), with the graph 智 Quoted
- 15.9 Is 志 in 志士 resolve, a mind set on the good, or a loan for 知/智, so that 志士 is a man of knowledge set beside the humane man? What does "completing humaneness" complete: the humaneness in one's own person, kept from damage by a right death, or a humane work done for the people? 張栻 and 朱熹 take the 仁 harmed in 害仁 to be this same inner 仁. 孔安國 restates the clause with 而 in place of 以 繆播, quoted by 皇侃, says that where humaneness dwells there is in itself no danger Own reading
- 15.10 Do 賢 "worthy", said of the great officers, and its counterpart 仁 "humane", said of the officers, differ in sense, or are they one sense, the change of word being mere variation? What the figure of sharpening one's tools stands for: the tools as the worthy friends a man works with, or as his own talent, which others sharpen. All read 利 "sharpen" and 器 "tools" literally, and the variant 厲 for 利 leaves the sense unchanged. 鄭玄's notes on the Odes (詩鄭箋) define 工 as "doing one's work well" (善其事曰工), the words of… 皇侃 explains the two verbs by rank Quoted
- 15.11 Which governing does 顏淵 ask about: the state of 魯 as it then was, the whole world spoken of as "a state", or the realm of whoever succeeds 周 as king? 皇侃 reads every item of the answer as a rite 魯 already kept. Is 夏之時 the 夏 calendar, whose year begins in the 寅 month, or the 夏 seasons by which hunts, sacrifices and sowing were timed, which all three dynasties kept beside their own year-head (正朔)? Does 韶舞 name one piece, 舜's music the 韶, or two pieces, the 韶 and King Wǔ's (武王) 武, with 舞 read as 武? 俞樾 reads 則 as "take as a model" (法) as part of the same argument. Does 鄭 name the state of 鄭, or describe the sound itself: "repeated", busy playing, or "deviant", an unsound tone? Whether the repeat in 鄭聲淫 means the 鄭 odes is a separate question. 馬融 calls the 殷 carriage the great lù (大輅) and quotes the Zuǒ Commentary (左傳) 周 kept the music of six ages, by 皇侃's list Own reading
- 15.12 Is 遠 "far" in space or far in time? The paired 近 splits the same way: trouble right at hand, or trouble soon. Own reading
- 15.13 The same saying appears in 9.18, without the opening 已矣乎 皇侃 reasons from the opening 已矣 that the Master "had long since not seen" such a man… Quoted
- 15.15 Does 厚 stand for "blame oneself heavily" (厚責), with 責 supplied from the following 薄責, or does 自厚 mean making one's own virtue substantial, so that blame is no part of the word's sense? Mentioned
- 15.16 One clause or two? Either 不曰 governs both cries and 者 marks the man who does not say the doubled cry, or the line breaks after the first 如之何 and 如之何者 marks the point at which the cry is raised (孔安國: the calamity already formed). 梁章鉅 takes the quotation in the Luxuriant Dew of the Spring and Autumn Annals (春秋繁露), "a man who does not say 'What is to be done, what is to be done?'" (人而不曰「如之何,如之何」者), to be presumably the source of the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注); 程樹德 reads 陸賈's 無如之何者 as one clause too. Mentioned
- 15.17 劉寶楠 calls this chapter a warning given in the Master's family school (夫子家塾之戒) 難矣哉, "hard indeed", says such men will come to nothing Quoted
- 15.20 Is 名 the name a person makes, his repute among others, or the posthumous title (諡) conferred at death? Is 稱 read chēng, "be spoken of" (the gentleman frets at dying with no name), or chèn, in the departing tone, "fit" (he frets at dying with a name beyond his reality)? Mentioned
- 15.22 Is the 群 of 群而不黨 a gathering of gentlemen among themselves, who do not help one another for private ends (黨 = "help" (助)), or living in harmony among people at large, without cleaving to a party (黨 = "partisan cleaving" (阿比))? What 不黨 forbids follows from whose company it is. Mentioned
- 15.23 李充, quoted by 皇侃, explains the second half as "consulting the grass cutters and firewood… Mentioned
- 15.25 Who made the trial, and on whom? 包咸, 皇侃 and 朱熹: Confucius tests the man he praises. 毛奇齡: the chapter is about raising and setting aside officials, who are tried before use. 包慎言 (drawing on 班固's Book of Hàn (漢書) treatise): the three dynasties already made the trial on this people, and the next sentence states it. Whose straight way is it, and what is "straight"? 馬融 and those after him: the Three Dynasties' rulers, in dealing with this people. 陳天祥: a separate saying in which the people walked it themselves. 郭象: the straight way is leaving all to the world without intent. 簡朝亮: the people's own, born straight and shown in their impartial verdicts on men, today as of old. The Records of the Three Kingdoms (三國志), in the biography of 胡質, quotes the line as 必有所試… 皇侃 also records a further account (又通) that isn't his own Quoted
- 15.26 Is 史 the scribe, the officer in charge of writing, or, as 宋翔鳳 suggests, the writing of graphs itself, of the kind of the 漢 史書 and 史篇, rather than a chronicle? Both sides take 闕文 as a blank left for a graph that was not known. Is the horse clause a second practice Confucius saw, a simile, a figure for a fault, or the very 闕文 the first clause names (劉安世), and so what does 今亡 say? Those who take it as a practice also split on its purpose: training or sharing. 葉夢得's suspicion, reported by 翟灝, that the seven characters are interpolated is a textual question, not a construal. 亡 here means "there is none" (無) Quoted
- 15.29 What does 弘 mean in 人能弘道: to make the Way great, or both to hold its every pattern within and to widen it out? The second 弘 (the Way cannot make the man great) is read alike by all; the two-sense reading is stated only for the first. Mentioned
- 15.31 The Variant Punctuations of the Classics (經讀考異) records two ways to break the line Mentioned
- 15.32 Is 在其中 the result of each course, so that the plowman who does not study goes hungry and the learner is fed by emolument, or only what can befall within it: plowing, the means to food, may fail, and emolument comes with learning unsought? The same question covers the repeat in 祿在其中矣. Mentioned
- 15.33 What does 之 refer to in 知及之 and in the 之 that follow 守, 得, 失 and the repeated 知及之, 仁能守之? Is it the office gained, the moral principle, or the people? 朱熹 also takes 涖之 and 動之 as the people. Whose action is 動 in 動之不以禮? Is it the ruler moving and rousing the people, or his own movement and rest, which ritual must carry through? 李充, quoted by 皇侃, names a failing for each of the first three Own reading
- 15.34 張憑, as 皇侃 quotes him, says that to call a man a gentleman is to credit him with "the… Mentioned
- 15.35 The clause names no verb. In what does the people's relation to benevolence exceed their relation to water and fire: their need of it, or their distance from it? Mentioned
- 15.36 張憑, as 皇侃 quotes him, says the way to be humane is "putting others first and oneself… Mentioned
- 15.37 Is 諒 the petty good faith that the gentleman need not keep, or is the character a miscopy of 讓 "yield"? 皇侃 also records an anonymous account (一通云) in which the gentleman's Way is never incorrect but he cannot make others trust it; no named figure holds it. The same word is in 14.17 Quoted
- 15.38 Is 敬其事 reverent, scrupulous care for one's duties, or, with 敬 read through its component 茍 "urge oneself on", pressing on with them urgently, set against putting the pay last? 孔安國's "first exhaust your strength" (先盡力) and 朱熹's "be reverent in my affairs" (敬吾之事), which keeps the word itself, do not decide it. Mentioned
季氏 Book 16 · Jì Shì 11
- 16.1 Is the 止 of 不能者止 declining office when a man measures himself and falls short, or leaving a post he holds when he cannot do his part? Is 相 an assistant or minister in general, one who supports his lord, or specifically the attendant who leads a blind man? Whose screen wall is it, and so where does the 季氏's real danger lie: with the 季氏's own retainers inside its house, or with the ruler of 魯 inside his court? Which 季 head is meant is decided under 季氏. Are the escaped tiger and wild ox and the ruined tortoise-shell and jade a general image of a keeper's fault, or does each image name an event? A 蕭牆 is the screen (屏) a ruler set up at his gate Own reading
- 16.2 Does the 國命 that the retainers seize take in rites, music and punitive expeditions (蔡清's Elementary Guide to the Four Books (蒙引), as 馮景 reports it), or only the state's instructions and commands, short of rites, music and campaigns (皇侃; 馮景 adds that such commands never pass the state's border)? Is 議 the commoners' criticism of the government, which they have no cause for when the Way prevails (孔安國), or planning state policy, which under the Way commoners take no part in because worthies hold office (方觀旭)? 方觀旭 also takes 庶人 more widely, to include clerks, runners and even retainers. The tallies halve, says 皇侃 陪 means "doubled" (重), says 馬融 Own reading
- 16.3 Whose four generations: which four 季氏 heads (is 悼子 counted; 文子 or 桓子?), or four dukes, 成公 to 定公? The ducal five are decided at 五世. Do the Three Huán (三桓) here name all three houses descended from Duke Huán (桓公), or the Jì clan (季氏) alone? 祿 leaving the ducal house means that rank and revenue were no longer granted by the ruler The "therefore" (故) applies the rule of 16.2 Quoted
- 16.4 What 便辟 names: chiefly what 辟 stands for (避, 譬, 嬖 or 僻), with 便 as clever (馬融) or practiced (朱熹, 黄式三): one who sidesteps what others dislike, a deft maker of comparisons, a ruler's favorite, a man practiced in deportment but not upright, or one habituated to excessive deference. 善 here means "good at" Quoted
- 16.7 What age does 老 "old age" name: fifty and above, or seventy? 方觀旭's case for seventy rests on reading 既衰 as decline already finished, against "at fifty decline begins" in the Royal Regulations (王制). By the rites, says 皇侃, a man is in his prime at thirty and sets up a household… 皇侃 explains why the old are greedy Own reading
- 16.8 What is the 天命 the gentleman stands in awe of and the small man does not know? Is it Heaven sending fortune and calamity on those who follow or defy it, or, in the Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注), the correct principle Heaven confers? 毛奇齡's Correcting the Errors in the Four Books (四書改錯) also attacks the 宋 habit of glossing 天 as "principle" (理). Are the 大人 simply men in position, rulers who govern, or men of virtue: 何晏's sage, or 朱熹's man of rank, years and virtue? 陳鱣 and 程樹德 object that the second repeats the 聖人 named next. Mentioned
- 16.9 皇侃 names the four grades 困 here is being stuck Quoted
- 16.10 How are 色 and 貌 told apart? Are they one's demeanor at rest and one's demeanor in motion, or what shows in the face and the bearing of the whole body? 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, sums up the last thought with the words of 14.13 Mentioned
- 16.12 Whether 餓 names 伯夷 and 叔齊's fast to death on 首陽 in refusal of 周's grain, or the hunger of their flight after yielding their state (宦懋庸 adds that 餓 says hunger, not death). What 斯 "this" in 其斯之謂與 points to: virtue, as the two cases show it; a saying lost from before the line; or the lines of 16.11 on seeking one's aim. The 德/得 variant in 民無德而稱焉 depends on the answer. 伯夷 and 叔齊 were the two sons of the lord of Gūzhú (孤竹君之二子) Own reading
- 16.13 What the gentleman's "keeping his son at a distance" consists in: no special favor, so that father and son keep apart (皇侃); ritual reserve, not estrangement (司馬光); or not teaching his son himself (范甯). Whether Chen Kang was right to conclude it at all is a judgment of him, not a sense of the word: 孫奇逢 calls the conclusion self-regarding (私心), and 黄式三 says it comes from suspecting that the sage had a secret teaching he never passed on. 陳亢 asks because 伯魚 was Confucius's son The subject of 獨立, "stood alone", is not written 皇侃 explains why the Odes make speech possible Own reading
- 16.14 In the Summary of the Rules of Propriety (曲禮) of the Book of Rites (禮記), the wife calls… 皇侃 says the people add 君 because the ruler himself says plain 夫人 小君, "lesser lord", is the title of the ruler's wife, 孔安國 says, and 寡 makes it modest… Quoted
陽貨 Book 17 · Yáng Huò 17
- 17.1 皇侃 paraphrases 時 with 伺, "to watch for" They met as Confucius was coming back from the bow (拜竟而還), says 皇侃 Quoted
- 17.2 Which nature the line means: one lodged in physical stuff beside a purer root, the nature Mencius called good, natures graded from sage to fool, or one neither good nor bad. What "near" measures: men's natures against one another, the nature's nearness to goodness, or feeling's nearness to the nature. The same construal carries to 相遠. 顧炎武 says the word 性 first appears in the Book of Shāng (商書) 孔安國's one comment on the line is "the gentleman is careful about what he practices"… Own reading
- 17.3 Who the highest wise are: those born highest in endowment, or anyone who grasps the good and holds to it till death, however slow-witted. Who the lowest stupid are: the bad by nature, the dull-witted by endowment who are not the wicked, or those who cut themselves off from the good whatever their stuff. 李顒's measure by conduct is at 上知. Whether 不移 says the lowest stupid cannot be moved, or only that they are not moved, by their own refusal, though they could be. 程樹德 notes that 朱熹's Collected Commentaries on the Analects (集注) leaves out 韓愈's three… 知 here is the word for "wise" that other texts write 智 Quoted
- 17.4 In 割雞焉用牛刀, what is the ox-knife? For 孔安國 it is the great Way, more than governing a small town needs. For 繆播 it is 子游's own talent, fit for a state but spent on 武城. Every reading takes the chicken as the small town. Older texts write 莧 for 莞 Mentioned
- 17.5 Is 徒 "for nothing", so that the summoner must mean to employ him, or, for 翟灝, "merely", the Master saying he would do more than curb 弗擾? 翟灝's reading assumes the 季氏 sent the summons (see 召). Promise or refusal, and which 東周? A 周 revived here in the east; the decayed Eastern 周, which with 其 or 乎 as denial he would not make; 成周, which with 爲 in the departing tone (as 鄭叔友 also reads it), "assist", he would help; a rival 周 he would not set up; King Píng's (平王) restoration; or 費 raised up as a new 周, as Kings Wén (文王) and Wǔ (武王) rose from 豐 and 鎬. Own reading
- 17.6 Whether 惠 (here and again in 惠則足以使人) is kindness bestowed on people, or according with their feelings. Mentioned
- 17.7 Does 欲往 record a real wish to answer the rebel's summons, or only the look of one, the Master never meaning to go? Where does the gentleman refuse to "enter": the wrongdoer's state, or his faction? Is the 匏瓜 a gourd that, not eating, can hang fixed in one place while a man cannot; a bitter gourd hung up and never eaten; or the Gourd star hung in the sky? (Whether the wish to go is real is decided under 欲.) 張栻 calls the saying 子路 once heard "the gentleman's constant rule for guarding his person"… Own reading
- 17.8 What harm is 賊, the beclouding of good faith loved without learning: father and son who do not know to cover for each other, injury done to things, or the lawless harm of keeping one's word without regard to right? Mentioned
- 17.10 Is 爲 to study the two 南, to expound them, or to carry their teaching out in conduct? The repeat reads the same. Compare 16.13, where 伯魚 hurries across the courtyard and Confucius asks whether he has… 牆面 means "facing the wall" (面向牆也), 皇侃 says Own reading
- 17.12 What is soft within the man stern in look: a fawning heart, so that he is a hidden flatterer, or plain weakness, so that he is a coward behind his severity? Is 小人 the common people, from whom the wall-boring thief is drawn? Or is it the morally petty, of whom the thief is one kind? 孔安國's and 皇侃's bare 小人 (a small man with a thief's heart, a small man stealing) decide neither. Is 窬 "to climb over" a wall, so that 穿窬 names two kinds of break-in? Or is it an opening (= 竇) that the thief bores through, so that 穿窬 is one act? Every reading takes 穿 as "bore through". The closing gloss in 皇侃's Subcommentary (皇疏), "窬 means a hole" (窬,竇也), comes after 江熙's words and may be his or 皇侃's. 皇侃 explains the likeness Quoted
- 17.13 What 鄉原 is. Is 原 the verb "trace out", 愿 "honest", 傆 "crafty", a miscopied 柔, or 原壤's surname? And is 鄉 the village, 向 "leaning toward", or "rustic"? Mentioned
- 17.14 Who casts off whom in 德之棄? Men of virtue may cast off the man who repeats on the road what he heard there (德 = the virtuous), he may cast off his own virtue, or (皇侃) both may be true at once. 陳天祥's "old subcommentary" (舊疏) is worded differently from Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary (皇疏) printed here and lacks its clause on casting off one's own virtue; 梁章鉅 replies by citing Huáng Kǎn's Subcommentary. 道 and 塗 both mean "road" 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, takes up the words of 14.24 皇侃 says that "learning got by memorizing questions is not enough to make a man a teacher"… Own reading
- 17.16 Is the ancient proud man's 廉 angularity, having edges and corners (馬融, 朱熹), purity and integrity (李充), or self-restraint, the sense 陳鱣 gives both 廉 and the 魯 text's variant 貶? 皇侃 records an anonymous alternative account (又一通) that pairs the clauses differently Mentioned
- 17.20 Whose man is the 將命者: an envoy 孺悲 sent to Confucius, or Confucius's own attendant who carries his words? Own reading
- 17.21 Is the first 期 the full year 宰我 proposes, read jī, or the set term of the three years' mourning, read qī? Both sides take the second 期 (期可已矣) as a full year, read jī. Who is the 君子 of 宰我's argument: the ruler in mourning, whose rites and music transform the people, or people generally, as in an old saying? The readings also split on whether the clause speaks of the three years' mourning or of any long neglect. Toward whom is 予 "not humane": his parents, whom he would not mourn three years, or the world at large, in approving the age's lapse of the rites? Own reading
- 17.24 What is 徼: filching others' ideas, spying things out, or (read as the 絞 of 鄭玄's text) pressing urgency? Who says 賜也亦有惡乎, and is it a question? Both readings give the three hatreds that follow to 子貢. (徐幹's Balanced Discourses (中論) quotes these hatreds as Confucius's words, and 蘇軾's letter to 韓 joins 惡訐以爲直 to Confucius's own. Those are quotations, not readings, and the variants section (考異) calls 蘇軾's a mistaken joining.) Confucius names four hatreds and 子貢 three 孫 here is the word also written 遜, "deferential" 皇侃 tells this apart from the Master's "brave but without ritual" 皇侃 says 訐 is exposing a man's private secrets to his face (面發人之陰私) Own reading
- 17.25 Whom does the pair name: women and petty men at large, or a household's maidservants and menservants? 朱熹 glosses only 小人 outright; his "menservants and maidservants" (臣妾) extends the saying to the women servants as well. Own reading
微子 Book 18 · Wēi Zǐ 7
- 18.1 What was the Viscount of 微's leaving: going over from 殷 to 周, quitting the court for his own fief, or quitting his post and fleeing? All read 去 as leaving; they differ on what the leaving was. (No one glosses the 之 of 去之 separately.) 箕子 was a kinsman of 紂 比干 was an uncle of 紂 皇侃 says each man did what fitted his place, and each place needed filling Own reading
- 18.4 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, applies the words of 10.27 to Confucius here Mentioned
- 18.5 Is 接輿 the recluse's own name, the style of a man named 陸通, or no name at all but "the one who met Confucius's carriage"? Is 已而 a lament that the age's disorder is already extreme and past mending, or a command telling Confucius to quit (已 = "to leave off" (去)), with 而 a mere particle? The repeated 已而 reads the same way. (The 魯 reading in the Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) has no named holder.) Is 殆 "in peril" or "held in suspicion"? Both readings take 今之從政者 as those who take part in government now; on the second they, Confucius among them, are suspected, as 子西 suspected him. Is the couplet about Confucius' own course, past and to come, or about the past and coming ages? And does the second line say he can still turn back, ask a question that expects no, or promise that the coming age can still be put in order (追 = "put in order" (治))? 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, explains the hurry Own reading
- 18.6 Does 桀溺 set two ways an officer may follow against each other, or invite 子路 to leave Confucius and follow him? (The second 從 reads alike.) Is 天下有道 a condition, "if the world had the Way", so 易 is changing the world; or "those in the world who have a way", with whom 丘 will not trade? Mentioned
- 18.7 What the old man carried on his staff: a bamboo basket, or a field implement for weeding. What 分 means in 五穀不分. What the old man did with his staff before weeding: leaned on it, stood it upright, or set it down (植 as the old graph of 置). Whether the old man presented his sons to 子路 during his stay, or 子路 only saw them on his return, with the clause moved after 至則行矣. Who speaks the closing words: 子路, leaving them for the old man's sons, or, with a 福州 manuscript's 子路反,子曰, the Master after 子路's return. What 大倫 refers to: the one great relation of ruler and minister, or the great human relations as a whole. Whom the old man's two lines describe (子路, Confucius, or himself) and whether their 不 negates. 拱, folding the hands, is the posture the Summary of the Rules of Propriety (曲禮)… 黍 is a glutinous millet Own reading
- 18.8 Is the 逸 of 逸民 "surpassing" (超逸), so people of outstanding integrity and conduct, or "left aside" (遺), so people without office? Is 夷逸 (here and at the second 夷逸) a personal name, one of seven recluses, or a description of 虞仲, "fled among the 夷", so that the list names fewer men? Is 朱張 the name of a recluse whose deeds were lost, a known man (王弼's 子弓, 金履祥's 周章), or no name at all but 譸張, "feigned madness", a label over others in the list? It bears on why the appraisals that follow never mention him. Does 放言 mean setting speech aside, no longer talking of the world's affairs, or giving free rein to speech? Is 廢 "to cast oneself aside", withdrawing from a disordered age, or should it be read 發, as in 鄭玄's text, "setting in motion"? Is it "in person they accorded with purity", or should 身 be 行, as in the Records of the Grand Historian (史記), with 中 itself meaning "person"? Does 無可無不可 describe Confucius's own course, with nothing fixed as allowable or not, or, as 江熙 reads it, his stance toward the recluses, which does not name how he himself differs? 柳下惠 is the man dismissed three times (三黜) in 18.2 鄭玄 explains the words Own reading
- 18.11 What does 士 say of the eight: that all became eminent officers, that they held only the rank of 士 below the great officers, or that they were recluses rather than men in office? Whether 伯适 is the great minister 南宮括 is a separate question. Mentioned
子張 Book 19 · Zǐ Zhāng 23
- 19.1 Book 19 holds only the disciples' sayings, with no words of Confucius, as 皇侃 notes Quoted
- 19.2 有 and 亡 are the world having this man or lacking him 陸德明's Explanations of the Texts of the Classics (釋文) reads 亡 in its usual sound (亡如字) Quoted
- 19.3 Whether the two rules apply to different kinds of association or of learner (two spheres, two stages, two temperaments), so that both stand, whether 子張's reply rightly faults 子夏's 拒, or whether 子夏's rule is the right one for friends and 子張's belongs to a ruler. A further question is whether 子張's 眾 and 不能 include 子夏's 不可者 (黄式三 says they do not). Mentioned
- 19.4 What are the "small ways": the rival schools' doctrines, useful crafts such as farming and divination, or skills and arts short of the great Way? 焦循's claim that the gentleman shuns clinging rather than the small ways turns on how he reads 泥. Mentioned
- 19.5 Is 知其所亡 daily learning what one has not yet heard or known, or daily recognizing, by self-examination, where one still falls short in the Way, principle, virtue and work? 皇侃 matches the two clauses to 2.11's "reviewing the old and knowing the new" (温故而知新) 亡 here means "not to have" (無) Quoted
- 19.6 Is 志 in 篤志 the will, so "firm in resolve", or the old graph for 識, so "keep thoroughly in memory"? Does 切 in 切問 name what one asks about, matters close to oneself (matching 近 in 近思), or how one asks: urgently, or earnestly and thoroughly? 黃式三 observes that wherever the text says "in it" (在其中), the thing need not be wholly so Own reading
- 19.7 Is 肆 the workshop where artisans make their goods, or the market stall where goods are set out? Is 學 the gentleman's act of studying, or the school where he dwells, with a 居 understood to match 居肆? Does 致 mean the gentleman arrives at the Way, carries it to its utmost, or has the Way brought to him? 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, says skill is not inborn either Own reading
- 19.8 皇侃 says a gentleman's fault is an error, not done on purpose, so he corrects it once he… Quoted
- 19.9 李充, quoted by 皇侃, says people call these changes, but the gentleman himself does not… Mentioned
- 19.10 Is 厲 "to afflict" (病), so that the untrusting people think he is afflicting them, or is it read as 賴, "to rely on", so that they think he is relying on them? 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, says of remonstrance without settled trust Mentioned
- 19.11 Who or what are 大德 and its pair 小德 (which splits the same way): men of greater and lesser virtue, the great and small points of a man's conduct, or the sage and the worthy whom a learner approaches? Is 閑 "law, rule", or a barrier marking a limit that one goes out and in across? Own reading
- 19.12 Where the phrase breaks: does 小子 stand with 門人 as one phrase naming 子夏's disciples, or open the next clause, "the youngsters, at sprinkling and sweeping … will do"? What the root is that 子游 says the disciples lack, and whether 本 is the noun "the root" or the verb "trace it to the root". Does 孰, in both questions, ask which disciple can take the Way first and which will flag later, or which part of the Way is taught first and which later? The readings split likewise on whether 君子之道 is the great Way alone or its branch and root together. Whose weariness 倦 is: the learner's flagging, or the teacher's wearying of teaching; or is it no weariness at all, but the old graph of 券 "tally", or a corruption for a word meaning "teach"? What 區 means in the plant comparison: plants sorted by kind, plants raised each in its own plot, or the curled sprout that already holds the whole plant (the 區 of 區萌, which 王應麟 says is read like 勾). What the plants stand for, the Ways or the learners, is also disputed. What would be 誣 against the gentleman's Way: falsifying it by forcing it all on beginners, or (with the 憮 of the Book of Hàn (漢書), or 誣 in its root sense "add" (加)) taking it all in together? 馬融's note also takes 誣 as falsifying, which 焦循 rejects as not the word's root sense. 程樹德 finds 憮 workable but the received 誣 seemingly better, and calls 江聲's emendation of 憮 to 幠 forced; he does not choose between the senses. Own reading
- 19.13 皇侃 notes that the sayings of 子夏, eleven chapters in all, end here 馬融 explains the first clause in the words of 1.6 Quoted
- 19.14 What 而止 rules out: grief run to excess that harms the mourner (孔安國), or mourning carried past grief into ritual form and ornament (楊時, 朱熹). 朱熹 then faults 子游's 而止 itself as too lofty and as slighting fine detail. Quoted
- 19.15 Is 友 the noun, "my friend 張", or a verb, "I befriend 張", with 吾 as its subject? What is "hard" about 子張: his bearing, his talent, or the hard things he does, with 為 as the full verb "do"? Or is 為 a mere particle? 朱熹's "his conduct was too lofty" speaks of conduct but does not say how 為 is read. Who is "not yet humane": 子張, whom 子游 faults, or 子游 himself, who says he has not reached it? Own reading
- 19.16 Does 堂堂 describe 子張's imposing outward bearing, or the breadth of his virtue? Whether the line praises or faults his humaneness is a separate question; 王闓運 denies the line disparages his 堂堂 but does not gloss the word. In 難與並為仁, does 並 mean practicing humaneness together with 子張, so the line faults him as hard to join in it, or standing level with him, so that none can match his humaneness? 皇侃 notes that the fourth of his five parts of the book, the sayings of 曾參, begins here… Quoted
- 19.18 皇侃 says that men of that age, within the three years of mourning, all changed the… The 皇侃 recension (皇本) and the Korean edition (高麗本) have no 能 after 難, so the clause reads… Quoted
- 19.19 What 情 is and what one must not be pleased at: the facts of an offense and one's skill in getting them, or the plight of the scattered people and the punishing of them. The Mèng house (孟氏) was a junior ministerial house of 魯, 皇侃 says 皇侃 makes this a household post Quoted
- 19.20 What is "the badness of the world" that all comes to 紂, and how does it reach him: as bad repute laid to his name, as the world's bad men gathering to his side, or as those men's evil counted as his own? 下流 is part of the question, because 物茂卿 takes dwelling in the lower current as 紂's being a haven for fugitives, where 朱熹 has the low ground where the streams converge, a figure for a man foul in fact on whom bad repute gathers. The answer also decides what 是 measures in the first sentence: the charges laid on 紂, or the disorder and evil his bad men brought. Quoted
- 19.21 皇侃 explains the simile part by part Quoted
- 19.23 Is 宮 the house or palace that the wall encloses, or is it itself an old word for a wall, so that 宮牆 simply means "enclosing wall"? How long is the 仞 that measures Confucius's wall: seven feet, as 包咸's note says, or eight feet, the same as the arm-span 尋? 皇侃 names the one man who found the gate Quoted
- 19.24 Is the reviler the one who makes his ignorance plain (見 "show"), or are discerning onlookers the ones who see it in him (見 "see")? Whose measure does the reviler fail to know: his own capacity, or the sage's? The Examining the Analects (論語稽) glosses 量 as "the allotment of high and low" and does not say whose. Own reading
- 19.25 Does 立之 "raising them up" mean setting up teaching, or setting the people up in their livelihood? The second 立 follows whichever sense the first takes. What does 動之 "moving them" refer to: setting the people to labor, or rousing them? 孔安國 only repeats the word (動之則莫不和睦), so his note decides nothing. What does 榮 mean, and whose state is it: the Master's own glory and honor, the people's delight in him, or a state of all the things of his age? All readings take the paired 哀 as mourning. 皇侃 supposes that 子禽 had seen Confucius "harried and not employed in his age" (栖遑不被時用) 孔安國 takes 得邦家 as becoming a feudal lord (諸侯), or a minister or grandee (卿大夫) Own reading
堯曰 Book 20 · Yáo Yuē 3
- 20.1 Is 天 in 天之曆數 Heaven itself, or (皇侃) "the heavenly seat", the throne? What is 曆數: the ordered succession of rulers, the prophetic registers that name 舜, or the calendar? Is 在 "rests in" (the succession lies in 舜's person) or, after 董仲舒, "examine" (舜 must examine his own person)? Is 允 the adverb "sincerely, truly", or, with 王引之, the verb "use"? To whom is the announcement made: the one God of Heaven, the Five Emperors of the 太微 stars, or (王闓運) a founding ancestor and 堯? Who are "the guilty" whom the speaker dares not pardon: any guilty men, 桀 in particular, the Four Villains (四凶, as 劉寶楠 reports 鄭玄), or (王闓運) 禹's father? In 朕躬有罪,無以萬方, is the clause "my guilt is my own: I will not let it fall on the myriad regions", or "the ruler's guilt is not caused by the people"? 孔安國's "the myriad regions have no part in it" fits either. Whose words are 謹權量 and the clauses after it: Confucius prescribing for later kings, or a record of what past rulers did? This governs the whole run of clauses that 謹 opens. Is 法度 institutions in general, or measures: measures of length alone (法 only filling out the phrase), or the pitch-pipes and the length measures as two items? Which lapsed offices are restored: any old office that had lapsed, or the offices in charge of the weights, measures and standards just named? Promise or warning? 困窮 can be "reach to the utmost" or "distress and want", and 永終 "long endure" or "end forever"; the readings pair them differently. Who is "God's servant", and what is not concealed: 桀 and his guilt, 湯 himself not hiding 桀's guilt, the worthy men 湯 will not keep hidden, or (王闓運) 禹? Did 周 receive a great gift from Heaven, or did King Wǔ (武王) make a great bestowal, and was that bestowal the enfeoffment of lords or a handout of wealth and grain? Was 周 rich in good men, or were good men the ones enriched? And who are the 善人: the ten capable ministers, worthy men, or the common people? Whose kin and whose men of 仁: King Wǔ's (武王) kinsmen set below 殷 worthies such as 箕子, the tyrant 紂's closest kin set below the house of 周's men of 仁, or (宋翔鳳) words of enfeoffment setting a man of 仁 such as 太公 above close kin? 堯 and 舜 are posthumous titles, as 皇侃 explains 四海, "the four seas", here means lands, by the old glosses that 閻若璩 defends 湯 gives his personal name, 履, because he is about to address Heaven, as 皇侃 explains 孔安國 explains the color of the 玄牡 皇侃 places these lines in the Great Declaration (泰誓) of the Documents (尚書), 周's harangue… 皇侃 describes the 逸民 as men "of outstanding ability and conduct, who do not serve"… 孔安國 gives a reason for each Own reading
- 20.2 Is 費 spending, so that he benefits the people at no cost to himself, or, for 錢坫, going against men's hearts, the same in sense as the 不怨 that follows? The two repeats of 惠而不費 go with it. Does 可勞 name the people fit to bear labor service, or the works fit to be labored at? 黄式三 counts choosing the task, choosing the man, and weighing the year and the season all as 擇. What is the 仁 he desires and gets (here and again in 得仁): humaneness completed in his own person, his nature and his office's duty, or humane government carried out among the people? Is 猶之 "all the same, in any case", the goods being due to be given anyway, or is 之 a miscopied 上, so the line speaks of the ruler above giving to men? Whom 有司 is set against is asked under 有司. Both readings take 有司 as a lowly clerk. Is he set against the ruler, grudging being a clerk's proper charge and not a ruler's way, or against the gentleman in office, so that the name disgraces him like cruel, oppressive and injurious? The sense of 猶之 is asked under 猶之. Are 眾 and 大 the gentleman's own wealth and rank, never turned against those with little or of low degree, or do 眾寡 and 小大 describe whatever he deals with, many or few, great or small? 孔安國 (he does not slight men for being few or small) and 殷仲堪 (many or few do not change his feeling) fit either side. 皇侃 says desire has many paths (欲有多塗) 子張 asks only what "beneficent without expense" means, yet the answer goes through all… Old quotations of this line lack the first 之 皇侃 explains this bearing with the words of 19.9 Own reading
- 20.3 What kind of knowing 知命 is: knowing that there is a decree, received from Heaven, and not striving against it, or knowing the decree by righteousness, letting rightness decide. What 命 is: the allotted lot of straits and success, or the nature Heaven confers on man. 黄式三 and 李顒 hold the two together. Whether 禮 here is the rites, ritual forms carried out in conduct, or "pattern or principle" (理). 江熙, quoted by 皇侃, says that one who cannot appreciate words cannot take another man's… Own reading
Connected
Named in this entry
Named in the entries for
- 皇本 Huáng Běn
- 江熙 Jiāng Xī
- 李充 Lǐ Chōng
- 王弼 Wáng Bì
- 范甯 Fàn Níng
- 孫綽 Sūn Chuò
- 繆協 Miào Xié
- 欒肇 Luán Zhào
- 顏延之 Yán Yánzhī
- 衛瓘 Wèi Guàn
- 繆播 Miào Bō
- 張憑 Zhāng Píng
25 more
- 袁氏 Yuánshì
- 蔡謨 Cài Mó
- 郭象 Guō Xiàng
- 周生烈 Zhōushēng Liè
- 沈驎士 Shěn Línshì
- 殷仲堪 Yīn Zhòngkān
- 顧歡 Gù Huān
- 熊埋 Xióng Mái
- 王朗 Wáng Lǎng
- 太史叔明 Tàishǐ Shūmíng
- 季彪 Jì Biāo
- 虞喜 Yú Xǐ
- 包述 Bāo Shù
- 梁覬 Liáng Jì
- 秦道賓 Qín Dàobīn
- 張封溪 Zhāng Fēngxī
- 褚仲都 Chǔ Zhòngdū
- 陸特進 Lù Tèjìn
- 袁宏 Yuán Hóng
- 樊光 Fán Guāng
- 季隨 Jì Suí
- 袁喬 Yuán Qiáo
- 仲突 Zhòngtū
- 論語釋疑 Lún Yǔ Shì Yí
- 論釋 Lún Shì
Same era Three Kingdoms to Sui · 220–618